Is China's rising presence in Hungary since 2012 impacting on Hungary's relations with the EU?

Xiwen WangAustralian 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how China's growing political and economic influence in Hungary, particularly through the 16+1 initiative, affects Hungary's relationship with the European Union. It finds that while Hungary actively engages with China for pragmatic economic and political reasons, its core economic integration with the EU remains strong, and China's influence on Hungary's EU relations is limited by EU regulations and values.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the complex geopolitical question of how increased bilateral engagement between an EU member state (Hungary) and a rising global power (China) impacts the former's relationship with its supranational bloc (the EU). Specifically, it examines the period since 2012, marked by China's "16+1" initiative (now 17+1, then 16+1 again), which aims to foster cooperation between China and Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries. As China's economic and political footprint in Hungary has grown significantly, with major projects like the Budapest-Belgrade railway, a vaccine plant, and a Fudan University campus, concerns arise about whether this deepening relationship might undermine EU unity or influence Hungary's stance towards China within the EU framework. The paper seeks to evaluate the extent of this impact.

Methods

The paper employs a qualitative research approach, relying on a comprehensive review and analysis of existing academic literature, policy documents, news reports, and official statements. It synthesizes information to trace the evolution of Sino-Hungarian relations, particularly in the context of the 16+1 initiative and the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). The analysis focuses on identifying patterns in political and economic engagement, assessing the motivations behind Hungary's policies, and examining the interplay between these bilateral ties and Hungary's obligations and interactions with the EU.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on secondary data sources such as academic publications, reports from international organizations (IMF), government documents, and news articles.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pragmatic Engagement: Hungary's deepening relationship with China is largely driven by pragmatic considerations, including seeking economic recovery and growth, accessing capital, and leveraging China as a bargaining chip in negotiations with the EU.
  • EU as Dominant Economic Partner: Despite significant Chinese investment, the EU remains Hungary's primary economic partner, providing substantial financial assistance and driving economic development. This structural linkage constrains the extent to which Hungary can diverge from EU policy.
  • "Eastern Opening" Strategy: Following the 2008 financial crisis, Hungary adopted an "Eastern Opening" strategy to diversify its economic reliance away from European markets, with China being a key target.
  • "State Capitalist" Alignment: The current Hungarian government's embrace of a "state capitalist" approach aligns with China's model, fostering a political affinity that facilitates closer ties.
  • Limited Political Leverage: While Hungary advocates for China's interests within the EU, China's political leverage over Hungary at the EU institutional level is considered limited, largely due to EU regulations and the overarching importance of EU membership.
  • De-Europeanization vs. Foreign Policy: While the Orban government has been described as pursuing "de-Europeanization" in domestic policy, its foreign policy implementation generally aligns with EU criteria, especially concerning core values.

Key Results

  • Trade Imbalance: Hungary has a significant trade deficit with China, with imports from China growing substantially more than its exports to China between 2010 and 2020.
  • FDI Disparity: While China's Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) stock in Hungary has increased, it remains marginal compared to that of EU countries, particularly Germany.
  • Budapest-Belgrade Railway: This flagship project, financed by a Chinese loan, illustrates the nature of 16+1 infrastructure cooperation but has faced EU scrutiny and delays, highlighting the EU's regulatory power.
  • EU Sanctions and Hungary's Stance: Hungary has often been the sole EU member state to express reservations or oppose EU sanctions or statements critical of China, particularly on issues like human rights and Hong Kong. However, it ultimately adheres to EU sanctions when agreed upon by all member states.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Qualitative Focus: The paper is primarily qualitative, relying on analysis of existing literature and policy documents. While insightful, it could benefit from more quantitative data to further solidify some conclusions.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that while Hungary's cooperation with China is pragmatic and driven by national interests, its economic integration with the EU is unlikely to be weakened. Future research could explore the long-term sustainability of this balancing act and the potential for future shifts in Hungary's geopolitical alignment. The paper also notes that China's influence is "counteracted by the EU's regulatory power," suggesting further investigation into the specific mechanisms and effectiveness of this counteraction would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hungary has been an active participant in China’s 16+1 initiative which is a cooperation scheme launched by Beijing in 2012 to facilitate comprehensive cooperation between China and 16 Central and Eastern European countries. The relationships between China and Hungary have improved greatly since then and China’s political and economic presence in the country is increasingly visible. Apart from the Budapest-Belgrade railway, the recent high-profile Chinese investment in Hungary includes a vaccine plant and Fudan University branch campus in Budapest. Since their bilateral relations have deepened, will China’s political and economic presence in Hungary impact Hungary’s relations with the European Union (EU) and the EU’s unified stance towards China? This article evaluates the impact of the 16+1 initiative on Sino-Hungarian political and economic relations and the impact of their engagement on Hungary’s relations with EU institutions and initiatives.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023is,
  author = {Xiwen Wang},
  title = {{Is China's rising presence in Hungary since 2012 impacting on Hungary's relations with the EU?}},
  booktitle = {Australian},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.30722/anzjes.vol15.iss1.17365},
}
Figure