Irony Detection, Reasoning and Understanding in Zero-shot Learning

Yunfei Long, Peiling Yi, Yuhan XiaarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Irony detection remains a significant challenge for Natural Language Processing (NLP) due to the inherent contrast between literal and intended meanings. This paper introduces IDADP, a novel framework designed to enable Large Language Models (LLMs) to detect, reason about, and understand irony in a zero-shot setting. By extracting irony-specific knowledge and integrating it into a multi-stage prompting pipeline, IDADP achieves performance comparable to fine-tuned models while maintaining superior generalization across diverse datasets.

Introduction

Irony is a sophisticated linguistic device where intended meaning diverges from literal expression. For NLP systems, failing to detect irony can lead to critical errors in sentiment analysis and misinformation detection. Current irony detection models face three primary challenges: poor generalization across platforms (e.g., Twitter vs. Reddit), a lack of explainable reasoning ("black box" nature), and a failure to demonstrate true linguistic understanding beyond binary classification.

Methodology: The IDADP Framework

The IDADP (Irony Detection, Reasoning, and Understanding) framework leverages the in-context learning capabilities of LLMs through a structured four-stage process. Unlike traditional fine-tuning, IDADP primes the model with irony-specific linguistic cues before execution.

Overview of the IDADP framework, illustrating the flow from knowledge extraction to the final voting mechanism.

The process consists of:

  1. Irony-focused Knowledge Extraction: The LLM generates definitions and linguistic markers for irony.
  2. Knowledge Integration: This extracted knowledge is used to "prime" the model's attention.
  3. Prompt Engineering: Advanced techniques like Task-Specific Chain-of-Thought (CoT) guide the model through logical steps, such as contrasting literal meaning with situational context.
  4. Voting Mechanism: Multiple predictions are generated using prompt variations, with a majority-consent rule determining the final label to reduce output variability.

Experimental Setup and Datasets

To evaluate generalization, the framework was tested across six diverse datasets representing different platforms and irony styles, including Twitter (iSarcasm, SemEval-2018), the Internet Argument Corpus (Gen, RQ, HYP), and Reddit.

Summary of the six datasets used for evaluation, highlighting variations in size, text length, and platform.

Results and Discussion

IDADP consistently outperformed competitive zero-shot baselines. On the iSarcasm dataset, it achieved an F1-score of 0.67, a significant improvement over the standard GPT-3.5 baseline of 0.45. Beyond detection, the framework excels in reasoning and understanding. Human evaluations of the generated explanations yielded an average score of 2.5/3.0, indicating logically sound reasoning. Furthermore, cosine similarity scores between the model’s non-ironic rephrasing and ground truth typically ranged between 0.7 and 0.9, demonstrating a strong grasp of the intended meaning.

Key Insights

  • Specialized Reasoning: General reasoning boosters like Auto-CoT proved insufficient for irony, suggesting that irony detection requires specialized linguistic knowledge rather than generic logic.
  • Mitigating Literal Bias: LLMs often default to literal interpretations. IDADP's success stems from forcing an explicit contrast between literal and contextual meanings.
  • Zero-Shot Generalization: While fine-tuned models (e.g., BERT) often suffer from performance degradation when tested on out-of-domain data, IDADP maintained robust performance across all six datasets.

Conclusion

The IDADP framework demonstrates that the "knowledge" of irony is latent within LLMs and can be effectively extracted through structured prompting. While the model still faces challenges with extremely subtle cultural cues and occasional false positives, it represents a significant step toward human-like irony understanding in AI. Future work will explore multimodal integration and hybrid symbolic-neural methods to further bridge the gap in linguistic flexibility.

Summary updated

Abstract

The generalisation of irony detection faces significant challenges, leading to substantial performance deviations when detection models are applied to diverse real-world scenarios. In this study, we find that irony-focused prompts, as generated from our IDADP framework for LLMs, can not only overcome dataset-specific limitations but also generate coherent, human-readable reasoning, transforming ironic text into its intended meaning. Based on our findings and in-depth analysis, we identify several promising directions for future research aimed at enhancing LLMs' zero-shot capabilities in irony detection, reasoning, and comprehension. These include advancing contextual awareness in irony detection, exploring hybrid symbolic-neural methods, and integrating multimodal data, among others.
BibTeX
@misc{long2025irony,
  author = {YUNFEI LONG and Peiling Yi and Yuhan Xia},
  title = {{Irony Detection, Reasoning and Understanding in Zero-shot Learning}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2501.16884},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.16884},
}
Figure