Iterative Learning-Based Negative Effect Compensation Control of Disturbance to Improve the Disturbance Isolation of System

Xiantao Li, Lu Wang, Xianqi Xia, Yuzhang Liu, Bao ZhangSensors 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel control strategy, NECOD+ILC, for improving the disturbance isolation of aviation photoelectric stabilization platforms. By combining iterative learning control (ILC) to suppress periodic cogging torque and a new negative effect compensation of disturbance (NECOD) method for residual disturbances, the system achieves significantly higher pointing accuracy and robustness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aviation photoelectric stabilization platforms are crucial for accurate targeting and imaging in aerospace and defense. However, their performance is often limited by disturbances, particularly the cogging torque of permanent magnet synchronous motors (PMSMs) used for driving. This periodic disturbance directly impacts pointing accuracy, especially for long-distance, high-precision applications. Existing methods like Active Disturbance Rejection Control (ADRC) and traditional iterative learning control (ILC) have limitations in fully suppressing these disturbances or are complex to tune. This paper aims to develop a more effective and robust control strategy to overcome these challenges.

Methods

The proposed solution, NECOD+ILC, combines two key techniques:

  • Off-line Iterative Learning Control (ILC): This method is used to specifically target and suppress the position-periodic cogging torque of the PMSM. ILC works by learning from past performance over repeated cycles, effectively memorizing and compensating for predictable, position-dependent disturbances. The paper uses an "offline" approach where the learned compensation is applied based on motor position.
  • Negative Effect Compensation of Disturbance (NECOD): This is a novel control strategy designed to suppress residual disturbances that remain after ILC compensation, as well as other real-time disturbances. A key advantage of NECOD is that it does not require prior knowledge of the system model or direct measurement of the disturbance. It achieves compensation through additional feedback links, aiming to cancel out the negative effects of disturbances. The paper also introduces a parameter 'b' in the feedback loop for further adjustment and optimization.

The paper also compares NECOD+ILC against classical ADRC and ADRC+ILC.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted on an aviation photoelectric stabilization platform.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Control: Combining ILC for predictable periodic disturbances (cogging torque) with NECOD for unpredictable residual disturbances offers a powerful, multi-faceted approach to disturbance rejection.
  • Model-Free NECOD: The NECOD method's ability to compensate for disturbances without relying on a precise system model is a significant advantage for practical engineering applications, simplifying tuning and implementation.
  • Robustness to Parameter Perturbations: The NECOD+ILC strategy demonstrates remarkable resilience to changes in system parameters (up to ±15%), maintaining high performance, which is crucial for real-world systems operating under varying conditions.
  • Simplified Tuning: Compared to ADRC, NECOD+ILC is highlighted as having fewer parameters and being easier to adjust, making it more amenable to engineering deployment.

Key Results

  • Improved Pointing Accuracy: The NECOD+ILC strategy significantly improved the Line-of-Sight (LOS) pointing accuracy compared to ADRC and ADRC+ILC.
  • Under static conditions, the mean LOS pointing error was reduced by approximately 54% compared to ADRC and 32% compared to ADRC+ILC.
  • Under dynamic (swing) conditions, the mean LOS pointing error was reduced by approximately 70% compared to ADRC and 42% compared to ADRC+ILC.
  • Reduced Overshoot: The NECOD+ILC strategy exhibited less overshoot during trapezoidal wave tracking compared to ADRC+ILC and ADRC.
  • Strong Robustness: Even with ±15% parameter perturbation, the LOS pointing error increased by less than 5% for the NECOD+ILC scheme, demonstrating its robustness.
  • ILC Effectiveness: The ILC component alone showed a significant improvement in speed error (±0.5°/s after the third iteration) for periodic disturbances.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameter Tuning: While NECOD is presented as having simpler parameter adjustment than ADRC, the paper mentions that the parameter 'b' in the NECOD feedback loop can be further optimized in combination with the stability of the system during commissioning.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest that this control scheme lays a foundation for subsequent research into higher-precision control schemes for such platforms. The paper implies that further optimization and application to more complex scenarios could be explored.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{li2022iterative,
  author = {Xiantao Li and Lu Wang and Xianqi Xia and Yuzhang Liu and Bao Zhang},
  title = {{Iterative Learning-Based Negative Effect Compensation Control of Disturbance to Improve the Disturbance Isolation of System}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22093464},
}
Figure