TL;DR
This paper introduces "theory prime implicates," a novel generalization of prime implicates for knowledge compilation. This new approach allows for more efficient query answering from propositional knowledge bases by leveraging tractable theories implied by the knowledge base itself, leading to significantly smaller compiled representations compared to existing methods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Artificial intelligence systems often need to answer queries based on large knowledge bases. However, directly querying these knowledge bases can be computationally intractable, often taking exponential time. Knowledge compilation aims to solve this by transforming a knowledge base into an equivalent, but more efficiently queryable, form during a preprocessing step. While existing methods like prime implicates compilation offer improvements, they can still result in exponentially larger compiled representations. This paper addresses the challenge of creating knowledge compilations that are not only logically equivalent to the original knowledge base but also significantly more compact and faster for query answering, without sacrificing expressiveness.
Methods
The core of this paper is the introduction of theory prime implicates. This concept extends the standard notion of prime implicates by incorporating a "built-in" tractable theory, denoted by $\Phi$. Instead of just considering clauses implied by the knowledge base $\Sigma$, theory prime implicates consider clauses that are implied by $\Sigma$ given $\Phi$. This is formalized as $\Sigma \cup \Phi \models \pi$, where $\pi$ is a clause.
The authors propose a compilation function, $\text{COMP}_{\Phi}(\Sigma)$, which is essentially the set of theory prime implicates of $\Sigma$ with respect to a chosen tractable theory $\Phi$, along with $\Phi$ itself. The key idea is that by selecting a "good" tractable theory $\Phi$ (one that is implied by $\Sigma$ and allows for efficient query answering), the resulting compilation $\text{COMP}_{\Phi}(\Sigma)$ becomes "local" for clausal query answering. This locality means that answering a query $\pi$ involves checking a polynomial number of theory prime implicates against $\pi$, rather than exhaustively searching the entire knowledge base.
The paper also outlines an algorithm, $\text{TPI}(\Sigma, \Phi)$, for computing theory prime implicates, which adapts Quine's iterated consensus technique. Furthermore, it discusses strategies for identifying "good" tractable theories, including subsets of the knowledge base that are Horn clauses, binary clauses, or satisfy specific structural properties (like acyclic tied-chain graphs or bounded induced width).
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical contributions and uses examples to illustrate the concepts.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Theory Prime Implicates: The generalization of prime implicates by incorporating a tractable theory $\Phi$ is the central innovation. This allows for a more flexible and potentially more compact compilation.
- Locality for Query Answering: The theory prime implicates approach makes the compiled knowledge base "local," meaning queries can be answered by examining a subset of the compiled knowledge, significantly speeding up the process.
- Tractable Theories as a Lever: The effectiveness of the compilation heavily relies on the choice of a "good" tractable theory $\Phi$. The paper explores various classes of theories that can serve this purpose, suggesting that the choice of $\Phi$ can dramatically impact compilation size and query speed.
- Space Savings: A key advantage highlighted is the potential for significant space savings compared to standard prime implicates compilation, especially when the chosen theory $\Phi$ is much smaller than the original knowledge base.
- Complementary Approach: Theory prime implicates compilation is presented as complementary to existing techniques, offering a new tool in the AI researcher's arsenal for tackling intractability.
Key Results
- Equivalence Preservation: The compilation $\text{COMP}_{\Phi}(\Sigma)$ is proven to be logically equivalent to the original knowledge base $\Sigma$.
- Polynomial Query Answering: Query answering from a theory prime implicates compilation can be performed in time polynomial in the size of the compilation, provided the chosen theory $\Phi$ is tractable.
- Size Comparison: The size of theory prime implicates compilations is shown to be smaller than, and potentially exponentially smaller than, the size of prime implicates compilations in the general case.
- Experimental Evidence: Preliminary experiments on benchmark problems (diagnosis and qualitative physics) demonstrated substantial space savings for theory prime implicates compilations compared to prime implicates and other existing compilation techniques like FPI$_1$. For instance, in the "Adder" problem, the theory prime implicates compilation with a specific theory $\Phi$ resulted in 706 clauses, while the prime implicates compilation had 9700 clauses.
Limitations and Future Work
- Predicting "Good" Theories: A significant challenge is identifying "good" tractable theories that lead to optimal compilations. The paper proposes a heuristic search strategy but acknowledges that a polynomial-time procedure for finding such theories is unlikely.
- Empirical Validation: The authors emphasize the need for more extensive empirical validation to assess the practical applicability of the approach.
- Predicting Compilation Suitability: A key open problem is predicting whether a given compilation technique is well-suited to a particular knowledge base.
- Incremental Compilation: While the approach is amenable to incremental updates, the paper notes that even small changes to the knowledge base can sometimes lead to significant changes in the compilation.
- Exponential Growth Potential: Despite the savings, the paper acknowledges that, like other compilation techniques, theory prime implicates compilations can still be exponentially larger than the original knowledge base in some cases.
Summary updated