Jamming Transitions in Amorphous Packings of Frictionless Spheres Occur over a Continuous Range of Volume Fractions

Pinaki Chaudhuri, Ludovic Berthier, Srikanth SastryPhysical 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We numerically produce fully amorphous assemblies of frictionless spheres in three dimensions and study the jamming transition these packings undergo at large volume fractions. We specify four protocols yielding a critical value for the jamming volume fraction which is sharply defined in the limit of large system size, but is different for each protocol. Thus, we directly establish the existence of a continuous range of volume fractions where nonequilibrium jamming transitions occur. However, these jamming transitions share the same critical behavior. Our results suggest that, even in the absence of partial crystalline ordering, a unique location of a random close packing does not exist.

Introduction

In the study of granular matter and glasses, "jamming" is the transition where a disordered collection of particles becomes rigid. For decades, researchers have sought a specific density—the Random Close Packing (RCP) limit—where this transition supposedly occurs for frictionless spheres. However, a conflict emerged in the literature: some studies pointed toward a unique, universal "J-point," while others suggested that the jamming density depends on the preparation protocol. A major confounding factor was whether this variation was simply due to partial crystallization or particle "demixing." This study resolves the debate by investigating whether a unique jamming point exists and if different jammed states share fundamental physical properties.

Methods

The study utilizes numerical simulations of a 3D binary mixture of frictionless spheres with a 1.4 diameter ratio to suppress crystallization. The approach combines thermal and athermal protocols:

  1. Equilibration: Systems are equilibrated at various initial volume fractions ($\phi_{init}$) using Monte Carlo simulations.
  2. Rapid Compression: A very fast compression "pins" the structural history of the fluid.
  3. Athermal Energy Minimization: Particles are treated as soft harmonic spheres, using inflation and conjugate gradient energy minimization to find the zero-energy point.
  4. Decompression Analysis: The jamming threshold ($\phi_J$) is located by fitting energy decay during controlled decompression to a power law.

Simulations were performed for system sizes of $N = 1000$ and $N = 8000$ particles across four distinct initial volume fractions ($\phi_{init}$) ranging from 0.3572 to 0.5935.

Results and Discussion

The "J-Line" and Structural Memory

The most significant finding is that jamming is not a single point but a continuous range of volume fractions, forming a "J-line." The jammed state retains a "memory" of its fluid precursor; subtle structural differences in equilibrated fluids at different $\phi_{init}$ translate into distinct jamming densities. As shown in Figure 1, the jamming volume fraction $\phi_J$ varies significantly depending on the protocol, yet all states collapse onto a single master curve when comparing energy to coordination number.

Figure 1: (a-b) Energy e vs volume fraction ϕ showing protocol-dependent jamming points. (c) Coordination number z vs ϕ. (d) Data collapse of energy e vs z across all protocols.

Universal Critical Behavior

Despite jamming at different densities, the nature of the transition is identical. Every point on the "J-line" exhibits the same critical exponents. At the jamming threshold, all configurations are isostatic ($z \approx 6$). Universal scaling laws are observed: pressure $P$ vanishes linearly with $(\phi - \phi_J)$, and the coordination number $z$ follows a square-root scaling $(z - z_c) \sim \sqrt{\phi - \phi_J}$, as demonstrated in Figure 2.

Figure 2: Scaling of (a) pressure P and (b) excess coordination number z-zJ as a function of distance from the jamming point ϕ-ϕJ, showing universal exponents.

Conclusion

This work establishes that the jamming volume fraction for frictionless spheres varies continuously between approximately 0.648 and 0.662. This suggests that a unique "Random Close Packing" point does not exist even in the absence of crystallization. While the transition density is protocol-dependent, the critical scaling behavior remains universal. Future work may explore how friction expands this range and how these findings reconcile with mean-field theories of the glass transition.

Summary updated

Abstract

We numerically produce fully amorphous assemblies of frictionless spheres in three dimensions and study the jamming transition these packings undergo at large volume fractions. We specify four protocols yielding a critical value for the jamming volume fraction which is sharply defined in the limit of large system size, but is different for each protocol. Thus, we directly establish the existence of a continuous range of volume fractions where nonequilibrium jamming transitions occur. However, these jamming transitions share the same critical behavior. Our results suggest that, even in the absence of partial crystalline ordering, a unique location of a random close packing does not exist.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chaudhuri2010jamming,
  author = {Pinaki Chaudhuri and Ludovic Berthier and Srikanth Sastry},
  title = {{Jamming Transitions in Amorphous Packings of Frictionless Spheres Occur over a Continuous Range of Volume Fractions}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.104.165701},
}
Figure