Abstract
In the digital era, the rights of the elderly digitally disadvantaged groups are in a dilemma, and the right to information, the right to privacy, and the right to social development cannot be guaranteed. From the jurisprudential basis, the jurisprudential sources of the rights of the elderly digitally disadvantaged groups include the three aspects of safeguarding human dignity, guaranteeing digital human rights, and promoting the traditional virtues of respecting the elderly. In order to seek a relief path for the rights of the elderly digitally disadvantaged groups, the causes of the dilemma of protecting the rights of the elderly digitally disadvantaged groups should be analysed from the perspective of social structural factors and the factors of individual ability and psychological characteristics. Finally, specific relief paths are proposed to protect the rights of the elderly digitally disadvantaged groups, firstly, relying on the legal empowerment to improve the digital rights protection system, and secondly, the synergy of multiple subjects to build an all-round social security network.
Introduction: The Digital Divide as a Human Rights Crisis
As essential services like healthcare, banking, and transportation migrate almost exclusively to digital platforms, a significant portion of the elderly population is being left behind. This phenomenon, often termed the "digital divide," represents a "double divide" at the intersection of biological aging and technological exclusion.
Despite the rapid expansion of the internet, data from the National Bureau of Statistics (January 2024) confirms that 21.1% of China's population—approximately 297 million people—is aged 60 or older. Furthermore, the 52nd CNNIC Report (August 2023) indicates that while internet penetration has reached 76.4%, the non-netizen population remains at 333 million, with the elderly being the primary demographic within this group. This paper argues for a robust jurisprudential framework to transition from mere "formal" age-appropriate design to substantive legal protections and multi-stakeholder social support.
Jurisprudential Foundations
The protection of the elderly in a digital society is rooted in three primary legal and cultural pillars:
- Safeguarding Human Dignity: Derived from Constitutional and Civil law, the right to participate in society without being marginalized by technology is a core component of human dignity.
- Digital Human Rights: In a modern context, the right to information and social development is no longer optional; it is a prerequisite for exercising basic human rights. Access to digital tools must be viewed through the lens of fundamental entitlements.
- Traditional Virtues: The concept of "Digital Back-feeding" (数字反哺) frames digital literacy as a modern form of filial duty, integrating traditional cultural values of respecting the elderly into the technological age.
Analyzing the Barriers to Inclusion
The dilemma facing the elderly is driven by both structural and individual factors:
- The Digital Matthew Effect: This social structural factor creates a feedback loop where those proficient in digital tools gain more resources, while the disadvantaged fall further behind, effectively creating an "information island" for the elderly.
- Substantive vs. Formal Age-Appropriateness: Current industry efforts often suffer from formalism. Many companies simply increase font sizes (formal age-appropriateness) without addressing complex user interface logic or backend accessibility (substantive age-appropriateness).
- Psychological Barriers: Individual factors such as "learned helplessness," technology anxiety, and a lack of digital confidence prevent many elderly individuals from engaging with new systems, even when they are available.
Strategic Relief Paths: Legal Empowerment
To address these challenges, the paper proposes a multi-layered roadmap for reform:
Legislative Reform
There is an urgent need to update the Law on the Protection of the Rights and Interests of the Elderly to explicitly include digital rights. This includes the right to information, the right to privacy in digital spaces, and the right to social development. Current laws often treat digital access as a convenience rather than a fundamental right, leaving the elderly vulnerable to privacy breaches and social exclusion.
The "Offline" Safety Net
While the digital transition is inevitable, maintaining "offline" channels for essential services—such as manual windows at hospitals and banks—must be a mandatory legal safeguard. Access to basic societal functions should not be contingent on technological proficiency.
Multi-Subject Synergy
A collaborative model is required to build an all-round social security network:
- Government: Provide oversight and clear regulatory frameworks.
- Enterprises: Focus on substantive age-appropriate R&D, potentially incentivized by tax breaks or social responsibility certifications.
- Families and Communities: Provide the "final mile" of education through technical tutoring and emotional support.
Conclusion and Future Directions
Protecting the digitally disadvantaged is a matter of legal justice, not just technological adjustment. While this paper provides a theoretical and legal foundation, future work must address emerging challenges such as algorithmic fairness—ensuring that automated systems in insurance or credit scoring do not discriminate against the elderly. Additionally, developing concrete, industry-wide engineering standards for substantive accessibility will be crucial for moving beyond UI tweaks toward true digital inclusion.
Summary updated