Joint Design of Fronthauling and Hybrid Beamforming for Downlink C-RAN Systems

Jaein Kim, Seok-Hwan Park, Osvaldo Simeone, Inkyu Lee, Shlomo Shamai ShitzIEEE Trans. Communications 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of optimizing wireless communication in Cloud Radio Access Networks (C-RANs) by jointly designing hybrid beamforming (combining digital and analog signal processing) and fronthaul compression. They propose an iterative algorithm that maximizes network performance (sum-rate and energy efficiency) under realistic constraints, demonstrating its effectiveness even with imperfect channel information.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern wireless systems, especially those using massive MIMO (multiple-input multiple-output) with a large number of antennas, face a trade-off between performance and cost. Equipping every antenna with a full radio frequency (RF) chain is prohibitively expensive. Hybrid beamforming offers a solution by using a low-dimensional digital beamforming at the baseband unit (BBU) and an analog RF beamforming at the remote radio heads (RRHs).

In a C-RAN architecture, the BBU handles baseband processing, while RRHs manage RF functionalities. This setup introduces a new challenge: the limited capacity of the fronthaul links connecting the BBU to the RRHs. Signals transmitted over these links must be compressed, and the compression process introduces noise that depends on the beamforming strategies. This interdependence makes optimizing the digital beamforming, fronthaul compression, and analog RF beamforming a complex, coupled problem. Furthermore, obtaining perfect channel state information (CSI) is often impractical, especially in TDD systems where uplink training is affected by the very RF beamforming being designed. This paper aims to jointly optimize these components to maximize network performance (weighted sum-rate and energy efficiency) while respecting power and fronthaul capacity constraints, even under imperfect CSI conditions.

Methods

The paper proposes an iterative algorithm based on block coordinate descent (BCD) to solve the complex optimization problem. The core idea is to alternately optimize different sets of variables:

  • Digital Beamforming and Fronthaul Compression: For a fixed RF beamforming, the digital beamforming vectors and the fronthaul quantization noise covariance matrices are optimized. This sub-problem is tackled using a weighted minimum-mean-square-error (WMMSE) approach, which involves introducing convex lower bounds and iteratively updating auxiliary variables.
  • RF Beamforming: For fixed digital beamforming and fronthaul compression, the analog RF beamforming matrices are optimized. This sub-problem is also addressed using the WMMSE approach, but with an added challenge: the constant modulus constraint on the RF beamforming matrices (representing phase shifters). To handle this, the constraint is relaxed to a convex one, and after optimization, the resulting matrices are projected back onto the feasible space.

The algorithms for optimizing digital/fronthaul and RF beamforming are then run alternately. For the imperfect CSI scenario, the authors adopt the Sample Average Approximation (SAA) method to handle the uncertainty arising from channel estimation errors. This involves generating multiple channel realizations based on the estimated covariance and optimizing for the average performance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is based on simulations with synthetic channel models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Joint Optimization is Crucial: The paper strongly emphasizes that optimizing digital beamforming, fronthaul compression, and RF beamforming in isolation leads to suboptimal performance. Their joint design approach is key to achieving significant gains.
  • Hybrid Beamforming's Adaptability: Even with imperfect CSI, the proposed hybrid beamforming strategy shows remarkable robustness and good performance, outperforming simpler schemes.
  • Fronthaul Compression's Impact: The capacity of fronthaul links significantly influences the achievable sum-rate. As fronthaul capacity increases, the performance gap between hybrid and fully digital systems narrows.
  • Energy Efficiency Trade-offs: While maximizing sum-rate is important, optimizing for energy efficiency reveals different performance characteristics, especially at higher SNRs where maximizing sum-rate can become energy-inefficient.
  • RF Chain Count Matters: The number of RF chains at the RRHs is a critical parameter. Increasing it generally improves sum-rate, but the benefits diminish beyond a certain point, and can even negatively impact energy efficiency if not optimized carefully.

Key Results

  • The proposed joint design algorithm consistently outperforms baseline schemes (e.g., random RF beamforming, reduced-rank digital) in terms of both average sum-rate and energy efficiency across various SNR and fronthaul capacity levels.
  • In the perfect CSI case, the proposed algorithm converges within a few tens of iterations.
  • Under imperfect CSI, the proposed WSR maximization scheme demonstrates robust performance, outperforming regularized ZF and channel estimation error minimization schemes, especially in the presence of uplink noise.
  • The performance loss due to the projection step in RF beamforming optimization is shown to be small.
  • The paper shows that increasing the number of RF chains can lead to diminishing returns for sum-rate and can even negatively impact EE if not optimized.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Convergence Guarantee: While the individual sub-algorithms are convergent, the overall alternating optimization algorithm for RF beamforming is not guaranteed to converge due to the projection step. However, numerical results show good convergence behavior.
  • Computational Complexity: The iterative nature of the algorithm, especially with the SAA for imperfect CSI, can be computationally intensive. The paper notes that the number of RF chains significantly impacts running time.
  • Future Work Suggestions:
    • Developing a globally optimal algorithm.
  • Designing for low-resolution analog RF beamforming.
  • Exploring joint multivariate compression for RRHs that focus on analog processing.
  • Extending the uplink-downlink duality concept from single-user to multi-user scenarios.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kim2019joint,
  author = {Jaein Kim and Seok-Hwan Park and Osvaldo Simeone and Inkyu Lee and Shlomo Shamai Shitz},
  title = {{Joint Design of Fronthauling and Hybrid Beamforming for Downlink C-RAN Systems}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/tcomm.2019.2903142},
}
Figure