Joint sub-carrier pairing and resource allocation for cognitive networks with adaptive relaying

Hamza Soury, Faouzi Bader, Musbah Shaat, Mohamed-Slim AlouiniEURASIP J. Wirel. Commun. Netw 2013 · DOI · OpenReview

Introduction

The wireless spectrum is a finite and increasingly crowded resource. Cognitive Radio (CR) offers a solution by allowing secondary users (SUs) to "borrow" unused spectrum from primary users (PUs), provided they do not cause harmful interference. To extend the coverage and capacity of these secondary networks, researchers often use relays.

However, traditional relaying techniques face a fundamental trade-off. Amplify-and-Forward (AAF) is simple but amplifies noise, which is detrimental at low Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNR). Conversely, Decode-and-Forward (DAF) eliminates noise by re-encoding the signal, but can propagate significant errors if the relay fails to decode correctly at low SNR. This paper addresses these challenges by proposing a framework that intelligently switches between these modes while optimizing resource allocation.

System Model and Adaptive Relaying

The authors develop a framework for a multi-carrier (OFDM) cognitive relay system. The core of their approach is the Adaptive Relaying Protocol (ARP), which allows the relay to evaluate the received SNR and dynamically choose the most efficient mode. If the SNR is above a specific threshold ($\gamma_{th}$), the relay uses DAF; if it falls below, it switches to AAF to avoid decoding errors.

Illustration of a cooperative relay cognitive radio network with N = 4.

Joint Optimization Strategy

Beyond adaptive relaying, the paper introduces a sophisticated Sub-carrier Pairing strategy. Unlike simpler systems where a relay must transmit on the same sub-carrier it received on ("matching"), this model allows the relay to receive on sub-carrier k and transmit on sub-carrier l. This flexibility enables the system to exploit the best available channels in both hops of the transmission.

To maximize the total end-to-end data rate, the authors jointly optimize power allocation and sub-carrier pairing. This problem is non-convex and constrained by both the total power budget and the maximum allowable interference at the primary user's receiver. The authors solve this by transforming it into a dual problem and applying a sub-gradient algorithm to iteratively find the optimal configuration.

Key Results and Performance

Simulation results confirm that the ARP consistently achieves higher average capacity than using AAF or DAF alone. The protocol effectively tracks the "upper envelope" of performance, behaving like AAF when the signal is weak and switching to DAF as signal strength increases.

Capacity performance of ARP compared to fixed AAF and DAF protocols across different sub-carrier counts.

Key insights from the evaluation include:

  • Pairing Advantage: Optimal sub-carrier pairing provides a significant capacity gain over random pairing or simple matching.
  • Interference Bottlenecks: The interference constraint ($I_{th}$) often acts as the primary bottleneck, sometimes preventing the system from reaching its full hardware power budget.
  • Relay Positioning: The transition point where DAF becomes superior to AAF depends on the relay's location; proximity to the source favors earlier DAF viability.

Conclusion

While the proposed optimization algorithm provides substantial performance gains, the authors note that its $O(TN^3)$ complexity may require further refinement for real-time applications with high sub-carrier counts. Future research directions include developing lower-complexity suboptimal algorithms and extending the framework to multi-relay networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Relayed transmission in a cognitive radio (CR) environment could be used to increase the coverage and capacity of communication system that benefits already from the efficient management of the spectrum developed by CR. Furthermore, there are many types of cooperative communications, including decode-and-forward (DAF) and amplify-and-forward (AAF). In this paper, these techniques are combined in an adaptive mode to benefit from its forwarding advantages; this mode is called adaptive relaying protocol (ARP). Moreover, this work focuses on the joint power allocation in a cognitive radio system in a cooperative mode that operates ARP in multi-carrier mode. The multi-carrier scenario is used in an orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) mode, and the problem is formulated to maximize the end-to-end rate by searching the best power allocation at the transmitters. This work includes, besides the ARP model, a sub-carrier pairing strategy that allows the relays to switch to the best sub-carrier pairs to increase the throughput. The optimization problem is formulated and solved under the interference and power budget constraints using the sub-gradient algorithm. The simulation results confirm the efficiency of the proposed adaptive relaying protocol in comparison to other relaying techniques. The results show also the consequence of the choice of the pairing strategy.
BibTeX
@article{soury2013joint,
  author = {Hamza Soury and Faouzi Bader and Musbah Shaat and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Joint sub-carrier pairing and resource allocation for cognitive networks with adaptive relaying}},
  journal = {EURASIP J. Wirel. Commun. Netw.},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1186/1687-1499-2013-259},
}
Figure