TL;DR
This paper performs a comprehensive global fit of the Constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (cMSSM) against a wide range of experimental data. The key finding is that the cMSSM is excluded at the 90% confidence level, meaning it's no longer a viable explanation for particle physics phenomena. This exclusion is achieved through a novel frequentist p-value calculation using "toy experiments."
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Standard Model (SM) of particle physics, while incredibly successful, has some limitations, such as not incorporating dark matter or explaining the hierarchy problem. Supersymmetry (SUSY) offers a potential solution by introducing a new symmetry that pairs every known particle with a "superpartner." The Constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (cMSSM) is a simplified, well-motivated version of SUSY that aims to explain these puzzles.
However, as experimental data has accumulated from precision measurements (like the muon's anomalous magnetic moment, (g-2)μ), astrophysical observations (dark matter), and direct searches at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) for new particles, the cMSSM has faced increasing pressure. Previous studies showed a poor "best fit" of the cMSSM to the data, but lacked a rigorous statistical method to definitively exclude the model. This paper tackles the problem of quantifying this tension by performing a robust frequentist analysis to determine if the cMSSM can be statistically rejected.
Methods
The core of this paper is a sophisticated global fit of the cMSSM parameter space using the FITTINO program. The authors employ a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method to sample the vast parameter space.
The novel contribution is the development and application of a consistent frequentist methodology to calculate a p-value for the cMSSM. This involves:
- Pseudo-experiments (Toy Studies): Instead of just looking at the overall fit quality (χ²), they generate thousands of synthetic datasets ("toy experiments") based on the best-fit predictions. They then perform a fit to each toy dataset and see how often the resulting χ² is as bad or worse than the observed data. This allows them to derive a true p-value.
- Analytical and Quantitative Analysis of Observable Sets: They investigate how the choice of experimental observables (what data is included in the fit) impacts the p-value. They highlight the phenomenon of "dilution," where including many barely constraining measurements can artificially inflate the p-value, masking tensions.
- Vacuum Stability Analysis: They also analyze the stability of the electroweak vacuum within the cMSSM parameter space, determining if the universe could tunnel into a different, lower-energy state.
Datasets
The paper utilizes a comprehensive set of experimental and observational data, including:
- Precision Observables: Anomalous magnetic moment of the muon ((g-2)μ), effective weak mixing angle (sin²θeff), top quark and W boson masses, Bs oscillation frequency (Δms), and branching ratios for b-hadron decays (B(Bs → μμ), B(b → sy), B(b → τν)).
- Astrophysical Observations: Dark matter relic density (from Planck) and spin-independent WIMP-nucleon scattering cross-section bounds (from LUX).
- LHC Searches: Constraints from ATLAS and CMS searches for supersymmetric particles (particularly jets + missing transverse momentum) and Higgs boson properties (signal strengths and mass).
- Higgs Data: Measurements from LEP and the LHC, including signal strengths across various decay channels and the Higgs boson mass.
The paper defines five different "Higgs observable sets" to study the impact of Higgs data on the fit.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The cMSSM is Statistically Excluded: The most significant finding is that, when analyzed rigorously with a frequentist p-value, the cMSSM is ruled out at the 90% confidence level. This means the model, as currently formulated, cannot explain the observed universe.
- P-value is Sensitive to Observable Choice: The choice of which experimental data to include in the fit dramatically affects the p-value. Including too many "barely constraining" measurements can dilute the statistical power and lead to a misleadingly high p-value.
- (g-2)μ is a Major Tension: The anomalous magnetic moment of the muon is a key driver of the cMSSM's exclusion. The cMSSM, particularly at higher sparticle masses favored by LHC searches, struggles to reconcile its prediction for (g-2)μ with the experimental measurement.
- Vacuum is Metastable, but Long-Lived: While the cMSSM vacuum is found to be metastable, its predicted lifetime is significantly longer than the age of the Universe, meaning it's not an immediate concern for the stability of our universe.
- "SM with Dark Matter" is a Better Description: The analysis suggests that the cMSSM, in its excluded parameter regions, effectively resembles the Standard Model plus a generic dark matter candidate, offering little additional predictive power in those scenarios.
Key Results
- Exclusion of cMSSM: The paper reports p-values for the cMSSM below 10% for preferred observable sets, leading to exclusion at the 90% confidence level. For example, a p-value of (4.9±0.7)% is obtained with the Medium Observable Set.
- Impact of (g-2)μ: Removing the (g-2)μ observable from the fit significantly increases the p-value to around 50%, highlighting its crucial role in the exclusion.
- Vacuum Metastability: The electroweak vacuum is found to be metastable, but with a lifetime vastly exceeding the age of the Universe.
- Best Fit Regions: The best-fit points are found in the τ-coannihilation region (around M₀ ≈ 500 GeV) and a secondary minimum in the focus-point region (M1/2, M₀ > 2 TeV).
Limitations and Future Work
- Computational Cost: The calculation of p-values through toy experiments is computationally intensive. While the authors developed efficient techniques, the number of toy experiments is still limited, leading to statistical uncertainties in the p-values.
- Observable Set Dependence: The paper emphasizes that the p-value is sensitive to the choice of observables. While they explore various sets, the "best" set for a definitive exclusion is a subject of ongoing discussion.
- "Softness" of Exclusion: The authors acknowledge that the freedom in choosing observable sets introduces a "softness" to the exclusion, meaning the cMSSM isn't "hardly" killed but rather "softly."
- Future Work: The authors suggest that less restricted SUSY models, which allow for more decoupled sparticle masses, might circumvent the tensions observed in the cMSSM. They also point out that future collider experiments and improved dark matter detection sensitivity will further constrain or potentially discover SUSY. The paper also notes that the current precision of Higgs measurements doesn't allow for discrimination between the SM and cMSSM based solely on Higgs properties.
Summary updated