Irritability Is Associated With Decreased Cortical Surface Area and Anxiety With Decreased Gyrification During Brain Development

Camille Piguet, Angeline Mihailov, Antoine Grigis, Charles Laidi, Édouard Duchesnay, Josselin HouenouFrontiers in Psychiatry 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals distinct structural brain differences associated with irritability and anxiety in developing youth. Irritability in children and adolescents is linked to reduced cortical surface area in areas related to cognitive control, while anxiety is associated with decreased gyrification in regions involved in emotion regulation, highlighting these as key vulnerability markers for psychiatric disorders.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The emergence of severe psychiatric disorders often occurs during adolescence, a critical period of brain development. While we understand that early symptoms can predict later disorders, the specific neural underpinnings of these "prodromal" traits, particularly when viewed dimensionally rather than as distinct diagnoses, remain unclear. This paper tackles the question of how two central transdiagnostic vulnerability traits – irritability and anxiety – are associated with structural brain development in youth. Understanding these associations is crucial for early detection and the development of targeted interventions for a range of mental health conditions.

Methods

The researchers utilized a whole-brain approach to analyze structural MRI data from a large developmental cohort. They employed FreeSurfer software to extract three key measures of brain maturation: cortical thickness, surface area, and the local gyrification index (LGI). LGI, in particular, is highlighted as a potentially sensitive marker for early brain development. Vertex-wise statistical analyses were conducted using a general linear model, correlating these structural measures with irritability and anxiety scores. To account for the multiple comparisons inherent in whole-brain analysis, they used a cluster-wise correction method based on Monte Carlo simulations, with a cluster-forming threshold of p < 0.01 and a cluster-wise threshold of p < 0.05.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Healthy Brain Network (HBN) cohort. This is an open-access, large-scale developmental cohort designed to recruit children and adolescents aged 5-21 with a focus on those with concerns about school results or potential psychiatric problems. The HBN provides a rich dataset including MRI scans, clinical information, and behavioral assessments. The researchers specifically used data from the first three releases of the HBN, totaling 1,552 subjects initially, with a final sample of 658 subjects for the irritability analysis and 645 for the anxiety analysis after quality control and selection criteria were applied.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Irritability and anxiety are not just different labels for the same thing: The study provides neurobiological evidence that these two traits are associated with distinct structural brain alterations, supporting their conceptual independence as vulnerability factors.
  • Parental reports matter: While self-reports are valuable, the study found that parental reports of irritability and anxiety yielded more robust and significant associations with brain structure, suggesting they may better capture clinically relevant psychopathology.
  • Early brain development is key: The findings underscore the importance of studying brain development during childhood and adolescence, as structural differences in these critical periods can predispose individuals to later mental health challenges.
  • Specific brain regions implicated: The identification of specific cortical regions (rostral prefrontal cortex, precuneus for irritability; anterior cingulate cortex, dorsomedial prefrontal cortex for anxiety) provides concrete targets for future research and intervention.

Key Results

  • Irritability: Parental reports of irritability were significantly associated with decreased cortical surface area in the bilateral rostral prefrontal cortex and the precuneus.
  • Anxiety: Parental reports of anxiety were significantly associated with decreased local gyrification index (LGI) in the anterior cingulate cortex and dorsomedial prefrontal cortex.
  • Self-report measures of irritability and anxiety did not yield significant associations with brain structure after multiple comparison corrections, despite showing moderate correlations with parent reports.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-sectional design: The study's correlational nature prevents drawing conclusions about causality. It's unclear whether the brain differences cause the symptoms or vice versa, or if a third factor is involved.
  • Age range and puberty: The broad age range, including puberty, introduces variability that, while accounted for in analyses, still presents a complexity.
  • Overlapping symptom dimensions: The study focused on two key dimensions but acknowledges that developmental psychopathology is complex and involves many overlapping symptom dimensions.

Future work suggested by the authors includes:

  • Longitudinal studies: To establish causal relationships and track developmental trajectories.
  • Connectivity analyses: To explore how these structural differences relate to functional brain networks and how these networks mature.
  • Testing mechanistic models: Investigating how impaired cognitive control (linked to irritability) and threat dysregulation (linked to anxiety) manifest in neural circuits.
  • Replication: The open-access nature of the HBN data allows for easy replication of these findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> Brain development is of utmost importance for the emergence of psychiatric disorders, as the most severe of them arise before 25 years old. However, little is known regarding how early transdiagnostic symptoms, in a dimensional framework, are associated with cortical development. Anxiety and irritability are central vulnerability traits for subsequent mood and anxiety disorders. In this study, we investigate how these dimensions are related to structural changes in the brain to understand how they may increase the transition risk to full-blown disorders. <b>Methods:</b> We used the opportunity of an open access developmental cohort, the Healthy Brain Network, to investigate associations between cortical surface markers and irritability and anxiety scores as measured by parents and self-reports. <b>Results:</b> We found that in 658 young people (with a mean age of 11.6) the parental report of irritability is associated with decreased surface area in the bilateral rostral prefrontal cortex and the precuneus. Furthermore, parental reports of anxiety were associated with decreased local gyrification index in the anterior cingulate cortex and dorsomedial prefrontal cortex. <b>Conclusions:</b> These results are consistent with current models of emotion regulation network maturation, showing decreased surface area or gyrification index in regions associated with impaired affective control in mood and anxiety disorders. Our results highlight how dimensional traits may increase vulnerability for these disorders.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{piguet2021irritability,
  author = {Camille Piguet and Angeline Mihailov and Antoine Grigis and Charles Laidi and Édouard Duchesnay and Josselin Houenou},
  title = {{Irritability Is Associated With Decreased Cortical Surface Area and Anxiety With Decreased Gyrification During Brain Development}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2021.744419},
}
Figure