Abstract
Background: Recent genome-wide association studies (GWASs) have suggested several susceptibility loci of hepatitis B virus (HBV)-related hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) by statistical analysis at individual single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). However, these loci only explain a small fraction of HBV-related HCC heritability. In the present study, we aimed to identify additional susceptibility loci of HBV-related HCC using advanced knowledge-based analysis. Methods: We performed knowledge-based analysis (including gene- and gene-set-based association tests) on variant-level association p-values from two existing GWASs of HBV-related HCC. Five different types of gene-sets were collected for the association analysis. A number of SNPs within the gene prioritized by the knowledge-based association tests were selected to replicate genetic associations in an independent sample of 965 cases and 923 controls. Results: The gene-based association analysis detected four genes significantly or suggestively associated with HBV-related HCC risk: SLC39A8, GOLGA8M, SMIM31, and WHAMMP2. The gene-set-based association analysis prioritized two promising gene sets for HCC: cell cycle G1/S transition and NOTCH1 intracellular domain regulates transcription. Within the gene sets, three promising candidate genes (CDC45, NCOR1, and KAT2A) were further prioritized. Among genes of liver-specific expression, multiple genes previously implicated in HCC were also highlighted. However, none of the genes prioritized by the knowledge-based association analyses were successfully replicated in the independent sample. Conclusions: This comprehensive knowledge-based association mining study suggested several promising genes and gene-sets associated with HBV-related HCC risks, which would facilitate follow-up functional studies on the pathogenic mechanism of HCC.
Introduction
Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is a leading cause of cancer-related mortality worldwide, with chronic Hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection serving as a primary driver in many regions. While Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS) have successfully identified several genetic susceptibility loci, these individual single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) explain only a small portion of the disease's heritability. This "missing heritability" suggests that many risk-associated variants with small effect sizes remain undetected by traditional SNP-level analysis. This study addresses this gap by employing "knowledge-based" analysis, which aggregates weak individual signals into biologically meaningful units: genes and functional pathways.
Methods
The researchers utilized a multi-stage analytical pipeline to identify new risk factors:
- Meta-Analysis: Data from two existing GWAS cohorts (Qidong and Hong Kong) were combined to enhance statistical power.
- Gene-Based Association Analysis: Tools such as GATES and ECS were used to calculate the collective significance of all variants within a specific gene, allowing for the detection of associations that individual SNPs might miss.
- Gene-Set and Pathway Analysis: The LDRT method was applied to identify enriched biological pathways, such as NOTCH1 signaling and cell cycle regulation.
- Functional Annotation: Top candidates were evaluated using HaploReg and RegulomeDB to predict their impact on gene regulation or protein function.
- Replication: The study attempted to validate 21 top SNP candidates in an independent replication cohort of 1,888 individuals from Shanghai.
Results
Identification of Candidate Genes
The gene-based analysis identified four genes significantly or suggestively associated with HBV-related HCC risk:
- SLC39A8: Encodes the ZIP8 transporter involved in zinc and manganese homeostasis. Zinc deficiency is known to influence autophagy and tumor formation.
- GOLGA8M: Located in a genomic region prone to copy number variations and rearrangements, common features of cancer progression.
- SMIM31 and WHAMMP2: Also emerged as suggestive risk loci.
Additionally, the study highlighted genes with liver-specific expression, including PAH, UGT2B10, and UROC1, as potential risk factors.
Pathway Enrichment
Gene-set analysis prioritized two critical biological circuits:
- Cell Cycle G1/S Transition: A fundamental process in cellular proliferation.
- NOTCH1 Intracellular Domain Regulates Transcription: A pathway frequently dysregulated in various cancers. Within these pathways, CDC45, NCOR1, and KAT2A were identified as promising candidate genes.
Replication Challenges
Despite the robust discovery phase, the study faced a "replication gap." None of the prioritized genes were successfully replicated in the independent cohort. Only one SNP (rs17343667 in the EIF2AK1 gene) showed a nominal association, but it did not meet the threshold for strict statistical significance after correction.
Discussion and Limitations
The findings underscore the complexity of the genetic architecture of HCC. The failure to replicate findings in the independent sample is likely due to the small effect sizes of the identified variants and the limited sample size of the replication cohort. The researchers emphasize that while knowledge-based analysis provides a powerful tool for identifying biological leads, confirming these associations requires much larger international consortiums.
Furthermore, these results are primarily statistical. Future research must involve functional "wet lab" validation—such as gene knockout studies in liver cell lines—to determine if these candidate genes directly drive oncogenesis. Despite the lack of replication, this study provides a valuable roadmap of genes and pathways for future investigation into the pathogenic mechanisms of HBV-related HCC.
Summary updated