Knot homologies and generalized quiver partition functions

Tobias Ekholm, Piotr Kucharski, Pietro LonghiLetters 2021

Abstract

We conjecture a relation between generalized quiver partition functions and generating functions for symmetrically colored HOMFLY-PT polynomials and corresponding HOMFLY-PT homology Poincaré polynomials of a knot $K$. We interpret the generalized quiver nodes as certain basic holomorphic curves with boundary on the knot conormal $L_K$ in the resolved conifold, and the adjacency matrix as measuring their boundary linking. The simplest such curves are embedded disks with boundary in the primitive homology class of $L_K$, other basic holomorphic curves consists of two parts: an embedded punctured sphere and a multiply covered punctured disk with boundary in a multiple of the primitive homology class of $L_K$. We also study recursion relations for the partition functions connected to knot homologies. We show that, after a suitable change of variables, any (generalized) quiver partition function satisfies the recursion relation of a single toric brane in $\mathbb{C}^3$.

Introduction: The Knots-Quivers Correspondence

In the study of mathematical knots, the HOMFLY-PT polynomial is a fundamental invariant used to distinguish different knots. It is defined by specific skein relations that describe how the polynomial changes when crossings in a knot diagram are altered.

Skein relations defining the HOMFLY-PT polynomial.

The "categorification" of this invariant, known as HOMFLY-PT homology, provides even deeper structural information. Recently, researchers discovered a remarkable "knots-quivers correspondence," suggesting that knot data can be encoded into a quiver—a directed graph of nodes and arrows. The generating function of the quiver's representations (its motivic partition function) matches the knot's polynomial.

However, the standard correspondence fails for complex knots like $9_{42}$. This research addresses this limitation by introducing generalized quivers and providing a geometric explanation for these new structures.

Methodology

The authors bridge knot theory, symplectic geometry, and string theory using several sophisticated techniques:

  • Generalized Quiver Nodes: Unlike standard quivers where each node represents a disk wrapping the knot conormal once, the authors introduce nodes with multiplicity $\mu > 1$. Geometrically, these correspond to "stretched" holomorphic disks that wrap around the knot multiple times.
  • Symplectic Field Theory (SFT) Stretching: SFT is used to decompose complex holomorphic curves into "two-level buildings"—consisting of a punctured sphere and a multiply-covered disk—to derive new partition function formulas.
  • Refinement via Bott Localization: To transition from polynomials to homology (the "refined" level), the authors employ Bott localization, treating BPS states as "equivariant vortices" where homological grading emerges from the geometry.
  • Noncommutative Variables: Quantum torus algebras are used to derive recursion relations (quantum $A$-polynomials) for these generalized partition functions.

The model was validated against benchmark knots, including the Unknot and Trefoil for baseline consistency, and complex knots like $9_{42}$ and $10_{132}$ to demonstrate the success of the generalized approach.

Key Insights and Results

The most significant conceptual shift is the realization that quiver nodes can be non-embedded, "stretched" configurations carrying higher winding numbers.

A major discovery is the Toric Brane Property. The authors show that by defining a new "toric brane variable" $Z$ as the sum of all quiver variables ($Z = \sum Z_i$), the complex partition function of any knot simplifies significantly. It satisfies the exact same recursion relation as the simplest possible topological string configuration: a single toric brane in $\mathbb{C}^3$.

Key results include:

  • Formal Definition: A new definition for the generalized quiver partition function (Definition 3.5) incorporating node multiplicity.
  • Conjecture 3.6: A conjecture that this new function generates the Poincaré polynomials for symmetrically colored HOMFLY-PT homology.
  • Universality: Proof that after a suitable change of variables, any generalized quiver partition function satisfies the recursion relation: $(1 - \hat{y} - Z) P_Q(x; q) = 0$. This identifies the "DNA" of knot homologies as fundamentally related to the unknot's quantum curve.

Discussion and Future Work

While the model successfully reproduces data for problematic knots like $9_{42}$, some limitations remain. Much of the HOMFLY-PT homology data for complex knots is currently conjectural. Furthermore, this work focuses on "symmetric" representations (single-row Young diagrams); extending this to arbitrary representations is a significant future challenge. Finally, while the structural part of the conjecture appears robust, the technical details of the variable changes may require further refinement for even more exotic knots.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We introduce generalized quiver partition functions of a knot K and conjecture a relation to generating functions of symmetrically colored HOMFLY-PT polynomials and corresponding HOMFLY-PT homology Poincaré polynomials. We interpret quiver nodes as certain basic holomorphic disks in the resolved conifold, with boundary on the knot conormal $$L_K$$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"> <mml:msub> <mml:mi>L</mml:mi> <mml:mi>K</mml:mi> </mml:msub> </mml:math> , a positive multiple of a unique closed geodesic, and with their (infinitesimal) boundary linking density measured by the adjacency matrix of the generalized quiver. The basic holomorphic disks that are quiver nodes appear in a certain U (1)-symmetric configuration. We propose an extension of the quiver partition function to arbitrary, not U (1)-symmetric, configurations as a function with values in chain complexes. The chain complex differential is trivial at the U (1)-symmetric configuration, under deformations the complex changes, but its homology remains invariant. We also study recursion relations for the partition functions connected to knot homologies. We show that, after a suitable change of variables, any (generalized) quiver partition function satisfies the recursion relation of a single toric brane in $${\mathbb {C}}^3$$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"> <mml:msup> <mml:mrow> <mml:mi>C</mml:mi> </mml:mrow> <mml:mn>3</mml:mn> </mml:msup> </mml:math> .
BibTeX
@article{ekholm2021knot,
  author = {Tobias Ekholm and Piotr Kucharski and Pietro Longhi},
  title = {{Knot homologies and generalized quiver partition functions}},
  journal = {Letters},
  year = {2021},
}
Figure