Jahn–Teller and Non-Jahn–Teller Systems Involving CuF64– Units: Role of the Internal Electric Field in Ba2ZnF6:Cu2+ and Other Insulating Systems

J. A. Aramburu, Pablo García‐Fernández, J. M. García‐Lastra, M. MorenoThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that the standard Jahn-Teller (JT) framework often fails to explain the behavior of transition metal ions in non-cubic crystal structures. By incorporating the effect of the internal electric field from surrounding ions, the authors successfully reproduce experimental data for Cu<sup>2+</sup> in Ba<sub>2</sub>ZnF<sub>6</sub>, demonstrating that this field, not just the JT effect, dictates the system's properties and can even prevent the characteristic distortions of a JT system.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Jahn-Teller (JT) effect is a fundamental concept in solid-state physics and chemistry, explaining how degenerate electronic states in transition metal ions can lead to structural distortions, lowering the system's symmetry and stabilizing it. This effect is widely used to interpret the properties of many transition metal compounds, particularly those with d<sup>9</sup> electron configurations like Cu<sup>2+</sup>. However, the authors highlight a discrepancy: while the JT framework is often applied to systems with non-octahedral local symmetry, its applicability and the resulting predictions don't always align with experimental observations, especially in tetragonal lattices. Specifically, for Cu<sup>2+</sup> in tetragonal systems like Ba<sub>2</sub>ZnF<sub>6</sub>, experimental data (like EPR spectra and optical transitions) don't fit the expected JT behavior, particularly regarding the ground state electronic configuration and the presence of three equivalent distortions. This paper aims to resolve this discrepancy by investigating the role of the internal electric field generated by the surrounding crystal lattice on the impurity ion, which is often neglected in simpler JT models.

Methods

The researchers employed first-principle calculations using Density Functional Theory (DFT). They utilized the CRYSTAL (version 14) code for periodic supercell calculations to model the Ba<sub>2</sub>ZnF<sub>6</sub> host lattice with diluted Cu<sup>2+</sup> impurities. To accurately capture the electronic structure and excited states, they also employed the Amsterdam density functional (ADF) code for cluster calculations. A key aspect of their methodology was the explicit inclusion of the internal electric field, ER(r), generated by the surrounding lattice ions. This field was incorporated into the cluster calculations by using point charges derived from the periodic calculations. They investigated various electronic configurations and distorted geometries to compare with experimental data.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations and comparison with existing experimental data from literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Internal Electric Field is Crucial: The study strongly emphasizes that the internal electric field (ER(r)) from the surrounding lattice ions plays a dominant role in determining the properties of transition metal ions in non-cubic lattices, often more so than the traditional Jahn-Teller effect.
  • JT Framework Limitations: The standard JT framework, which assumes a perfectly octahedral starting point and focuses on orbital degeneracy-driven distortions, is insufficient for understanding systems like Ba<sub>2</sub>ZnF<sub>6</sub>:Cu<sup>2+</sup>.
  • Anomalous Ground State Explained: The unusual compressed ground state of Cu<sup>2+</sup> in Ba<sub>2</sub>ZnF<sub>6</sub>, where the unpaired electron resides in the a<sub>1g</sub>(~3z<sup>2</sup>-r<sup>2</sup>) orbital (contrary to the b<sub>1g</sub>(~x<sup>2</sup>-y<sup>2</sup>) orbital in cubic systems), is directly attributed to the anisotropic nature of the internal electric field.
  • Suppression of JT Distortions: The significant internal electric field in Ba<sub>2</sub>ZnF<sub>6</sub> creates a substantial energy gap between the relevant orbitals, which can be larger than typical JT stabilization energies. This effectively "prevents" the characteristic three equivalent distortions expected in a static JT effect.
  • Quasi-JT vs. Internal Field Effects: While a quasi-JT effect can occur under specific strain conditions in cubic lattices, the strong internal field in tetragonal lattices like Ba<sub>2</sub>ZnF<sub>6</sub> fundamentally alters the system's behavior, ruling out a quasi-JT explanation.

Key Results

  • Reproducing Experimental Data: By including the internal electric field, the calculations successfully reproduced the experimental d-d transition energies for Cu<sup>2+</sup> in Ba<sub>2</sub>ZnF<sub>6</sub>, which could not be achieved with isolated cluster calculations.
  • Internal Field Gap: The internal electric field ER(r) creates an energy gap (Δ<sub>0</sub> ≈ 0.35 eV) between the b<sub>1g</sub>(~x<sup>2</sup>-y<sup>2</sup>) and a<sub>1g</sub>(~3z<sup>2</sup>-r<sup>2</sup>) orbitals, even when the CuF<sub>6</sub><sup>4-</sup> complex is geometrically octahedral.
  • Anomalous Ground State: The calculations confirm that the ground state for Cu<sup>2+</sup> in Ba<sub>2</sub>ZnF<sub>6</sub> involves the hole in the a<sub>1g</sub>(~3z<sup>2</sup>-r<sup>2</sup>) level, leading to a compressed geometry, a direct consequence of the internal field.
  • Absence of Quasi-JT: The study concludes that Ba<sub>2</sub>ZnF<sub>6</sub>:Cu<sup>2+</sup> does not exhibit a quasi-JT effect due to the strong influence of the internal electric field, which significantly modifies the JT pattern.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The authors acknowledge that while their approach significantly improves upon simpler models, the interpretation of experimental data should avoid overly simplified models unless their assumptions are rigorously justified.
  • Future Work on Other Systems: The paper suggests that similar investigations into the role of internal electric fields are needed for other transition metal ions in various insulating lattices, particularly for square-planar complexes where higher extrinsic contributions are expected.
  • Orthorhombic Minima: The paper speculates that if orthorhombic minima were to exist in such systems, their explanation would likely require a full pseudo Jahn-Teller model, indicating a potential avenue for future theoretical exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

The applicability of the Jahn–Teller (JT) framework to 6-fold coordinated d9 ions whose local symmetry is not strictly octahedral is explored by means of first principle calculations. Our results contradict much of the existing literature where these systems are analyzed within the quasi-JT regime which assumes the usual JT description with a small splitting between b1g(∼x2–y2) and a1g(∼3z2–r2) orbitals and also the existence of three nearly equivalent distortions. To clarify this issue we investigate the equilibrium geometry (equatorial, Req, and axial, Rax, Cu2+–F– distances) and optical transitions for CuF64– units formed in Cu2+-doped the tetragonal Ba2ZnF6 host lattice. While the experimental d–d transitions cannot be reproduced through the isolated CuF64– unit at the equilibrium geometry, a reasonable agreement is reached adding in the calculation the internal electric field, ER(r), created by the rest of lattice ions on the electrons confined in the complex. It is shown that this tetragonal field, ER(r), already produces a gap Δ0 ∼ 0.35 eV between b1g(∼x2–y2) and a1g(∼3z2–r2) orbitals of Ba2ZnF6:Cu2+ when Rax = Req. Nevertheless, as this internal field leads to a Δ0 value higher than typical JT barriers it drastically modifies the characteristic pattern of a JT effect. In particular, it prevents the existence of three equivalent distortions as confirmed by experimental EPR data. Furthermore, ER(r) is shown to be the main physical reason behind an unusual compressed ground state with the hole in the a1g(∼3z2–r2) level while it is always placed in the b1g(∼x2–y2) level for MX6 complexes (M = Cu2+, Ag2+, Ni+; X = F–, Cl–) in cubic lattices displaying a static JT effect. While the experimental results of CuF64– in Ba2ZnF6 cannot be understood within the JT framework it is pointed out that a quasi-JT situation can however happen for a d9 ion in a cubic lattice under a strain of ∼10–3 in agreement with experimental data. The present results stress the key role played by the internal electric fields for a quantitative understanding of compounds with transition metal cations. Moreover, they also demonstrate that in the interpretation of experimental data the use of a simple model should be avoided unless all its assumptions are well justified.
BibTeX
@article{aramburu2017jahnteller,
  author = {J. A. Aramburu and Pablo García‐Fernández and J. M. García‐Lastra and M. Moreno},
  title = {{Jahn–Teller and Non-Jahn–Teller Systems Involving CuF<sub>6</sub><sup>4–</sup> Units: Role of the Internal Electric Field in Ba<sub>2</sub>ZnF<sub>6</sub>:Cu<sup>2+</sup> and Other Insulating Systems}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpcc.6b11999},
}
Figure