Keyword Analysis and Systematic Review of China’s Sponge City Policy and Flood Management Research

Yichen Lu, Mei‐Ting Huang, Honglin Xiao, Zhigang Lü, Mingjing Xie, Kaida ChenAtmosphere 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

China's "Sponge City" policy is a crucial initiative for tackling urban flooding exacerbated by climate change and urbanization. This systematic review and keyword analysis of research on the policy reveals a significant shift from purely engineering-focused flood control to a more integrated, multi-objective approach encompassing technical, environmental, institutional, and social dimensions. The findings highlight key research trends, identify critical knowledge gaps, and offer a roadmap for optimizing future policy and research in this vital area.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cities worldwide are increasingly vulnerable to flooding due to the combined forces of climate change (leading to more extreme weather events) and rapid urbanization (increasing impervious surfaces and altering natural drainage patterns). Traditional "grey infrastructure" solutions, like larger drainage pipes and levees, are often expensive, environmentally damaging, and insufficient to cope with these escalating risks. In response, China launched its "Sponge City" policy in 2013, aiming to enhance urban resilience by integrating low-impact development (LID) and green infrastructure (GI) into urban water management. While the policy has seen widespread implementation, there's a need for a comprehensive understanding of its research landscape, identifying what has been studied, how the focus has evolved, and where critical knowledge gaps remain to guide future policy and research effectively.

Methods

The authors employed a systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis using the CiteSpace software. They retrieved 201 relevant articles from the Web of Science database and narrowed them down to 61 studies specifically focusing on China's sponge city policy and urban flood management. CiteSpace was used to perform:

  • Keyword Co-occurrence Analysis: To identify clusters of related research themes and visualize the network of concepts.
  • Temporal Evolution Analysis (Time Slicing): To track how research hotspots and thematic priorities have changed over time, from 2017 to 2024.
  • Betweenness Centrality Measurement: To identify keywords that act as crucial bridges between different research areas.

This approach allowed them to map the research landscape, identify key trends, and construct a multidimensional analytical framework.

Datasets

The primary dataset for this study was a collection of 61 peer-reviewed academic papers, conference papers, monograph chapters, and policy reports related to China's sponge city policy and urban flood management, sourced from the Web of Science Core Collection, Scopus, and Google Scholar. The search was conducted in July 2025, covering publications from 2017 to 2025. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Evolution from Engineering to Integration: The most striking insight is the clear shift in research focus. Early research was heavily engineering-centric, focusing on technical flood control models. However, the field has evolved significantly towards a more holistic, interdisciplinary approach.
  • The Rise of a Multidimensional Framework: The study successfully proposes and validates a four-dimensional analytical framework (technical, environmental, institutional, and social) for understanding sponge city research. This moves beyond single-indicator assessments and captures the complex interplay of factors influencing policy success.
  • Identifying Critical Knowledge Gaps: The analysis pinpoints specific areas needing more attention, such as cross-scale coordination (linking river basin, city, and community levels), smart management integration, and deeper exploration of public participation mechanisms.
  • Sponge City as a National Strategy: The research underscores that sponge city initiatives are not just technical solutions but are deeply embedded within China's national strategy for sustainable urban development and climate resilience.

Key Results

  • Research Trends: The research landscape has evolved from focusing on "flood risk" and "impact" (2017-2019) to "sponge city" and "resilient city construction" (post-2020). More recently, themes like "extreme precipitation," "risk assessment," "community resilience," and "nature-based solutions" have emerged.
  • Core Research Dimensions: The analysis identified four key dimensions in sponge city research:
  • Technical: Stormwater modeling, pluvial flooding, urban rainfall runoff.
  • Environmental: Green infrastructure, permeable pavement, rainwater gardens.
  • Institutional: Policy implementation, governance, PPP (Public-Private Partnership) models.
  • Social: Public perception, willingness to pay, community resilience.
  • Key Challenges Identified: The study highlights persistent challenges, including insufficient funding, difficulties in retrofitting older urban areas, limited drainage capacity, interdepartmental coordination gaps, and low public engagement.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Potential Bias: Manual screening of literature may introduce subjective judgment.
  • Limited Scope: The study did not include grey literature or databases outside of the specified ones, potentially missing some practice-oriented or policy evaluation work.
  • Cross-Regional Comparisons: While the study provides insights, a more robust exploration of cross-regional comparisons and temporal analyses across diverse climatic and socio-economic conditions is needed.
  • Smart Management and Public Participation: The application of smart management tools and data-driven decision-making is still in its exploratory phase and requires closer integration with policy evaluation. Research on public participation, risk communication, and social resilience building needs strengthening.

Future work should focus on:

  • Interdisciplinary Integration: Strengthening the integration of hydrological modeling, social sciences, and policy analysis.
  • Learning from International Experience: Adapting successful strategies from other regions to local contexts.
  • Long-Term Monitoring and Simulation: Enhancing data collection and dynamic modeling to understand policy performance under future climate scenarios.
  • Smart Technologies: Applying smart water management and big data analytics to inform policy and governance.
  • System Integration: Moving from conceptual understanding to system integration and refined management practices.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the acceleration of climate change and urbanisation, Chinese cities are facing increasingly severe flood risks. To address this challenge, China began implementing its sponge city policy in 2013, leveraging low-impact development, green infrastructure construction, and integrated water resource management to enhance urban resilience to floods and improve water security. This study utilises the Web of Science database as a reference, retrieving 201 relevant literature sources. From these, 61 studies closely related to China’s sponge city policy and urban flood management were selected. CiteSpace was employed to conduct keyword co-occurrence and temporal evolution analyses, comprehensively outlining the research hotspots and developmental trajectory of this field. The results indicate that research content has gradually shifted from early engineering-based flood control models to multi-objective, interdisciplinary comprehensive management, encompassing flood risk assessment, policy implementation mechanisms, integration of green infrastructure, and economic feasibility analysis. Based on this, this paper constructs an analytical framework incorporating technical, environmental, institutional, and social dimensions to integrate existing research findings, while identifying gaps in cross-scale coordination, smart management, and public participation. The research conclusions can provide valuable references for future policy optimisation and urban sustainable development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2025keyword,
  author = {Yichen Lu and Mei‐Ting Huang and Honglin Xiao and Zhigang Lü and Mingjing Xie and Kaida Chen},
  title = {{Keyword Analysis and Systematic Review of China’s Sponge City Policy and Flood Management Research}},
  booktitle = {Atmosphere},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/atmos16091090},
}
Figure