John Hopcroft's views on China's education

Weijie Zhao, Zhenjiang HuNational 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This interview with Turing Award winner John Hopcroft offers a critical perspective on China's computer science education, highlighting both its strengths and areas for improvement. Hopcroft suggests that while China excels at producing highly prepared students for top universities, its system needs to shift from an overemphasis on elite programs and research metrics to a broader focus on improving the quality of undergraduate education for all students.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

This paper addresses the challenges and opportunities in improving computer science education in China, as seen through the eyes of a seasoned international educator. Professor John Hopcroft, with over 55 years of teaching experience and significant involvement in upgrading Chinese university education, shares his observations on the differences between Chinese and American educational systems, the effectiveness of current reform efforts, and the future direction of computer science education in China. The core problem is how to elevate the overall quality of computer science education in China to foster a generation of globally competitive and well-rounded individuals, moving beyond a focus on elite programs and publication metrics.

Methods

This paper is an interview, not a traditional research paper with experimental methods. The "method" employed is a structured conversation between National Science Review (NSR) editors and Professor John Hopcroft. The interview format allows for a qualitative exploration of Hopcroft's extensive experience and insights into China's educational landscape. He draws upon his direct involvement with institutions like Shanghai Jiaotong University (SJTU) and Peking University (PKU), his experience teaching in both the US and China, and his broader understanding of global educational trends.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Talent Concentration vs. Distribution: China's top universities attract exceptionally strong incoming freshmen due to intense competition, potentially surpassing those at top US universities. However, over four years, US-educated students often demonstrate greater independence and research initiative.
  • The "Told What to Do" Syndrome: A significant difference observed is that some Chinese students are primarily trained to follow instructions, while their American counterparts are more inclined to explore their own research directions.
  • The Pressure Cooker Environment: The intense pressure in Chinese universities to secure research funding and publish papers creates a challenging environment for junior faculty, hindering both teaching and basic research. This environment also leads to talented faculty leaving China.
  • The Importance of Government Priority: Hopcroft emphasizes that significant educational reform requires top-level government commitment, which he sees as present in China's focus on improving undergraduate education.
  • Beyond Elite Classes: While China's "elite classes" are producing world-class students, they are too small to address the broader educational needs. The focus needs to shift to raising the quality of education for all students.
  • Rethinking University Metrics: Hopcroft advocates for evaluating universities based on the quality of their undergraduate programs rather than solely on international rankings, which are often driven by research funding and publication counts.
  • Separating Applied Research: He suggests that applied research should eventually move out of universities, similar to the US model with institutions like Stanford Research Institute, to allow universities to focus on education and basic research.
  • The Value of Curiosity and Free Exploration: Hopcroft champions basic research and "crazy directions" as drivers of unexpected breakthroughs, emphasizing that learning how to learn is more crucial than memorizing vast amounts of information.
  • Early Childhood Education's Critical Role: The first two years of a child's life are identified as the most critical stage for brain development and the foundation for future learning.
  • The "Why" Behind Deep Learning: Hopcroft is interested in the theoretical foundations of deep learning, not just its applications, highlighting a need for more fundamental research in China.

Key Results

  • Hopcroft has been actively involved in improving computer science education at SJTU for the past 10 years, helping to hire faculty and upgrade teaching quality.
  • He has brought back 20 faculty from the USA to teach in China and plans to hire 10 more.
  • A teaching award for the best Chinese undergraduate computer-science teachers was proposed in 2018, initially evaluating top nine universities and expanding to 50 universities in 2019.
  • The award aims to recognize teachers based on knowledge, material currency, student engagement, and teaching effectiveness, not just research output.
  • Hopcroft believes that improving undergraduate programs will automatically lead to better graduate students and graduate education, though this will take several years.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Current System's Limitations: Hopcroft points out that the current system in China, with its emphasis on publications and funding, can stifle creativity and basic research.
  • Elite Class Scalability: The success of elite classes is limited by their small scale; the challenge is to scale this quality to all students.
  • Language Barrier for Internationalization: Attracting international students is hindered by the language barrier, although translation technology is improving.
  • Transitioning Applied Research: Moving applied research out of universities is a long-term goal that may take 10-20 years to fully implement.
  • Future Focus: Hopcroft plans to focus on undergraduate education first, then move to early childhood education, acknowledging the complexity and expense of the latter.
  • AI as a Tool, Not Intelligence: He stresses that current AI, particularly deep learning, is primarily pattern recognition and not true intelligence. Achieving true understanding of function and content represents the next major revolution.
  • Broader Computer Science Directions: Beyond AI, Hopcroft highlights security, privacy, distributed networks, and information storage as crucial areas for future computer science exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Professor John Hopcroft at Cornell University is a Turing Prize winner (1986) and an educator with more than 55 years of teaching experience. For the past 10 years, Hopcroft has been coming to China to give courses to undergraduate students at Shanghai Jiaotong University (SJTU) and has helped SJTU to improve the quality of computer-science education. He also chairs the Center on Frontiers of Computing Studies at Peking University (PKU), the Turing Class at PKU and the Hopcroft Center at Huazhong University of Science and Technology (HUST) in Wuhan, and is engaged in many other projects aiming to upgrade China's computer-science undergraduate education. Recently, <i>NSR</i> talked with Professor Hopcroft to learn his views on education in China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2020john,
  author = {Weijie Zhao and Zhenjiang Hu},
  title = {{John Hopcroft's views on China's education}},
  booktitle = {National},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1093/nsr/nwaa016},
}
Figure