Joint Power Control and Resource Allocation with Rate Fairness Consideration for SWIPT-Based Cognitive Two-Way Relay Networks

Huaping Liu(刘华平), Chunling Peng, Guozhong Wang, Huaping LiuSensors 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of efficiently sharing wireless spectrum in cognitive radio networks, specifically focusing on a two-way relay system that simultaneously harvests energy and transmits data. The authors propose a novel algorithm (JPCRA) to optimize power and time allocation, ensuring fairness among users while minimizing interference to the primary network, leading to improved overall performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ever-increasing demand for wireless communication has led to a severe scarcity of radio spectrum. Cognitive radio (CR) offers a solution by allowing secondary users (SUs) to opportunistically access licensed spectrum, provided they don't interfere with primary users (PUs). This paper focuses on a specific CR scenario: a two-way relay network where two SUs communicate with each other via a relay node. This relay node is special because it can simultaneously harvest energy from the received signals (SWIPT - Simultaneous Wireless Information and Power Transfer) and then use this harvested energy to relay information.

The core challenges addressed are:

  • Spectrum Underlay: Ensuring SUs operate without causing unacceptable interference to PUs. This requires careful power control.
  • Rate Fairness: Guaranteeing that all SUs achieve a minimum transmission rate, especially when channel conditions are asymmetric.
  • Resource Allocation: Optimizing how time is divided for different communication phases (e.g., transmission, relaying) and how power is split at the relay for energy harvesting versus information decoding.
  • Energy Efficiency: Leveraging SWIPT to power the relay node, which is crucial for sustainable operation.

The paper aims to maximize the minimum transmission rate among the cognitive users (ensuring fairness) by jointly optimizing power allocation at the sources, time allocation for transmission frames, and the power splitting ratio at the relay, all while respecting the PU's interference threshold.

Methods

The paper proposes a Joint Power Control and Resource Allocation (JPCRA) scheme, which is a sub-optimal algorithm designed to tackle the complex, non-convex optimization problem. The core idea is to decouple the problem into smaller, manageable parts and solve them iteratively.

The JPCRA scheme involves two main degenerated optimization works:

  1. Power Allocation with Power Control Consideration (PAPC): This part focuses on determining the optimal power control and power allocation parameters for the source nodes and the relay, assuming fixed time and power splitting ratios. This is achieved by deriving expressions for the maximum attainable power levels for P1, P2, and PR based on interference constraints and peak power limits.
  2. Jointly Optimum Time Allocation and Power Splitting Ratio (JoTAPS): This part focuses on optimizing the time allocation parameter (t) and the power splitting ratio (ρ) at the relay, assuming fixed transmit power. The paper proves that this sub-problem is a convex optimization problem, allowing for efficient solutions using iterative optimization.

The overall JPCRA algorithm then iteratively applies PAPC and JoTAPS until convergence, leading to the final optimized parameters for the entire system.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is based on simulations using defined system parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fairness is Key: The paper emphasizes that simply maximizing the sum rate isn't enough. Ensuring a minimum rate for all users (rate fairness) is crucial, especially in scenarios with varying channel quality. The proposed JPCRA scheme explicitly targets this by maximizing the minimum achievable rate.
  • Interdependence of Resources: The study highlights how power control, time allocation, and power splitting are intricately linked. Optimizing one without considering the others can lead to suboptimal performance. The JPCRA algorithm's iterative approach addresses this interdependence.
  • SWIPT as a Game-Changer: The integration of SWIPT is shown to be vital for powering the relay, enabling sustainable operation without external power sources. The power splitting ratio becomes a critical parameter to balance energy harvesting and information decoding.
  • Cognitive Underlay Constraints: The strict interference threshold imposed by the primary network significantly impacts the achievable rates for the cognitive users, underscoring the importance of robust power control mechanisms.
  • Sub-optimal but Effective: The paper acknowledges that finding a globally optimal solution is computationally challenging. The proposed JPCRA scheme offers a practical and effective sub-optimal solution that significantly improves performance.

Key Results

  • The proposed JPCRA scheme demonstrates superior performance in terms of the max-min achievable rate compared to three traditional optimization schemes (FT-JOPSPA, FPS-JoTPA, FPA-JoTPS).
  • The JPCRA scheme effectively alleviates the impact of channel asymmetry, leading to improved fairness among users.
  • The performance of the system is shown to be sensitive to the interference threshold (Q) from the primary network and the maximum transmit power constraints of the source nodes (P1,max). As these parameters increase, the max-min achievable rate generally increases and then saturates.
  • The interference power from the primary network (σ²) has a detrimental effect on the achievable rate, with the JPCRA scheme showing a more gradual decrease compared to other schemes, indicating its robustness.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sub-optimal Solution: While effective, the JPCRA scheme is sub-optimal. Future work could explore more advanced optimization techniques to approach the global optimum.
  • Indoor Environment Assumption: The simulations are based on an indoor communication environment. Extending the analysis to other environments, such as urban outdoor or vehicular scenarios, would be beneficial.
  • Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) Integration: The authors suggest expanding the scheme to scenarios involving UAVs, which introduce unique mobility and deployment challenges.
  • Deep Learning for Relay Selection: Another interesting future direction proposed is the application of deep learning for cognitive relay selection, which could further enhance system performance.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{liu2023joint,
  author = {Huaping Liu(刘华平) and Chunling Peng and Guozhong Wang and Huaping Liu},
  title = {{Joint Power Control and Resource Allocation with Rate Fairness Consideration for SWIPT-Based Cognitive Two-Way Relay Networks}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23177620},
}
Figure