Joint and Individual Component Regression

Peiyao Wang, Haodong Wang, Quefeng Li, Dinggang Shen, Yufeng LiuJ. Comput. Graph. Stat 2022 · DOI · arXiv · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Joint and Individual Component Regression (JICO) model, a novel approach for analyzing heterogeneous multi-group data. JICO decomposes the response variable into shared (global) and group-specific components, offering a flexible framework that can adapt to varying degrees of data heterogeneity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many real-world datasets consist of data from multiple distinct groups, exhibiting heterogeneity. Analyzing such data with traditional methods can be problematic: a single global model might oversimplify and miss group-specific nuances, while separate group-specific models can fail to leverage shared information. The challenge is to develop a statistical model that can effectively capture both the commonalities across groups and the unique characteristics within each group. This is particularly relevant in fields like genomics, where data might come from different platforms, or in medical studies, where subjects can belong to different disease subtypes.

Methods

The core of the JICO model is its decomposition of the response variable into two parts: a "joint" component representing shared information across all groups, and an "individual" component capturing group-specific effects. Both components are driven by low-rank approximations of the predictor variables.

  • Low-Rank Approximations: JICO assumes that the underlying joint and individual structures in the predictors can be represented by low-rank matrices. This allows for efficient modeling and dimensionality reduction.
  • Continuum Regression (CR): To estimate the latent scores (the components that drive the joint and individual structures), the authors leverage Continuum Regression. CR is a flexible framework that unifies several popular regression techniques, including Ordinary Least Squares (OLS), Partial Least Squares (PLS), and Principal Component Regression (PCR), by introducing a tuning parameter. This flexibility allows JICO to adapt to different data structures.
  • Iterative Algorithm: An iterative algorithm is proposed to estimate the model components, alternating between estimating the joint and individual structures. This approach is designed to handle the complexity of simultaneously estimating these components.

Datasets

The paper uses the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) dataset for real-world application. The dataset consists of structural MRI features from 494 subjects across three subgroups: Normal Control (NC), early Mild Cognitive Impairment (eMCI), and Alzheimer's Disease (AD).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Global and Group-Specific Models: JICO offers a spectrum of models, allowing it to smoothly transition between purely global and purely group-specific analyses. This is achieved by adjusting the ranks of the joint and individual components and through the flexibility of the Continuum Regression parameter.
  • Leveraging Shared Information: By explicitly modeling a "joint" component, JICO can effectively utilize information that is common across different groups, leading to more robust and potentially more accurate predictions, especially when group-specific data is limited.
  • Adaptability through CR: The use of Continuum Regression is a key innovation, allowing the model to automatically select an appropriate regression strategy (akin to OLS, PLS, or PCR) based on the data's characteristics, controlled by the parameter $\gamma$.

Key Results

  • Simulation Studies: Extensive simulations demonstrate that JICO performs well across various settings, including those favoring PCR, PLS, and OLS. It consistently achieves optimal or near-optimal performance when using true ranks and adapts effectively to different data structures.
  • ADNI Data Analysis: Application to the ADNI dataset shows that JICO outperforms several standard methods (Ridge, PLS, PCR) in predicting ADAS-Cog scores. Notably, JICO with a tuned $\gamma$ value achieved the smallest overall Mean Squared Error (MSE), highlighting its ability to capture complex group heterogeneity. The analysis also provided visualizations of the joint and individual structures, revealing distinct patterns for individual components across disease groups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While the iterative algorithm is designed to be efficient, selecting tuning parameters (ranks $K$, $K_g$, and $\gamma$) can be computationally intensive, especially with a large number of candidate combinations. The authors suggest choosing smaller ranks for interpretability and using grid search or cross-validation for parameter tuning.
  • Theoretical Guarantees: The paper notes that while the iterative algorithm empirically meets convergence criteria, theoretical guarantees for convergence are not provided.
  • Initial Value Sensitivity: The study in Appendix E suggests that the algorithm's convergence to the same objective function value might depend on the initial values chosen for the individual matrices, particularly when $\gamma = 1$. However, the prediction performance remains similar regardless of the initial values. The authors recommend running the algorithm multiple times with different initial values to ensure the best performance.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that JICO can be extended to other regression algorithms covered by CR and applied to more complex heterogeneous data setups.

Summary updated

Abstract

Multi-group data are commonly seen in practice. Such data structure consists of data from multiple groups and can be challenging to analyze due to data heterogeneity. We propose a novel Joint and Individual Component Regression (JICO) model to analyze multi-group data. In particular, our proposed model decomposes the response into shared and group-specific components, which are driven by low-rank approximations of joint and individual structures from the predictors respectively. The joint structure has the same regression coefficients across multiple groups, whereas individual structures have group-specific regression coefficients. Moreover, the choice of global and individual ranks allows our model to cover global and group-specific models as special cases. For model estimation, we formulate this framework under the representation of latent components and propose an iterative algorithm to solve for the joint and individual scores under the new representation. To construct the latent scores, we utilize the Continuum Regression (CR), which provides a unified framework that covers the Ordinary Least Squares (OLS), the Partial Least Squares (PLS), and the Principal Component Regression (PCR) as its special cases. We show that JICO attains a good balance between global and group-specific models and remains flexible due to the usage of CR. Finally, we conduct simulation studies and analysis of an Alzheimer's disease dataset to further demonstrate the effectiveness of JICO. R implementation of JICO is available online at https://github.com/peiyaow/JICO.
BibTeX
@article{wang2022joint,
  author = {Peiyao Wang and Haodong Wang and Quefeng Li and Dinggang Shen and Yufeng Liu},
  title = {{Joint and Individual Component Regression}},
  journal = {J. Comput. Graph. Stat.},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.48550/arxiv.2209.12388},
}
Figure