Abstract
Purpose: Lesions in the spinal cord (SC) can be found in up to 83% of patients with multiple sclerosis (MS). As they are mainly located in the cervical segment, many centers exclude the thoracic part from SC imaging. The aim of our study was to quantify the decrease in sensitivity resulting from this approach. Methods: MR images (3T) of 543 consecutive patients with clinically isolated syndrome (CIS) (n: 37) and MS (n: 506) were analyzed retrospectively. Lesions were segmented semi-automatically on axial T2-weighted images of the whole SC using BrainSeg3D. The volume of lesions was related to vertebral levels. Results: Altogether 1782 lesions (CIS: 19; MS: 1763) were found in 409 patients. 70% of the lesion volume was located in the SC above the 3rd thoracic vertebral body, in a segment that is commonly covered by an isolated examination of the cervical SC. However, 26 patients (6%) showed lesions exclusively below the 3rd thoracic vertebral body, thus 94% of all patients with SC lesions could be detected with isolated MR imaging of the cervical SC. Conclusion: Though the majority of lesions can be detected in an isolated examination of the upper part of the SC, some patients showed lesions exclusively below the 3rd thoracic vertebral body. We recommend routine scanning of the whole SC in suspected MS.
Introduction
In the diagnostic workup for Multiple Sclerosis (MS), identifying spinal cord (SC) lesions is a critical component. These lesions are essential for satisfying the McDonald criteria, which require evidence of "dissemination in space"—meaning lesions must be present in different parts of the central nervous system. While spinal cord involvement is common, imaging the entire spinal cord presents significant logistical challenges. The cord is long, thin, and highly susceptible to motion artifacts from breathing and cardiac activity.
Because approximately 56% of lesions are known to reside in the cervical segment, many clinical centers opt to skip thoracic imaging to save time and improve patient comfort. However, this practice raises a vital question: what is the cost of this efficiency in terms of diagnostic sensitivity? This study quantifies the potential for missed diagnoses when the thoracic region is ignored.
Methods
The researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of 543 patients at the Technical University of Munich (TUM-MS). The cohort included 37 patients with Clinically Isolated Syndrome (CIS) and 506 with confirmed MS, including Relapsing-Remitting (RRMS), Secondary Progressive (SPMS), and Primary Progressive (PPMS) subtypes. All imaging was performed on 3-Tesla MRI scanners using standardized T2-weighted turbo spin echo (TSE) sequences.
To ensure high-quality data, the team employed a rigorous volumetric analysis:
- Segmentation: The BrainSeg3D software was used for semi-automated outlining of the spinal cord area on axial T2-weighted images.
- Manual Refinement: Two medical students, under the supervision of a senior neuroradiologist, manually segmented 1,782 individual lesions.
- Anatomical Mapping: The spinal cord was divided into 19 distinct regions (C3-C8, T1-T12, and L1) based on vertebral levels to map the distribution of the "lesion load."
- Axial Analysis: Unlike many studies relying on sagittal views—which can suffer from "partial volume" blurring—this study utilized axial slices to better detect lateral lesions.
Results
The study population represented a broad spectrum of MS phenotypes, with varying disease durations and disability scores (EDSS), as detailed in the clinical characteristics table below.
Lesion Distribution and Sensitivity
A total of 1,782 lesions were identified across 409 patients, meaning 75% of the total cohort had at least one SC lesion. The analysis confirmed a "cervical hotspot," with the highest concentration of lesion volume occurring at the C4 and C5 levels. Approximately 70% of the total lesion volume was located above the T3 vertebra.
However, the critical finding concerns diagnostic sensitivity. While an isolated cervical MRI (up to T3) would detect 94% of patients with spinal involvement, 6% of patients (26 individuals) had lesions exclusively in the lower thoracic cord. Specifically, 24 patients with MS and 2 with CIS would have been recorded as having "no spinal lesions" if the thoracic spine had been omitted from the protocol.
Discussion
The findings suggest that while cervical imaging captures the majority of the lesion load, it is not exhaustive. Missing the 6% of patients with isolated thoracic lesions could lead to a failure in meeting diagnostic criteria or a delay in diagnosis. Furthermore, the authors emphasize the prognostic value of spinal lesions. They are strong predictors of future disability progression, independent of clinical relapses. Capturing the total lesion load provides a more accurate baseline for long-term patient management.
The study does have limitations. In progressive forms of MS (like SPMS), lesions often become confluent, making individual counts difficult. Additionally, the use of 2D sequences with 4mm slice thickness may lead to underestimation of very small lesions due to partial volume effects. Future research, such as the multicenter ProVal-MS study, will aim to validate these findings and explore the correlation between thoracic lesions and specific clinical symptoms.
Conclusion
While the cervical spinal cord contains the highest density of MS lesions, imaging this region alone misses approximately 6% of patients with spinal involvement. To ensure maximum diagnostic sensitivity and a complete prognostic assessment, the authors recommend routine MR imaging of the entire spinal cord in patients with suspected Multiple Sclerosis.
Summary updated