JamCatcher: A Mobile Jammer Localization Scheme for Advanced Metering Infrastructure in Smart Grid

Taimin Zhang, Xiaoyu Ji, Zhou Zhuang, Wenyuan XuSensors 2019 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces JamCatcher, a novel mobile jammer localization scheme for Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) in smart grids. It addresses the challenge of locating mobile jammers in sparse networks using a mobile tracker, dividing the process into two stages: far-field chasing and near-field capturing, to achieve accurate localization even with limited observation nodes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Smart grids rely heavily on Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) for critical functions like billing and demand response. A significant threat to AMI is jamming attacks, particularly in the Neighborhood Area Network (NAN) where wireless communication is prevalent. These attacks can disrupt monitoring and state estimation, potentially leading to manipulation of the grid. Existing jammer localization methods often struggle with the sparse distribution of smart meters in AMI networks and typically assume stationary jammers. This paper tackles the problem of accurately localizing mobile jammers in these sparse AMI environments, where traditional methods fall short due to limited anchor nodes and potential communication issues.

Methods

JamCatcher employs a two-stage approach for jammer localization:

  • Far-Field Chasing Stage: This initial stage focuses on quickly guiding a mobile tracker (e.g., a drone or robot) towards the general vicinity of the jammer. It utilizes an error-minimizing approach, enhanced with a genetic algorithm (GA), to estimate the jammer's location based on jamming signal strength (JSS) measurements from boundary nodes. The goal here is not precise localization but efficient movement towards the jammer.
  • Near-Field Capturing Stage: Once the tracker is closer to the jammer and within the jammed area, this stage takes over. It uses a combination of a static algorithm (DiffLSQ, a least-squares method) and a dynamic algorithm (LimTrack, employing an Unscented Kalman Filter and Interacting Multiple Model) to refine the jammer's location. The dynamic algorithm leverages the jammer's motion model (using Constant Velocity and Constant Turn models) to handle uncertainty and provide a more accurate estimate, especially when observation nodes are scarce.

A key innovation is the ability to work with a limited number of observation nodes, a common scenario in AMI networks. The system also accounts for the time delay in data transmission, which is crucial in multi-hop communication environments.

Datasets

The paper describes two primary sources of data for evaluation:

  • Real-World Experiment: Experiments were conducted in a 20x30 meter gymnasium using 14 MicaZ nodes and a mobile jammer mounted on a robot. JSS measurements were collected every second. The true jammer location was recorded in real-time using a surveillance camera.
  • MATLAB Simulations: Extensive simulations were performed on a larger scale (500x500 meter AMI network) to evaluate JamCatcher under various conditions, including different node densities, environmental noise levels, and jammer movement patterns (circular, square, and sinusoidal routes).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mobility as an Advantage: Instead of being a hindrance, the jammer's mobility is leveraged by JamCatcher to gather new JSS measurements from different smart meters over time, improving localization accuracy.
  • Two-Stage Localization: The division into far-field chasing and near-field capturing stages is crucial. It allows for efficient initial tracking and then precise localization when the tracker is close to the jammer, adapting to different measurement availability.
  • Sparse Node Tolerance: The core contribution is the ability to achieve good localization accuracy with a significantly lower number of observation nodes compared to existing methods, which is a critical requirement for real-world AMI deployments.
  • Dynamic Modeling for Accuracy: The use of an Interacting Multiple Model (IMM) approach within the Unscented Kalman Filter (UKF) allows the system to adapt to complex jammer movements, leading to more robust localization.

Key Results

  • Real-World Performance: JamCatcher achieved an RMSE of 0.27 m in near-field capturing, outperforming the original ErrMin algorithm (RMSE of 0.31 m), despite using fewer observation nodes (half as many on average).
  • Simulation Performance: In simulations, JamCatcher's RMSE was 5.36 m, significantly better than ALSQ (20.5 m) and comparable to ErrMin (6.50 m), but with a much smaller number of observation nodes (average of 4 for JamCatcher vs. 16 for ALSQ/ErrMin).
  • Node Density Impact: JamCatcher's performance degraded gracefully with decreasing node density, consistently outperforming ALSQ.
  • Robustness to Noise and Path Loss: The method showed good robustness to variations in shadowing effects and path loss exponents, with the dynamic model mitigating the impact of errors in these parameters.
  • Tracking Speed: A tracker-jammer speed ratio of 1.5 or higher was sufficient to achieve a capture rate exceeding 75% in simulations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The paper assumes that jamming attacks can be identified by existing detection mechanisms and that smart meters can accurately measure JSS. The jammer is assumed to be omnidirectional and transmit at a constant power.
  • Tracker Mobility: While the tracker is mobile, its maximum speed is a factor in capture time. Future work could explore optimizing tracker movement strategies.
  • Complex Jamming Scenarios: The current work focuses on single mobile jammers. Future research could extend to scenarios with multiple jammers or more sophisticated jamming techniques.
  • Environmental Variability: While some robustness to environmental factors was shown, further investigation into performance in highly dynamic or unpredictable environments might be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

As the core component of the smart grid, advanced metering infrastructure (AMI) is responsible for automated billing, demand response, load forecasting, management, etc. The jamming attack poses a serious threat to the AMI communication networks, especially the neighborhood area network where wireless technologies are widely adopted to connect a tremendous amount of smart meters. An attacker can easily build a jammer using a software-defined radio and jam the wireless communications between smart meters and local controllers, causing failures of on-line monitoring and state estimation. Accurate jammer localization is the first step for defending AMIs against jamming attacks. In this paper, we propose JamCatcher, a mobile jammer localization scheme for defending the AMI. Unlike existing jammer localization schemes, which only consider stationary jammers and usually require a high density of anchor nodes, the proposed scheme utilizes a tracker and can localize a mobile jammer with sparse anchor nodes. The time delay of data transmission is also considered, and the jammer localization process is divided into two stages, i.e., far-field chasing stage and near-field capturing stage. Different localization algorithms are developed for each stage. The proposed method has been tested with data from both simulation and real-world experiment. The results demonstrate that JamCatcher outperforms existing jammer localization algorithms with a limited number of anchor nodes in the AMI scenario.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2019jamcatcher,
  author = {Taimin Zhang and Xiaoyu Ji and Zhou Zhuang and Wenyuan Xu},
  title = {{JamCatcher: A Mobile Jammer Localization Scheme for Advanced Metering Infrastructure in Smart Grid}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=4sSyQBLBixMO},
}
Figure