Knowledge and attitudes toward mild traumatic brain injury among patients and family members

Jian He, Zhongliang Chen, Jianjun Zhang, Xiao LiuFrontiers in Public Health 2024 · DOI

This study, published in Frontiers in Public Health, investigates the "Knowledge-Attitude-Practice" (KAP) gap regarding mild traumatic brain injuries (mTBI) among patients and their families. The researchers found significant deficiencies in understanding the psychological symptoms of concussions and identified that socioeconomic factors—specifically income and education—are primary drivers of how seriously families treat these "invisible" injuries.

TL;DR

Despite mTBI (concussion) being the most common form of brain injury, patients and their families harbor significant knowledge gaps, particularly regarding psychological symptoms and recovery assessment. The study highlights that targeted educational interventions are desperately needed, as positive attitudes toward recovery are heavily influenced by a person's education level and the specific cause of their injury.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI), often referred to as a concussion, accounts for over 80% of all traumatic brain injury cases. While "mild" in name, these injuries can lead to long-term cognitive, emotional, and physical deficits.

The success of mTBI management depends heavily on the patient’s and family’s adherence to recovery protocols (like cognitive rest and symptom monitoring). However, if the people responsible for care don't understand the risks or hold dismissive attitudes toward concussions, the clinical outcomes suffer. This paper seeks to quantify exactly where the knowledge gaps lie and which demographic factors predict a "suboptimal" attitude toward brain health.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study at Zhejiang Hospital, China, between July and September 2023. They employed a structured questionnaire based on the KAP model, which is a standard framework in public health for measuring how knowledge translates into attitudes and eventually into behavior.

Key methodological features included: * Quality Control: To ensure data integrity, the team used "trap questions" to filter out inattentive respondents and excluded any questionnaire completed in under 90 seconds. * Scoring System: Knowledge was scored on a 20-point scale (13 questions), and attitudes were measured on a 40-point Likert scale (8 questions). * Statistical Analysis: They used multivariate logistic regression to isolate the independent effects of variables like income, education, and the cause of injury on the participants' scores.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset generated from 573 valid questionnaires (culled from an initial 950 participants). The cohort was nearly evenly split by gender and primarily consisted of individuals aged 18–59. No external or pre-existing benchmarks were used, as the study aimed to capture a snapshot of a specific clinical population.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Invisible" Symptom Blind Spot: While most respondents (82.9%) correctly identified that a concussion is an mTBI, they struggled with the nuances of symptoms. Only 16.9% recognized nightmares as a psychological symptom, and only 50.4% identified memory impairment as a characteristic.
  • The Recovery Assessment Gap: Perhaps the most striking finding was that only 28.9% of participants knew that one of the best ways to assess recovery is simply to inquire about the patient’s feelings. This suggests a heavy reliance on "objective" physical signs (like stumbling) while ignoring the subjective emotional state that often signals lingering neurological issues.
  • The "Fall" Paradox: Participants who experienced mTBI due to falls were significantly more likely (OR = 3.588) to have positive attitudes toward care compared to those injured in sports or car accidents. This suggests that the context of the injury changes how seriously it is perceived; a fall may be viewed as a "medical event," while a sports collision might be dismissed as "part of the game."
  • Socioeconomic Predictors: Lower education levels (middle school) were strongly associated with less positive attitudes. Interestingly, a specific middle-income bracket (5,000–10,000 RMB/month) was negatively associated with both knowledge and attitude scores, suggesting that health literacy outreach may be missing this "middle" demographic.

Key Results

  • Knowledge Scores: The mean score was 11.00 ± 2.75 out of 20, indicating a mediocre level of baseline understanding.
  • Attitude Scores: The mean was 27.78 ± 4.07 out of 40. While generally positive, there was significant variance based on education.
  • Education Impact: Middle school education decreased the likelihood of having a positive attitude toward mTBI (OR = 0.378, p = 0.023).
  • Income Impact: Monthly income between 5,000–10,000 RMB was a negative predictor for both knowledge and attitude (β = -0.160, p = 0.026).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints:

  • Selection Bias: The use of online questionnaires may have excluded older populations or those without digital literacy.
  • Geographic Limitation: The study was confined to a single hospital in Zhejiang, which may not represent broader national or international trends.
  • Self-Reporting: Data is subject to recall bias, especially for those who suffered injuries months prior.

Future Work: The authors suggest developing "comprehensive, accessible mTBI education" programs tailored to different socioeconomic backgrounds. They also advocate for longitudinal studies to see if improving knowledge actually leads to better long-term clinical recovery for mTBI patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

Significant gaps in knowledge and attitudes toward mTBI exist among patients and their families, influenced by income and education levels. Personal experience with mTBI from falls correlates with more positive attitudes. These findings highlight the need for targeted educational interventions to improve understanding and attitudes, ultimately enhancing patient care and management. Comprehensive, accessible mTBI education is crucial for fostering positive attitudes and better knowledge among patients and their families.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2024knowledge,
  author = {Jian He and Zhongliang Chen and Jianjun Zhang and Xiao Liu},
  title = {{Knowledge and attitudes toward mild traumatic brain injury among patients and family members}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2024.1349169},
}
Figure