TL;DR
This paper tackles the challenge of "clickbait spoiling" – extracting the actual content (spoiler) that a clickbait headline teases. The authors propose a zero-shot approach using pre-trained language models, notably by rephrasing clickbait titles into questions to better suit Question Answering (QA) models. Their system achieves satisfactory results without any task-specific fine-tuning, demonstrating the potential of prompt-based methods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Clickbait headlines are designed to pique curiosity and entice users to click, often by being vague or sensational. The "Clickbait Spoiling" task, as defined in SemEval-2023 Task 5, aims to automatically extract the specific piece of information (the spoiler) from an article that satisfies this induced curiosity. This spoiler can be a short phrase, a contiguous passage, or multiple disjoint parts. A key challenge is that clickbait titles are rarely phrased as questions, which is the typical input format for powerful pre-trained Question Answering (QA) models. Furthermore, article texts can be very long, exceeding the input limits of these models, requiring a strategy to select the most relevant content. Existing approaches often rely on fine-tuning models specifically for this task, which can be time-consuming and require extensive labeled data. This paper explores a zero-shot approach, leveraging pre-trained models without any fine-tuning, to address these challenges.
Methods
The authors' system is built around three core components, all leveraging pre-trained models:
- Clickbait Title Rephrasing: To bridge the gap between clickbait titles and QA model expectations, they automatically rephrase titles into questions. This is done using a pre-trained language model (Flan-T5) with a specific prompt. To ensure the rephrased question remains relevant, its semantic similarity to the original title is checked using Sentence-BERT. If the rephrasing is deemed poor (low similarity), the original title is used.
- Relevance-based Context Ordering: To handle long article texts, they propose a method to select and order the most relevant sentences. Sentences from the article are embedded using Sentence-BERT and then sorted based on their semantic similarity to the clickbait title. The top-ranked sentences are then concatenated to form the model's context.
- Pre-trained QA-capable Model: The system utilizes pre-trained models that can perform Question Answering. This includes both traditional extractive QA models (DeBERTa, RoBERTa) and text generation models (Flan-T5, UnifiedQA) used in a zero-shot prompting setting. They explore different prompt templates, including one specifically designed for spoiler extraction and another for general question answering.
The final model's configuration (whether to use title rephrasing, context ordering, and which specific QA-capable model/prompt) is determined based on performance on the validation set for each spoiler type (phrase, passage, multi).
Datasets
The primary dataset used is the SemEval-2023 Task 5 dataset, which consists of clickbait titles, corresponding article texts, and the ground truth spoilers with their positions. This dataset was used for both validation and testing. No new datasets were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Rephrasing Titles as Questions is Beneficial: The most significant finding is that automatically rephrasing clickbait titles into questions generally improves the performance of zero-shot QA models, especially for phrase-type spoilers. This suggests that even without fine-tuning, aligning input formats with model pre-training objectives can yield substantial gains.
- Relevance-based Context Ordering is Often Detrimental: Counter-intuitively, sorting article sentences by semantic similarity to the clickbait title decreased performance. The authors hypothesize that spoilers are often found in the initial sentences, and their reordering approach might miss them or confuse the model. This highlights that simple semantic similarity might not be the best proxy for relevance in this context.
- Dedicated QA Models Outperform Text Generation Models (in Zero-Shot): While text generation models show promise, dedicated QA models (like DeBERTa) generally performed better in this zero-shot setting. This could be because QA models are more specialized for the task they were trained on, whereas text generation models are more general-purpose and rely heavily on prompt engineering.
- Prompt Engineering Matters: For text generation models, the choice of prompt template significantly impacts performance, suggesting that careful prompt design is crucial for effective zero-shot task adaptation.
Key Results
The paper reports results using the BLEU-4 score. While not achieving the performance of fine-tuned models, the zero-shot system achieved satisfactory results. For instance, the final hybrid model, which selectively applied title rephrasing and used DeBERTa for phrase/passage spoilers and Flan-T5 for multi-type spoilers, showed competitive performance. The authors note that their official submissions were among the top ten teams for most metrics and top five for phrase spoiling.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that their zero-shot approach, while promising, does not reach the performance of fine-tuned models. They also found that relevance-based context ordering was not effective, suggesting a need for more sophisticated methods to identify relevant context. Future work could explore more advanced prompt engineering for text generation models, investigate larger language models (like GPT-3 or OPT), and develop more effective relevance measures for context selection.
Summary updated