It’s Not Just Conflict That Motivates Killing of Orangutans

Jacqueline Davis, Kerrie Mengersen, Nicola K. Abram, Marc Ancrenaz, Jessie A. Wells, Erik MeijaardPLoS 2013 · DOI

Abstract: We investigated why orangutans are being killed in Kalimantan, Indonesia, and the role of conflict in these killings. Based on an analysis of interview data from over 5,000 respondents in over 450 villages, we also assessed the socio-ecological factors associated with conflict and non-conflict killings. Most respondents never kill orangutans. Those who reported having personally killed an orangutan primarily did so for non-conflict reasons; for example, 56% of these respondents said that the reason they had killed an orangutan was to eat it. Of the conflict-related reasons for killing, the most common reasons orangutans were killed was fear of orangutans or in self-defence. A similar pattern was evident among reports of orangutan killing by other people in the villages. Regression analyses indicated that religion and the percentage of intact forest around villages were the strongest socio-ecological predictors of whether orangutans were killed for conflict or non-conflict related reasons. Our data indicate that between 44,170 and 66,570 orangutans were killed in Kalimantan within the respondents' active hunting lifetimes. These findings confirm that habitat protection alone will not ensure the survival of orangutans in Indonesian Borneo, and that effective reduction of orangutan killings is urgently needed.

The Challenge to the Conflict Narrative

The Bornean orangutan is in a state of alarming decline. Traditionally, conservation strategies have focused on habitat loss and human-wildlife conflict—the idea that as forests are cleared for plantations, orangutans are forced onto farms, leading to retaliatory killings. However, this study challenges that narrative. By analyzing interview data from over 5,000 respondents in Kalimantan, Indonesia, researchers discovered that the majority of killings are actually motivated by non-conflict reasons, most notably hunting for food.

Methods and Study Scope

The researchers utilized a massive socio-ecological dataset derived from interviews conducted across 476 villages in Kalimantan.

Map of the study area in Kalimantan showing village locations and land cover types.

To analyze the complex relationships between social factors and killing motivations, they employed machine-learning techniques, including Boosted Regression Trees (BRT) to identify the strongest predictors of killing and Classification and Regression Trees (CART) to visualize the "decision paths" leading to different types of killings (e.g., for food vs. self-defense).

Key Insights: Why are Orangutans Killed?

The study reframes the orangutan not just as a victim of industrial expansion, but as a target of traditional hunting. Among those who admitted to personally killing an orangutan, 56% cited food as the primary reason.

Reported reasons for killing orangutans, showing that hunting for food is the most frequent motivation.

While fear and self-defense were the most common conflict reasons, they were significantly outweighed by non-conflict motivations in the aggregate data.

Socio-Ecological Predictors

  • Religion: This was the strongest predictor. Muslim villagers were significantly less likely to kill orangutans for food due to dietary taboos. Non-conflict killings were higher in areas with larger Christian or traditional belief populations.
  • The Intact Forest Paradox: Counter-intuitively, non-conflict killings were more likely in areas with more intact forest. This suggests that hunters spend more time in these areas seeking other game and kill orangutans opportunistically.

Key Results and Mortality Estimates

  • Estimated Mortality: The study estimates that between 44,170 and 66,570 orangutans were killed in Kalimantan within the active hunting lifetimes of the respondents.
  • Conflict vs. Non-Conflict: Non-conflict killings (est. 26,361–41,688) significantly outnumbered conflict-related killings (est. 12,690–29,024).
  • Prevalence: 26% of surveyed villages reported at least one orangutan killed in the year prior to the survey.

Implications for Conservation

The estimated number of killings is staggering, potentially exceeding some total population estimates for the species. This suggests that current populations are being depleted at an unsustainable rate.

The authors argue for a shift in strategy. Habitat protection is insufficient on its own; direct intervention to reduce hunting is critical. Conservation efforts must move beyond "fencing off" forests to include cultural engagement, education, and law enforcement tailored to specific ethnic and religious contexts where hunting for food is prevalent.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigated why orangutans are being killed in Kalimantan, Indonesia, and the role of conflict in these killings. Based on an analysis of interview data from over 5,000 respondents in over 450 villages, we also assessed the socio-ecological factors associated with conflict and non-conflict killings. Most respondents never kill orangutans. Those who reported having personally killed an orangutan primarily did so for non-conflict reasons; for example, 56% of these respondents said that the reason they had killed an orangutan was to eat it. Of the conflict-related reasons for killing, the most common reasons orangutans were killed was fear of orangutans or in self-defence. A similar pattern was evident among reports of orangutan killing by other people in the villages. Regression analyses indicated that religion and the percentage of intact forest around villages were the strongest socio-ecological predictors of whether orangutans were killed for conflict or non-conflict related reasons. Our data indicate that between 44,170 and 66,570 orangutans were killed in Kalimantan within the respondents' active hunting lifetimes: between 12,690 and 29,024 for conflict reasons (95%CI) and between 26,361 and 41,688 for non-conflict reasons (95% CI). These findings confirm that habitat protection alone will not ensure the survival of orangutans in Indonesian Borneo, and that effective reduction of orangutan killings is urgently needed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{davis2013its,
  author = {Jacqueline Davis and Kerrie Mengersen and Nicola K. Abram and Marc Ancrenaz and Jessie A. Wells and Erik Meijaard},
  title = {{It’s Not Just Conflict That Motivates Killing of Orangutans}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0075373},
}
Figure