IXV post-flight reconstruction and analysis of the aerothermodynamic measurements along the rarefied portion of the reentry trajectory

Marc Schouler, Ysolde Prévereaud, Luc MieussensInternational Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a detailed analysis of the Intermediate eXperimental Vehicle (IXV) reentry data, focusing on the rarefied portion of its trajectory. By comparing experimental heat flux data with advanced computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) simulations, the authors identify key factors influencing reentry aerothermodynamics and highlight the challenges in accurately modeling these extreme conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately predicting and understanding the aerothermodynamic conditions during atmospheric reentry is crucial for the design of safe and effective spacecraft. This is particularly challenging in the rarefied flow regime, where traditional continuum fluid dynamics models break down. The IXV mission provided a unique opportunity to gather in-flight data during such a phase. However, validating computational models against this data, especially in the transitional and rarefied regimes, requires sophisticated numerical techniques and a thorough understanding of various physical phenomena like gas-surface interactions and chemical kinetics. This paper aims to bridge this gap by performing a detailed post-flight analysis of the IXV's rarefied reentry phase, comparing experimental data with state-of-the-art simulations.

Methods

The authors employed two primary computational approaches:

  • Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC): This particle-based method is well-suited for simulating rarefied and transitional flows where intermolecular collisions are infrequent. They used the SPARTA code, carefully setting up simulations to meet stringent time and space convergence criteria. A sensitivity analysis was performed on various parameters, including the accommodation coefficient, chemical kinetic models, and collision models.
  • Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): For the near-continuum regime at 90 km, they used the ONERA code CEDRE, employing a Navier-Stokes solver with a chemical non-equilibrium model. This allowed for a comparison between continuum and kinetic approaches.

A key aspect of the analysis involved comparing the numerical results with experimental data from the IXV's thermocouples. An inverse method was used to reconstruct the convective heat flux from temperature measurements.

Datasets

  • IXV Flight Data: Experimental heat flux data collected from 20 thermocouples on the IXV vehicle during its reentry trajectory.
  • Atmospheric Models: The MSISE-00 model was used to provide atmospheric conditions (density, temperature, species fractions) based on flight parameters.
  • Reference Trajectories: Data from the Space Transportation System (STS) missions were used for trajectory comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Accommodation Coefficient Dominance at High Altitudes: The study highlights that at higher altitudes (more rarefied conditions), the gas-surface interaction, specifically the accommodation coefficient, plays a dominant role in determining heat flux. Lower accommodation coefficients lead to significantly smaller heat fluxes.
  • Altitude-Dependent Sensitivity: The sensitivity of the heat flux to various parameters (accommodation coefficient, density) decreases as the vehicle descends and the flow becomes less rarefied.
  • Instrumentation Reliability Concerns: Anomalies in some high-altitude sensor data raise questions about their reliability, suggesting a need for improved instrumentation in future high-altitude flight experiments.
  • DSMC vs. CFD Discrepancies: While both DSMC and CFD methods showed good agreement in aerodynamic coefficients at 90 km, significant differences were observed in shock layer position and thickness, likely due to the continuum breakdown and thermal equilibrium assumptions in CFD.
  • Chemical Kinetics Impact: The influence of chemical reaction models on heat flux was found to be minor, primarily localized to the nose region where thermal conditions are most severe.
  • Free Stream Density Uncertainty: Uncertainties in free stream density, especially at higher altitudes, can significantly impact heat flux predictions.

Key Results

  • Heat Flux Comparison: DSMC simulations generally predicted higher heat fluxes than the experimental data, particularly at lower altitudes. However, by adjusting the accommodation coefficient, a better agreement was achieved in specific regions.
  • Aerodynamic Coefficients: At 90 km, both DSMC and CFD provided good agreement for aerodynamic coefficients, with minor differences attributed to collision models and solver assumptions.
  • CFD vs. DSMC Shock Layer: CFD predicted a thinner and closer-to-the-wall shock layer compared to DSMC at 90 km, indicating a significant difference in how the continuum and kinetic methods capture the flow physics in this transitional regime.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: The study quantified the impact of various parameters, showing that the accommodation coefficient and free stream density were the most influential factors for heat flux prediction, especially at higher altitudes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Instrumentation Reliability: The paper points out potential issues with the reliability of some flight sensors at high altitudes, which limits the accuracy of the experimental data for validation.
  • CFD Thermal Equilibrium: The assumption of thermal equilibrium in the CFD solver is a significant limitation, especially in regions of continuum breakdown, leading to discrepancies with DSMC.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest the need for improved high-altitude flight experiments with more reliable sensors. They also emphasize the importance of accurately knowing atmospheric conditions and further investigating the impact of transport properties and continuum breakdown criteria in CFD for better agreement with DSMC and experimental data. Further research is needed to reconcile the differences between CFD and DSMC, particularly in the rarefied and transitional regimes.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{schouler2021ixv,
  author = {Marc Schouler and Ysolde Prévereaud and Luc Mieussens},
  title = {{IXV post-flight reconstruction and analysis of the aerothermodynamic measurements along the rarefied portion of the reentry trajectory}},
  journal = {International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2021.121582},
}
Figure