Kinetic terms in warped compactifications

Michael R. Douglas, Gonzalo TorrobaJournal of High Energy Physics 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops a robust formalism for calculating kinetic terms of fields in string theory compactifications, particularly those with warped geometries. By employing a Hamiltonian approach, they derive a gauge-invariant metric on the space of moduli, which is crucial for understanding the low-energy physics of these theories and has implications for string phenomenology.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

String theory compactifications are essential for bridging the gap between the high-dimensional theory and the observed four-dimensional physics. A key challenge in this process, especially for warped compactifications (where the geometry is not uniform), is to correctly derive the kinetic terms for the resulting four-dimensional fields. These kinetic terms dictate how fields propagate and interact, and their accurate calculation is vital for building realistic models. Previous attempts often struggled with subtle issues related to gauge invariance and the role of "compensator" fields, leading to incomplete or incorrect results. This paper aims to provide a systematic and physically intuitive method to overcome these difficulties.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in a Hamiltonian formulation of general relativity and Yang-Mills theory. Instead of directly manipulating the Lagrangian, the authors leverage the constraints inherent in the Hamiltonian approach to identify a natural, gauge-invariant metric on the space of fields (specifically, moduli).

Key techniques include:

  • Hamiltonian Formalism: This allows for the identification of physical degrees of freedom and the imposition of constraints that eliminate unphysical modes.
  • Symplectic Reduction: This mathematical tool is used to construct the reduced phase space, which corresponds to the space of physical configurations.
  • Orthogonality Condition: The paper emphasizes that the correct metric on the moduli space arises from ensuring that metric fluctuations are orthogonal to gauge transformations. This is achieved by minimizing an inner product over each gauge orbit.
  • Compensator Fields: These fields, which previously caused confusion, are reinterpreted within the Hamiltonian framework as Lagrange multipliers that enforce the necessary constraints, ensuring the physical fluctuations are in a specific gauge (harmonic gauge).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hamiltonian Approach as a Unifier: The paper demonstrates that the Hamiltonian framework provides a unified and elegant way to derive kinetic terms for both Yang-Mills theories and gravity, naturally handling gauge invariances and constraints.
  • Compensators as Dynamical Constraints: Compensator fields are not arbitrary additions but arise naturally as Lagrange multipliers that enforce gauge conditions, making them essential for defining the physical moduli space.
  • Warping's Impact on Moduli Dynamics: Warping significantly alters the kinetic terms, leading to different behaviors and potentially mixing different types of moduli (e.g., complex structure and Kähler moduli).
  • Harmonic Gauge as a Dynamical Constraint: The paper shows that the harmonic gauge choice, often assumed in other approaches, is not a mere convenience but a dynamical constraint arising from the underlying physics.
  • Power-Like Divergence in Warped Conifolds: For the specific case of the Klebanov-Strassler solution, the paper confirms a power-like divergence in the field space metric, but with a different numerical coefficient than previously found, highlighting the importance of correctly handling gauge transformations.

Key Results

  • A general formalism for computing kinetic terms in warped compactifications is presented, applicable to various string compactifications preserving 4D maximal symmetry.
  • The paper successfully derives the metric for complex and Kähler moduli in Calabi-Yau compactifications.
  • For the warped deformed conifold (Klebanov-Strassler background), the paper confirms the power-like divergence in the field space metric for the complex modulus S, finding a dependence of $|S|^{-4/3}$. While qualitatively agreeing with previous results, the quantitative coefficient differs, attributed to a more rigorous treatment of gauge transformations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Numerical Coefficients: While the hard-wall approximation provides the correct functional dependence on parameters like $g_s N \alpha'$ and $|S|$, the precise numerical coefficients for the kinetic terms may differ from those obtained in the full Klebanov-Strassler solution. Further work is needed to obtain these precise coefficients.
  • General Applicability of Conifold Results: The specific argument for the $1/|S|^{4/3}$ behavior in the conifold case relies on special properties of that solution. The generality of this result for other warped compactifications needs further investigation.
  • Kähler Potential and Supersymmetry: The paper suggests that understanding the implications of these results for the 4D Kähler potential is important, especially for compactifications that admit covariantly constant spinors.
  • Non-Conformal Calabi-Yau Compactifications: The authors propose extending this formalism to compactifications that are not conformally equivalent to Calabi-Yau manifolds, which are relevant for describing gravity duals of metastable vacua in strongly coupled gauge theories.
  • Mixed Moduli Terms: The possibility of mixed terms between complex structure and Kähler moduli in the field space metric is highlighted, which could impact KKLT scenarios.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{douglas2009kinetic,
  author = {Michael R. Douglas and Gonzalo Torroba},
  title = {{Kinetic terms in warped compactifications}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1088/1126-6708/2009/05/013},
}
Figure