TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel framework for assessing the investment efficiency of pumped storage power plants (PSPPs) in China, specifically considering regional grid operational demands and the inherent uncertainties of clean energy integration. By combining cloud models, AHP, and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, the study provides a nuanced understanding of PSPP investment across different Chinese regions, highlighting areas with the highest potential.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
China is rapidly expanding its renewable energy sources like wind and solar power. While this is crucial for decarbonization, these sources are intermittent and unpredictable, posing challenges to grid stability and requiring effective energy storage solutions. Pumped storage power plants are a key technology for grid balancing, but their investment efficiency can vary significantly across regions due to differing grid demands, energy mixes, and operational needs. Existing investment assessment methods often overlook these regional grid operational demands and the inherent uncertainties associated with clean energy, leading to potentially suboptimal investment decisions. This paper aims to fill this gap by developing a comprehensive model that accounts for these factors.
Methods
The authors propose a multi-stage methodology:
- Index System Development: They first identify key factors influencing PSPP investment efficiency from three perspectives: regional grid power restructuring demand, regional grid security and stable operation demand, and regional power grid energy storage demand. This leads to a refined set of 22 indicators.
- Information Representation (Cloud Model & AHP): To handle the inherent uncertainty and vagueness in decision-making, they employ a cloud model to represent indicator attributes. This model uses expectation (Ex), entropy (En), and hyper entropy (He) to capture the randomness and ambiguity of qualitative concepts. For determining indicator weights, they combine the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), a subjective weighting method based on expert judgment, with the entropy method, an objective weighting method that relies on data. A game combination weighting approach is used to integrate these subjective and objective weights, minimizing deviation and improving scientific rigor.
- Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation (FCE): Finally, the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method is used to integrate the cloud affiliation and importance values of each indicator. This allows for a qualitative and quantitative assessment of the overall investment efficiency level for each region.
Datasets
The study utilizes data from China's "China Electricity Industry Annual Development Report 2019" and relevant power enterprise and statistical yearbooks. This data pertains to six regional grids in China: North China, Northeast China, East China, Central China, Northwest China, and South China, for the year 2018.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Regional Nuance is Crucial: The study strongly emphasizes that a one-size-fits-all approach to PSPP investment is insufficient. Regional grid characteristics, energy mix, and operational demands significantly impact investment efficiency.
- Uncertainty Management is Key: The integration of cloud models effectively addresses the inherent randomness and ambiguity in assessing clean energy systems and their impact on PSPP performance.
- Combined Weighting for Robustness: Merging subjective (AHP) and objective (entropy) weighting methods, further refined by game theory, provides a more balanced and reliable assessment of indicator importance compared to using a single method.
- Grid Demand as a Primary Driver: The research highlights that factors related to regional grid demand, such as maximum system load and the proportion of incoming power, are particularly influential in determining PSPP investment efficiency.
Key Results
The study identified significant variations in investment efficiency across China's regions. The ranking of investment efficiency from highest to lowest is: Southern China > Northwest China > Central China > North China > Northeast China > East China.
- Southern China and Northwest China show the highest investment efficiency (Level V), indicating strong potential.
- North, Northeast, and Central China fall into Level III (moderate efficiency).
- East China exhibits the lowest investment efficiency (Level I).
The paper attributes Southern China's high score to its strong performance in "maximum system load" (X21), a heavily weighted indicator. Conversely, East China's low score is linked to both lower "maximum system load" and a less favorable "proportion of installed wind power capacity" (X12).
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Grid Operation Focus: The study primarily evaluates investment efficiency from the perspective of grid operation. Future work should incorporate other crucial aspects like sustainability and synergy to generate more universal investment decision results.
- Time Cost Ignored: The current model does not account for the long construction period of PSPPs, which incurs time costs.
- Alternative Storage Options: The paper notes that other energy storage technologies might be suitable for certain locations, and PSPPs may not always be the optimal choice.
Future research directions include expanding the evaluation to include sustainability and synergy aspects, incorporating the time cost of construction, and comparing PSPPs with other energy storage technologies. The authors also suggest that the mathematical model, while robust, can be adjusted based on specific needs and preferences.
Summary updated