Just a phase? Causal probing reveals spurious phasic dependence of sensory perception

Matteo Vinao-Carl, Y. Gal-Shohet, E. J. Rhodes, Jia V. Li, Adam Hampshire, David Sharp, Nir GrossmanbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper challenges the long-held belief that spontaneous brain oscillations (like alpha and theta waves) actively predict sensory perception. By carefully timing visual stimuli to these brain rhythms, the researchers found no causal link. Instead, they demonstrate that common analysis techniques can create artificial correlations, making it seem like brain rhythms predict behavior when they actually don't.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For years, researchers have observed that the timing (phase) of brain activity before a stimulus appears seems to correlate with how we perceive that stimulus. This has led to the popular idea that the brain uses these "pre-stimulus oscillations" like a clock, preparing to receive information at specific moments. However, there's been a nagging question: could these observed correlations be an artifact of how we analyze the data, rather than a true reflection of brain function? Specifically, the way we process brain signals using time-frequency analysis might be "smearing" the brain's response to a stimulus backward in time, creating a false impression of pre-stimulus prediction. This paper aims to settle this debate by directly testing the causal role of pre-stimulus oscillations in a controlled experiment.

Methods

The core of this study is a clever experimental design that directly probes causality. Instead of just observing correlations, the researchers actively manipulated when visual stimuli were presented. They used electroencephalography (EEG) to monitor brain activity in real-time and then timed visual cues to coincide with specific phases (peaks or troughs) of ongoing alpha and theta oscillations. This "phase-locking" allowed them to present stimuli at precisely controlled moments relative to the brain's internal rhythms.

A key methodological innovation is the use of an "end-point corrected Hilbert transform" (ecHT). Traditional methods for calculating the phase of brain signals (like the Hilbert transform) can be problematic because they are "acausal," meaning they use future data points to calculate past ones. This can lead to distortions, especially at the edges of the signal, potentially creating the spurious correlations the authors are investigating. The ecHT, on the other hand, is a causal method that accurately computes the phase in real-time without being influenced by the stimulus-evoked response. They compared analyses using both the standard acausal Hilbert transform and their novel causal ecHT.

Datasets

The study used EEG data recorded from 20 healthy human volunteers performing a visual choice reaction task. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "predictive" brain rhythm might be an illusion: The most striking finding is that when stimuli are presented in time with specific brain oscillation phases, there's no actual change in performance. This directly contradicts the idea that these oscillations are actively preparing the brain for upcoming stimuli.
  • Acausal analysis is a powerful source of spurious correlations: The study strongly suggests that common time-frequency analysis techniques, particularly those using the Hilbert transform, can create artificial relationships between pre-stimulus brain activity and behavior. This "smearing" of the stimulus-evoked response into the pre-stimulus period is the likely culprit.
  • Causal analysis is crucial for understanding brain function: The development and application of the ecHT highlight the importance of using causal methods when investigating the temporal dynamics of brain activity and its relationship to behavior. It allows researchers to disentangle true neural mechanisms from analytical artifacts.
  • The evoked response is key to the artifact: The researchers further demonstrated this by replacing pre-stimulus EEG with white noise. Even then, the acausal analysis showed a correlation with behavior, suggesting the artifact originates from how the evoked response is processed, not from spontaneous oscillations themselves.

Key Results

  • Presenting visual stimuli timed to the peak or trough of alpha and theta oscillations did not lead to any significant differences in response times (RTs) compared to random phase presentations.
  • Spurious correlations between theta phase and behavior emerged when using standard, acausal time-frequency analyses (Hilbert transform) on offline data.
  • These spurious correlations vanished when using the newly developed causal method (ecHT) for phase analysis.
  • The magnitude of the observed phasic dependency (artifact) was approximately 15% of the variance, suggesting it's a substantial effect in typical analyses.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while their findings challenge the interpretation of many previous studies, it doesn't mean spontaneous oscillations are entirely irrelevant. Future work could explore different brain regions, more complex visual processing tasks, or investigate how the amplitude of oscillations might relate to behavior. They also suggest that future studies aiming to uncover genuine relationships should meticulously implement causal analysis techniques like the ecHT, ensuring the analysis window is carefully aligned to avoid contamination from post-stimulus activity. The paper also notes that the strength of the artifact depends on the amplitude and latency of the evoked response, and may be less pronounced for higher frequencies or when the pre-stimulus window doesn't overlap with the evoked response.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT For over a decade, electrophysiological studies have reported correlations between sensory perception and the phase of spontaneous pre-stimulus brain oscillations. To date, these findings have been interpreted as evidence that the brain uses neural oscillations to sample and predict upcoming stimuli. Yet, evidence from simulations have shown that analysis artefacts could also lead to spurious pre-stimulus oscillations that appear to predict future brain responses. To address this discrepancy, we conducted an experiment in which visual stimuli were presented timed to specific phases of spontaneous alpha and theta oscillations. This allowed us to causally probe the role of ongoing neural activity in visual processing independent of the stimulus-evoked dynamics. Our findings did not support a causal link between spontaneous alpha / theta rhythms and behaviour. However, spurious correlations between theta phase and behaviour emerged offline using gold-standard acausal time-frequency analyses. These findings demonstrate that care should be taken when inferring causal relationships between neural activity and behaviour using acausal analyses. HIGHLIGHTS We causally probed the role of spontaneous EEG rhythms in visual attention via phase-locking. Theta phase predicted behaviour offline, but cues presented in real-time with theta had no effect on behaviour. Spurious theta rhythmic sampling is an artefact of the evoked potential and acausal filtering. ecHT accurately computes the phase in real-time and mitigates erroneous phase-behaviour correlations.
BibTeX
@misc{vinaocarl2023just,
  author = {Matteo Vinao-Carl and Y. Gal-Shohet and E. J. Rhodes and Jia V. Li and Adam Hampshire and David Sharp and Nir Grossman},
  title = {{Just a phase? Causal probing reveals spurious phasic dependence of sensory perception}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.08.21.554096},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure