ISPs’ Duty of Care in Copyright Infringement

Yu–Kai WangAMS 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This dissertation argues for a paradigm shift in digital copyright law: moving Internet Service Providers (ISPs) from a passive "safe harbor" role to a proactive "duty of care." By analyzing the legal landscapes of the US, EU, and China, the research proposes a systematic framework where ISPs must take reasonable technological steps to prevent infringement, rather than simply waiting for a takedown notice.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Since the late 1990s, the "Safe Harbor" mechanism (codified in the US DMCA and the EU E-Commerce Directive) has been the bedrock of the internet. It protects ISPs from liability for their users' copyright infringements, provided they "notice and take down" illegal content when alerted.

However, the author argues that this system was designed for a "young" internet that no longer exists. Today, the sheer scale and speed of digital dissemination make it impossible for right holders to police the web alone. While ISPs benefit from the massive data flows generated by user-uploaded content, the current legal regime allows them to remain "willfully blind" until a specific notice arrives. The paper tackles the central question: To what extent should an ISP be legally obligated to actively prevent infringement through its services?

Methods

The author employs a multi-disciplinary approach to build a case for a proactive duty of care:

  • Legal Dogmatic and Comparative Research: A deep dive into the statutes and judicial opinions of three representative systems: the US, the EU, and China.
  • Theoretical Analysis: The paper bridges the gap between the German "general duty of care" (Verkehrssicherungspflichten) and the Common Law "reasonable person" standard (the Caparo test).
  • Economic and Utilitarian Analysis: Using the Kaldor-Hicks improvement theory, the author argues that the risks and losses of technological progress should be shared by the entities that profit from them (ISPs), rather than falling solely on creators.
  • Empirical Research: A quantitative study of Chinese judicial decisions from 2015 to 2017 to map how courts are already moving toward imposing higher duties on ISPs in practice.

Datasets

The primary dataset for the empirical portion of the paper was sourced from IPhouse, a leading database for intellectual property cases in China.

  • Scope: The author analyzed cases involving the "Right of Dissemination on Information Networks" from 2015–2017.
  • Sample Size: Out of over 30,000 initial cases, the author filtered for those specifically discussing "duty of care," eventually focusing on a qualified sample of 111 first-instance and 55 second-instance cases where the ISP played an intermediary role.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Safe Harbor" is Leaking: The research reveals that courts worldwide are already "drilling holes" in safe harbor protections. Judicial trends show a move toward requiring "constructive knowledge"—meaning ISPs are held liable if they should have known about infringement based on the circumstances.
  • Proximity Matters: The author proposes that the level of duty should be proportional to the ISP's "proximity" to the infringement. A "mere conduit" (like an ISP providing raw internet access) should have a lower duty than a hosting platform that organizes and profits from user-uploaded content.
  • Technology as the Solution: A major "aha moment" is the argument that technological problems require technological responses. The author defends the use of filtering and content-recognition technologies (like Google’s Content ID), arguing they are not "general monitoring" but a necessary evolution of the duty of care.
  • The Anonymity Paradox: The paper highlights that the internet’s anonymity is the greatest obstacle to enforcement. Therefore, a key part of an ISP’s duty of care is the obligation to assist in identifying repeat infringers.

Key Results

  • Judicial Proactivity in China: The empirical analysis found that 75% of first-instance cases and 67% of second-instance cases in China already support a "proactive" duty of care for ISPs.
  • Administrative Force: In China, the "Network Sward" (Jian Wang) actions—campaign-style administrative enforcements—often impose a much higher standard of care on ISPs than the written statutes, effectively replacing the safe harbor in certain sectors like music and video.
  • EU Policy Alignment: The author provides strong theoretical support for Article 13 (now Article 17) of the EU’s Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market, which shifts the burden to platforms to obtain licenses or ensure the unavailability of infringing works.

Limitations and Future Work

The author acknowledges several critical tensions:

  • Privacy vs. Enforcement: Proactive monitoring and the disclosure of user information inherently threaten user privacy and data protection. The author suggests these measures must be "appropriate and proportionate" but admits the line is difficult to draw.
  • The "Small Business" Burden: While giants like Google can afford sophisticated filtering, a high duty of care could stifle innovation for smaller startups. The paper suggests a need for flexible standards based on the scale of the ISP.
  • AI and the Future: The conclusion briefly touches on the advent of AI-generated content, noting that as machines become "creators," the current man-powered legal mechanisms will face even greater challenges, marking a clear path for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

This dissertation discussed the ISP’s duty of care in copyright infringement. The duty hereon refers to the ISP’s legal obligation to take care of the influence of the provided service on the protection of others’ copyright. The duty is divided into three sub-categories: the duty of general prevention, the duty of assistance in specific infringement and the duty to deal with repeated infringement. In order to provide a comprehensive and systematic explanation of the duty, four main aspects are logically discussed: the background, the status quo, the justification, and the specific application.
\nIn addition to the traditional mechanism of notice and take down, it is asserted that the ISP should play a more active role in dealing with the users’ online infringement. In particular, the ISP should be imposed on a legal obligation to keep neutral actually and to have general control of the infringing activities through their service. Thereby, the application of the filtering technologies should not be refused as a whole, but should be limited from the perspective of the purpose, the scope as well as the efficacy. Accordingly, the fundamental orientation of the Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on Copyright in the Digital Single Market is supported by this dissertation. At the same time, it is recommended to adopt the application of the duty of general prevention on the ISPs providing platforms instead of recognizing the service itself as communicating to the public.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2019isps,
  author = {Yu–Kai Wang},
  title = {{ISPs’ Duty of Care in Copyright Infringement}},
  booktitle = {AMS},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.6092/unibo/amsdottorato/8912},
}

Loading related content...

Figure