Ionic control of porin permeability in bacteria

Santiago E. Caño Muñiz, Anja Hagting, Ieuan Evans, Ali F. Alsulami, David Summers, Tom L. Blundell, R. Andrés FlotobioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that bacterial porin permeability isn't static but dynamically controlled by internal ion concentrations (pH and potassium). This ionic regulation is linked to the bacterium's metabolic state, influencing nutrient uptake and antibiotic susceptibility, and identifies the Kch channel as a potential therapeutic target.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bacterial porins are crucial gateways in the outer membrane, allowing essential nutrients and antibiotics to enter. However, they also represent a potential "leak" for protons, which are vital for energy production. This raises a fundamental question: do bacteria actively regulate porin activity to balance nutrient needs, energy generation, and defense against antibiotics? Understanding this regulation is key to developing new strategies to combat bacterial infections, especially in the face of rising antibiotic resistance.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Fluorescent Tracer Uptake: They used fluorescent glucose analogs (2NBDG) and a penicillin analog (Bocillin FL) to visualize and quantify how easily molecules pass through porins. This was done using flow cytometry and single-cell imaging in a microfluidic "mother machine" setup.
  • Genetically Encoded Sensors: To monitor internal conditions, they engineered E. coli strains expressing fluorescent sensors for cytoplasmic and periplasmic pH and potassium levels.
  • Optogenetics: The light-activated proton pump ArchT was used to precisely control periplasmic acidification.
  • Electrophysiology: A genetically encoded voltage sensor (QuasAr2) was used to measure the inner membrane potential.
  • Molecular Dynamics Simulations: These were used to model how protonation of charged residues within porins might affect their structure and pore diameter.
  • Metabolic Manipulation: Bacteria were grown in media with different carbon sources (glucose, lipids, etc.) to probe the link between metabolism and porin activity.
  • Antibiotic Susceptibility Assays: Minimal inhibitory concentration (MIC) and ciprofloxacin uptake assays were performed on wild-type and mutant strains.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic Porin Regulation: Porin permeability is not a passive process but is actively and dynamically controlled by the bacterium's internal ionic environment.
  • Periplasmic pH and K+ as Key Regulators: Changes in periplasmic pH and potassium levels directly influence how permeable porins are. Acidification inhibits permeability, while increased potassium enhances it.
  • Metabolic Link: The bacterium's metabolic state, dictated by its carbon source, directly impacts periplasmic ion concentrations and, consequently, porin permeability. For example, glucose metabolism leads to increased periplasmic potassium and higher porin permeability.
  • Kch Channel's Crucial Role: The voltage-gated potassium channel Kch is identified as a key player in this regulation, mediating potassium influx and influencing porin opening.
  • Implications for Antibiotic Resistance: The study provides a mechanistic explanation for why bacteria are less susceptible to certain antibiotics when grown in lipid-rich environments (lower porin permeability) and how metabolic mutations can confer drug resistance.

Key Results

  • Periplasmic acidification (lower pH) significantly reduced 2NBDG uptake, indicating decreased porin permeability.
  • Increasing periplasmic potassium concentrations enhanced 2NBDG uptake, suggesting increased porin permeability.
  • Growth in glucose led to rapid fluctuations in periplasmic K+ and H+ levels, correlating with increased porin permeability and membrane action potentials.
  • Mutants lacking the Kch channel showed altered periplasmic ion levels and reduced porin permeability.
  • Antibiotic susceptibility assays showed that ompF, ompC, and kch knockout mutants were more resistant to ciprofloxacin, consistent with altered porin permeability.
  • E. coli grown in glucose media exhibited higher ciprofloxacin uptake compared to those grown in lipid media.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their findings are primarily based on Escherichia coli and future work should explore if these mechanisms are conserved in other Gram-negative bacteria. They also suggest that therapeutic activation of the Kch channel could be a promising strategy to enhance antibiotic accumulation and improve bacterial killing, particularly in conditions where lipids are the primary carbon source (e.g., intracellular infections). Further investigation into the precise molecular mechanisms by which periplasmic ions interact with porins and the Kch channel would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Bacterial porins permit permeation of hydrophilic nutrients and antibiotics across the outer membrane but also contribute to proton leak from the periplasmic space, suggesting that their activity might be dynamically regulated. Here we show, in Escherichia coli , that porin permeability is controlled by changes in periplasmic ions, inhibited by periplasmic acidification, thereby limiting proton loss during electron transport chain activity, and enhanced during starvation, promoting nutrient uptake. Growth in glucose increases periplasmic potassium through activating the voltage-gated channel Kch, triggering enhanced porin permeation and membrane action potentials. This metabolic control of porin permeability explains the recognized decrease in antibiotic susceptibility when bacteria are grown in lipid media and the impact of mutations in central metabolism genes on drug resistance, identifying Kch as a therapeutic target to improve bacterial killing by antibiotics. One sentence summary The permeability of bacterial porin is dynamically regulated by periplasmic pH and potassium levels, altering antibiotic resistance.
BibTeX
@misc{muniz2022ionic,
  author = {Santiago E. Caño Muñiz and Anja Hagting and Ieuan Evans and Ali F. Alsulami and David Summers and Tom L. Blundell and R. Andrés Floto},
  title = {{Ionic control of porin permeability in bacteria}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.07.13.499887},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure