Kinetically Controlled Synthesis of Highly Emissive Au18SG14 Clusters and Their Phase Transfer: Tips and Tricks

Chengjie Wang, Hairong Zhao, Zhongsheng Ge, Lizhuang Dong, Xiao Han, A. Balakrishna, Praveen Kumar Balguri, Yixi Wang, Udayabhaskararao ThumuACS 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides a detailed guide to the kinetically controlled synthesis of highly emissive Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> nanoclusters, focusing on crucial parameters like antisolvent choice, precursor aging time, and reaction temperature. It also introduces a novel, effective method for phase transfer of these clusters into organic solvents, significantly enhancing their luminescence properties and stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Atomically precise gold nanoclusters (NCs), particularly those protected by glutathione (GSH), are gaining attention for their unique optical properties, especially enhanced luminescence. While methods for synthesizing these clusters have evolved from mixed-size preparations to size-selective techniques and then to one-pot syntheses, achieving atomically pure and highly emissive clusters like Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> consistently across different lab conditions remains a challenge. Previous approaches often relied on thermodynamic control, which is less suitable for less stable, ultrasmall NCs. This paper addresses the need for a robust, kinetically controlled synthesis that yields high-quality Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> and explores how to effectively transfer these water-soluble clusters to organic solvents to further boost their luminescent performance and broaden their application potential.

Methods

The study employs a kinetically controlled, one-pot synthesis approach for Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> NCs. Key steps and techniques include:

  • Controlled Reduction: Utilizing a mild reducing agent, sodium cyanoborohydride (NaBH<sub>3</sub>CN), to slow down the reduction kinetics, which is crucial for controlled nucleation and growth.
  • Antisolvent Role: Investigating the impact of methanol as an antisolvent in the reaction mixture to promote controlled growth and precipitation.
  • Precursor Aging: Systematically studying the effect of aging time of the Au(I)-SG complex precursor on the final NC size and quality using UV-Vis spectroscopy, dynamic light scattering (DLS), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM).
  • Temperature Control: Evaluating the influence of reaction temperature (specifically 37 °C vs. 17 °C) on the synthesis yield and purity of Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> NCs.
  • Phase Transfer: Developing and optimizing a novel phase transfer method from aqueous to organic (toluene) solutions. This involved investigating the effect of pH and employing a dilution strategy to enhance the dissociation of the carboxylic acid groups on the glutathione ligand, facilitating electrostatic interaction with a phase transfer agent (TOAB).
  • Characterization: Employing UV-Vis spectroscopy, photoluminescence (PL) spectroscopy, PL quantum yield measurements, luminescence lifetime measurements, and TEM to characterize the synthesized NCs and their properties in different environments.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental synthesis and characterization rather than utilizing pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Kinetic Control is Paramount: Unlike many larger NC syntheses that benefit from thermodynamic control, ultrasmall and less stable clusters like Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> require precise kinetic control to achieve high purity and desired properties.
  • The "Sweet Spot" for Precursor Aging: The aging time of the Au(I)-SG complex precursor is critical. Too short an aging time leads to incomplete complexation, while too long an aging time results in aggregation and the formation of mixed-size clusters, hindering the synthesis of monodisperse Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub>. A specific window (below 10 minutes) was identified as optimal.
  • Temperature Sensitivity: The synthesis is highly sensitive to reaction temperature, with 37 °C proving to be the optimal temperature for high yield and purity, likely due to its influence on reaction kinetics. Lower temperatures lead to incomplete reduction and the formation of impurities.
  • Traditional Phase Transfer Fails: Standard phase transfer methods, typically successful for larger NCs (like Au<sub>25</sub>SG<sub>18</sub>) at basic pH, are ineffective for Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub>. Basic conditions (pH > 9) actually lead to structural decomposition of the Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> core.
  • Dilution is the Key to Intact Phase Transfer: A novel dilution method, coupled with a phase transfer agent, allows for the successful transfer of Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> into organic solvents without altering their core structure. This is achieved by increasing the dissociation of the ligand's carboxylic acid groups.

Key Results

  • Optimized Synthesis: The study identified crucial parameters (antisolvent, precursor aging time <10 min, and 37 °C reaction temperature) for the successful and large-scale production of Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> NCs.
  • Enhanced Luminescence Post-Transfer: After phase transfer to toluene using the developed dilution method, the Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub>-TOA NCs exhibited significantly enhanced luminescence quantum yields (9 to 3 times higher) and increased average photoluminescence lifetimes (1.5-2.5 times longer) compared to their aqueous counterparts.
  • Structural Integrity Maintained: The novel dilution-based phase transfer method successfully transferred Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> into organic solvents while preserving the integrity of the nanocluster core, as evidenced by UV-Vis spectra.
  • Solvent Polarity Effects: A polarity-based solvent pattern was observed for the optical properties of Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub>-TOA NCs, with organic solvents generally leading to enhanced fluorescence intensity and a blue shift in emission maxima compared to water. Toluene and acetone were identified as optimal solvents for viewing the NCs via TEM.

Limitations and Future Work

  • pH Sensitivity and Decomposition: The paper highlights that Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> clusters are sensitive to basic pH conditions, leading to structural decomposition. This limits the applicability of traditional phase transfer methods that rely on high pH.
  • "Subversive Effect" of OH⁻: The study points out the "subversive effect" of hydroxide ions (OH⁻) on Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub>, necessitating alternative phase transfer strategies.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this work provides a roadmap for the synthesis and optimal phase transfer of highly luminescent Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> NCs, opening opportunities for their use in optoelectronic applications. Further exploration of the polarity-based solvent effects and the precise mechanisms behind the enhanced luminescence post-transfer could be valuable. The identification of the exact composition of NCs formed at lower temperatures (17 °C) also remains an area for future investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Glutathione (GSH) protected gold nanoclusters (Au <sub><i>n</i></sub> SG <sub><i>m</i></sub> NCs) have been attractive because of their novel properties such as enhanced luminescence and band gap tunability at their quantum confinement region (below ∼2 nm). Initial synthetic routes of mixed-size clusters and size-based separation techniques had latter evolved toward atomically precise nanoclusters via thermodynamic and kinetic control routes. One such exemplary synthesis taking the advantages of a kinetically controlled approach is producing highly red-emissive Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> NCs (where SG = thiolate of glutathione), thanks to the slow reduction kinetics provided by the mild reducing agent NaBH<sub>3</sub>CN. Despite the developments in the direct synthesis of Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub>, several meticulous reaction conditions still need to be understood for the highly adaptable synthesis of atomically pure NCs irrespective of the laboratory conditions. Herein, we have systematically studied a series of reaction steps involved in this kinetically controlled approach starting from the role of the antisolvent, formation of precursors to Au-SG thiolates, growth of Au-SG thiolates as a function of aging time, and exploring an optimal reaction temperature to optimize the desired nucleation under slow reduction kinetics. The crucial parameters derived in our studies guide the successful and large-scale production of Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> at any laboratory condition. Next, we investigated the effect of pH on the NCs to study the stability and the best suitable condition for the phase transfer of Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> clusters. The commonly implemented method of phase transfer at the basic conditions (pH > 9) is not successful in this case. However, we developed a feasible method for the phase transfer by diluting the aqueous NC solution to enhance the negative charges on the NCs' surface by increasing the degree of dissociation at the carboxylic acid group. It is interesting to note that after the phase transfer, the Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub>-TOA NCs in toluene as well as in other organic solvents exhibited enhanced luminescence quantum yields from 9 to 3 times and increased average photoluminescence lifetimes by 1.5-2.5 times, respectively.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023kinetically,
  author = {Chengjie Wang and Hairong Zhao and Zhongsheng Ge and Lizhuang Dong and Xiao Han and A. Balakrishna and Praveen Kumar Balguri and Yixi Wang and Udayabhaskararao Thumu},
  title = {{Kinetically Controlled Synthesis of Highly Emissive Au<sub>18</sub>SG<sub>14</sub> Clusters and Their Phase Transfer: Tips and Tricks}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1021/acsomega.2c07663},
}

Loading related content...

Figure