ISCS-A Tool Kit for Constructing Knowledge-based System Configurators

Harry Wu, Hon Wai Chun, Alejandro MimoAAAI 1986

Introduction

In the mid-1980s, the "Expert System" boom was in full swing. While general-purpose AI tools were becoming available, they often lacked the specialized structures required for specific domains. For a knowledge engineer, using a general-purpose tool was akin to being given a block of steel and a forge when they specifically needed woodworking tools. This paper, originally presented by Honeywell researchers in 1986, introduces the Intelligent System Configuration Shell (ISCS). ISCS is a domain-specific toolkit designed to streamline the creation of systems that configure other complex systems, such as computer hardware and software.

System Architecture

ISCS is implemented on the Xerox 1108 workstation using INTERLISP-D and LOOPS. It provides a specialized environment that bridges the gap between general-purpose AI environments and the specific needs of configuration tasks. The architecture is organized into three primary layers: the User Interface, the ISCS Shell, and the Knowledge Base.

The three-layered architecture of the ISCS environment, showing the User Interface, ISCS Shell, and Knowledge Base.

The ISCS Shell acts as the engine, containing the Database Manager, User Interface Generator (WSI), Control and Inference mechanisms, and the Knowledge Engineer Assistant (KEA). This shell mediates between the high-level user interface and the underlying knowledge structures.

Knowledge Representation and Control

The power of ISCS lies in its specialized knowledge representation, which rests on four pillars:

  1. The Component Model: This utilizes a dual-hierarchy approach. A taxonomic hierarchy handles inheritance (e.g., a specific terminal model inheriting properties from a general terminal class), while a part-of hierarchy manages physical and logical connectivity (e.g., mapping which terminals are attached to specific communication lines).
  2. Constraint Demons: These are specialized triggers. Value demons validate data upon entry, while Class demons automate object creation based on system state (e.g., automatically adding a communication line when a certain number of terminals are configured).
  3. Procedural Hierarchy: Logic is organized into three layers—Operations (basic actions), Tasks (goal-oriented sequences), and Plans (high-level logic determining task execution order). This structure avoids the pitfalls of flat, unmanageable rule sets.

User Interface Generation (WSI)

A distinguishing feature of ISCS is its integrated User Interface Generator, known as WSI. Unlike many expert systems of the era where the interface was an afterthought, ISCS treats the UI as a first-class citizen. By using "mixins," standard interface components are automatically available to the knowledge engineer.

The Honeywell System Configurator interface generated by the WSI, utilizing data sheets and a file cabinet metaphor.

The WSI employs a "data sheet" and "file cabinet" metaphor. This allows end-users, such as sales representatives or field engineers, to interact with the system through familiar business forms rather than complex code or abstract logic.

Conclusion and Impact

ISCS represents a successful evolution from hand-coded configurators to a reusable, formal shell. By restricting the tool to the configuration domain, the researchers created "structure-based editors" that prevent semantic errors during the knowledge acquisition phase. The system was validated through internal Honeywell projects, including the configuration of DPS-6 software and DPS-90 hardware. While initially limited by the hardware of the time, ISCS demonstrated that domain-specific specialization significantly increases the productivity of knowledge engineers and the reliability of the resulting expert systems.

Reference: Wu, H., Chun, H. W., & Mimo, A. (1986). ISCS - A Tool Kit for Constructing Knowledge-Based System Configurators. Proceedings of AAAI-86.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu1986iscs,
  author = {Harry Wu and Hon Wai Chun and Alejandro Mimo},
  title = {{ISCS-A Tool Kit for Constructing Knowledge-based System Configurators}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1986},
}
Figure