Isolation of Yeast Strains with Higher Proline Uptake and Their Applications to Beer Fermentation

Ryoya Tanahashi, Akira Nishimura, Minh Nguyen, Irnayuli R. Sitepu, Glen Fox, Kyria Boundy‐Mills, Hiroshi TakagiJournal of Fungi 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the issue of proline accumulation in beer, which can lead to undesirable bitterness and haze. Researchers screened yeast strains from the Phaff Yeast Culture Collection and identified two Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains (UCDFST 40-144 and 68-44) that effectively consume proline while still producing sufficient alcohol for beer fermentation, offering a path to improved beer quality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Proline is a significant amino acid found in wort, the liquid extracted from malt during brewing. However, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the primary yeast used in beer fermentation, doesn't fully consume proline. This leads to high proline concentrations in the final beer, which can negatively impact its quality by contributing to bitterness, a low-acid taste, and potentially causing haze through interactions with polyphenols. While some non-Saccharomyces yeasts can utilize proline, they often lack the alcohol production capabilities needed for brewing. The challenge, therefore, is to find yeast strains that can efficiently metabolize proline during fermentation without compromising alcohol yield, thereby improving the overall sensory profile of beer.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage screening process to identify suitable yeast strains. Initially, they utilized an optimized isatin colorimetric assay to rapidly measure residual proline levels in culture supernatants. This assay was validated for its effectiveness in both nitrogen-deficient and nitrogen-rich media, including a synthetic complete medium and a wort-based beer fermentation model.

The screening involved two phases:

  1. Small-scale screening: 205 yeast strains from the Phaff Yeast Culture Collection were cultured in a proline-rich medium, and proline consumption was assessed after 48 hours using the isatin assay.
  2. Large-scale screening: Promising candidates from the initial screen (those showing significant proline reduction) were further evaluated in a larger volume of proline-rich medium.

Finally, the most effective proline-utilizing strains, particularly S. cerevisiae strains, were tested in a beer fermentation model using 10 °P wort. During these fermentation tests, residual proline, alcohol content (ABV), and original extract (Plato) were measured. Alcohol content was determined using an alcolyzer, and proline was quantified using an amino acid analyzer. Statistical analysis, specifically Student's t-test, was used to evaluate the significance of the results.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study consists of 205 yeast strains obtained from the Phaff Yeast Culture Collection at the University of California, Davis. These strains were isolated from various environments, including beer and wine fermentations. The paper also references supplementary tables (Table S1, S2, S3) which list the strains used, their genera, and their performance in the screenings. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Isatin Assay Versatility: The study successfully demonstrated that the isatin colorimetric assay, previously optimized for nitrogen-deficient conditions, is also effective for measuring proline in nitrogen-rich media like synthetic complete media and wort, making it a valuable tool for screening in brewing contexts.
  • Proline Accumulation is Common: A significant portion of the screened yeasts, including many S. cerevisiae strains, showed little to no proline consumption, confirming that proline accumulation is a widespread issue in fermentation.
  • Non-Saccharomyces Potential, But Limitations: While several non-Saccharomyces genera (e.g., Zygoascus, Galactomyces, Magnusiomyces) showed proline utilization, their low alcohol productivity rendered them unsuitable for typical beer fermentation.
  • Targeted S. cerevisiae Strains: The identification of specific S. cerevisiae strains (UCDFST 40-144 and 68-44) that not only consume proline but also produce sufficient alcohol is a key breakthrough. This suggests that proline utilization can be engineered or selected for within the Saccharomyces genus without sacrificing brewing performance.
  • Wine Yeast for Beer? Notably, the two most promising S. cerevisiae strains were originally isolated from wine fermentations. This hints at the potential for cross-application of yeast strains between winemaking and brewing, potentially leading to unique flavor profiles.

Key Results

  • The isatin assay was validated for its utility in measuring proline in both synthetic and wort-based media.
  • Out of 205 screened yeast strains, 50.7% did not consume proline.
  • 37 yeast strains (18.0%) were identified as proline-utilizing (reducing proline by >60%) in the initial screening.
  • This was narrowed down to 31 strains (15.1%) after a second screening.
  • Among Saccharomyces species, only 7.7% (11 out of 142 strains) were found to utilize proline effectively.
  • Two Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains, UCDFST 40-144 and 68-44, were identified as capable of significantly reducing proline levels while producing substantial alcohol (3.6% and 2.6% ABV, respectively) in a beer fermentation model. These strains also showed higher overall amino acid uptake compared to a standard ale yeast (UCDFST 96-12).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanism of Proline Utilization: While the study identified strains with enhanced proline utilization, the underlying genetic and molecular mechanisms are not fully elucidated. The authors suggest that whole-genome sequencing of the identified strains could help understand the detailed mechanisms, particularly concerning PKA signaling pathways.
  • Flavor Profile Characterization: The study highlights the potential of the identified wine yeast strains to produce distinctive beer flavors. However, further analyses, including the identification of volatile compounds and sensory evaluations, are needed to confirm and characterize these unique flavor profiles.
  • Broader Application of Non-Saccharomyces: While some non-Saccharomyces yeasts were found to utilize proline, their low alcohol production limits their direct application. Future research could explore co-fermentation strategies or genetic modifications to enhance their brewing suitability.
  • GMO Concerns: The paper briefly mentions that genetically modified organism (GMO) approaches to enhance proline transport (like the Put4 variant) are not always publicly acceptable, reinforcing the value of screening naturally occurring strains.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although proline is the most or second most abundant amino acid in wort and grape must, it is not fully consumed by the yeast <i>Saccharomyces cerevisiae</i> during alcoholic fermentation, unlike other amino acids. Our previous studies showed that arginine, the third most abundant amino acid in wort, inhibits the utilization of proline in most strains of <i>S. cerevisiae</i>. Furthermore, we found that some non-<i>Saccharomyces</i> yeasts utilized proline in a specific artificial medium with arginine and proline as the only nitrogen source, but these yeasts were not suitable for beer fermentation due to their low alcohol productivity. For yeasts to be useful for brewing, they need to utilize proline and produce alcohol during fermentation. In this study, 11 <i>S. cerevisiae</i> strains and 10 non-<i>Saccharomyces</i> yeast strains in the Phaff Yeast Culture Collection were identified that utilize proline effectively. Notably, two of these <i>S. cerevisiae strains</i>, UCDFST 40-144 and 68-44, utilize proline and produce sufficient alcohol in the beer fermentation model used. These strains have the potential to create distinctive beer products that are specifically alcoholic but with a reduction in proline in the finished beer.
BibTeX
@article{tanahashi2023isolation,
  author = {Ryoya Tanahashi and Akira Nishimura and Minh Nguyen and Irnayuli R. Sitepu and Glen Fox and Kyria Boundy‐Mills and Hiroshi Takagi},
  title = {{Isolation of Yeast Strains with Higher Proline Uptake and Their Applications to Beer Fermentation}},
  journal = {Journal of Fungi},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jof9121137},
}
Figure