Is friction essential for dilatancy and shear jamming in granular\n matter?

Varghese Babu, Deng Pan, Yuliang Jin, Bulbul Chakraborty, Srikanth SastryarXiv 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Granular packings display the remarkable phenomenon of dilatancy, wherein their volume increases upon shear deformation. Conventional wisdom and previous results suggest that dilatancy, as also the related phenomenon of shear-induced jamming, requires frictional interactions. Here, we investigate the occurrence of dilatancy and shear jamming in frictionless packings. We show that the existence of isotropic jamming densities $\phi_j$ above the minimal density, the J-point density $\phi_J$, leads both to the emergence of shear-induced jamming and dilatancy. Packings at $\phi_J$ form a significant threshold state into which systems evolve in the limit of vanishing pressure under constant pressure shear, irrespective of the initial jamming density $\phi_j$. While packings for different $\phi_j$ display equivalent scaling properties under compression, they exhibit striking differences in rheological behaviour under shear. The yield stress under constant volume shear increases discontinuously with density when $\phi_j > \phi_J$, contrary to the continuous behavior in generic packings that jam at $\phi_J$.

Introduction

In granular matter physics, two behaviors are foundational: dilatancy (volume expansion under shear) and shear jamming (solidification under applied stress). Traditionally, these have been attributed to inter-particle friction. Standard soil mechanics and physics models posit that friction is necessary to stabilize the structures formed during these processes. Previous simulations of frictionless particles often failed to exhibit dilatancy, reinforcing the belief that friction is an essential ingredient. This study challenges this paradigm by asking if the absence of these behaviors in previous frictionless models was due to the preparation protocols rather than the absence of friction itself.

Methods

The researchers utilized numerical simulations of two frictionless sphere models:

  • Bi-disperse (BD): A 1:1 mixture of spheres with a diameter ratio of 1.4.
  • Poly-disperse (PD): Spheres with a size distribution $P(D) \sim D^{-3}$.

To explore densities above the standard "J-point" ($\phi_J \approx 0.648$ for BD, $\approx 0.655$ for PD), they employed advanced annealing techniques:

  1. Mechanical Annealing: Cyclic athermal quasi-static (AQS) shear for the BD system.
  2. Thermal Annealing: A Swap Monte Carlo algorithm for the PD system to reach extremely dense, stable configurations.

These packings were then subjected to quasistatic shear under both constant volume (to study shear jamming) and constant pressure (to study dilatancy) conditions.

Results

The study reveals that dilatancy and shear jamming are intrinsic geometric consequences of the jamming landscape. When a frictionless system is prepared at an initial density $\phi_j$ higher than the minimal jamming density $\phi_J$, it must dilate when sheared due to geometric exclusion.

As shown in Figure 3, under constant volume shear, unjammed states at high densities successfully "jam," evidenced by a sharp jump in the number of non-rattler contacts ($Z_{NR}$) above the isostatic value of 6 (Panel c). Furthermore, the yield stress increases discontinuously with density when $\phi_j > \phi_J$ (Panels a and b), a significant departure from the continuous behavior seen in packings that jam at the J-point.

Under constant pressure, the systems evolve toward a universal steady state. Figure 6 illustrates the shear stress evolution for the PD model at different pressures. Regardless of the initial configuration, the systems tend toward a critical state density $\phi_c$ that coincides with $\phi_J$ in the limit of vanishing pressure. Even without microscopic friction, the sheared steady state exhibits a macroscopic friction coefficient ($\mu = \sigma/P$) of approximately 0.1, aligning with experimental observations of frictionless-like suspensions.

Discussion and Conclusion

This work demonstrates that friction is not a prerequisite for dilatancy or shear jamming. Instead, these phenomena emerge naturally in frictionless systems if they are prepared at sufficiently high initial densities. The "J-point" acts as a universal attractor for sheared systems in the limit of zero pressure.

Future work could extend these findings to high-speed inertial flows and investigate potential differences in 2D systems. Experimentally, these results suggest that "annealing" frictionless-like systems, such as emulsions or foams, through cyclic shear could allow researchers to observe these "frictional" behaviors in the lab.

Summary updated

Abstract

Granular packings display the remarkable phenomenon of dilatancy [1], wherein\ntheir volume increases upon shear deformation. Conventional wisdom and previous\nresults suggest that dilatancy, as also the related phenomenon of shear-induced\njamming, requires frictional interactions [2, 3]. Here, we investigate the\noccurrence of dilatancy and shear jamming in frictionless packings. We show\nthat the existence of isotropic jamming densities {\\phi}j above the minimal\ndensity, the J-point density {\\phi}J [4, 5], leads both to the emergence of\nshear-induced jamming and dilatancy. Packings at {\\phi}J form a significant\nthreshold state into which systems evolve in the limit of vanishing pressure\nunder constant pressure shear, irrespective of the initial jamming density\n{\\phi}j. While packings for different {\\phi}j display equivalent scaling\nproperties under compression [6], they exhibit striking differences in\nrheological behaviour under shear. The yield stress under constant volume shear\nincreases discontinuously with density when {\\phi}j > {\\phi}J, contrary to the\ncontinuous behavior in generic packings that jam at {\\phi}J [4, 7].\n
BibTeX
@misc{babu2020is,
  author = {Varghese Babu and Deng Pan and Yuliang Jin and Bulbul Chakraborty and Srikanth Sastry},
  title = {{Is friction essential for dilatancy and shear jamming in granular\textbackslash\{\}n matter?}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2003.08815},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2003.08815},
}
Figure