Investigations on the Heat Balance of the Melt Pool during PBF-LB/M under Various Process Gases

Siegfried Baehr, Fabian Fritz, Stefan Adami, Thomas Ammann, Nikolaus A. Adams, Michael F. ZaehMetals 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how different process gases (argon, helium, and mixtures) affect the heat balance and melt pool dynamics in laser powder bed fusion (PBF-LB/M) of aluminum. Using a combination of experimental measurements and advanced smoothed-particle hydrodynamics (SPH) simulations, the study reveals that while gas composition has a minor impact on melt pool dimensions and temperatures, the presence of a gas flow significantly influences heat transfer, particularly through convection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Laser Powder Bed Fusion (PBF-LB/M) is a powerful additive manufacturing technique for metals, but controlling the melt pool's thermal behavior is crucial for achieving desired part properties. During the process, an inert gas atmosphere is maintained to prevent oxidation and nitridation. Additionally, a gas flow is directed over the melt pool to remove byproducts like spatters and fumes. This gas flow, however, introduces convective heat transfer, which can alter the melt pool's cooling rate and dimensions. Understanding how different gases (like argon and helium, which have vastly different thermal properties) and their mixtures, along with the gas flow, influence this heat balance is essential for optimizing the PBF-LB/M process and predicting part quality. Previous studies have often focused on single gases or lacked detailed investigations into the combined effects of gas composition and flow on the entire heat balance.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining experimental measurements and numerical simulations.

  • Experimental Setup: A lab-scale PBF-LB/M machine was used to process an aluminum alloy. An on-axis high-speed pyrometer was utilized to measure the surface temperature of the melt pool. The experiments involved varying the process gas between pure argon (Ar), pure helium (He), and two mixtures (70% Ar/30% He and 30% Ar/70% He).
  • Numerical Modeling: A sophisticated smoothed-particle hydrodynamics (SPH) model was developed and validated. This model accounts for key physical phenomena in the PBF-LB/M process zone, including:
  • Fluid Dynamics: Governed by weakly-compressible Navier-Stokes equations with a transport-velocity formulation to mitigate tensile instability.
  • Heat Transfer: Described by the conservation of energy, incorporating conduction, radiation, and volumetric heat sources (evaporation, laser energy, etc.).
  • Evaporation: Modeled using a simplified approach that accounts for recoil pressure.
  • Laser-Material Interaction: A ray-tracing method was used to accurately model laser absorption and reflection.
  • Surface Tension: Modeled using a continuous surface force model.
  • Gas Flow: The model explicitly included the process gas and its interaction with the melt pool.

The SPH model was validated against experimental data, particularly melt pool dimensions and surface temperatures.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data collected from the PBF-LB/M machine and the pyrometer. Material properties for the aluminum alloy and the process gases (argon and helium) were sourced from established literature and databases. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Minor Gas Composition Impact: Surprisingly, the specific composition of the Ar-He gas mixture had a relatively small impact on melt pool dimensions and surface temperatures. This suggests that other factors, like the gas flow itself, play a more dominant role in heat transfer.
  • Helium Enhances Cooling (Slightly): An increasing fraction of helium in the process gas led to a slight increase in cooling rates. This is attributed to helium's higher thermal conductivity and diffusivity compared to argon.
  • Gas Flow is a Major Player: The presence of a gas flow (at 1.5 m/s) significantly reduced the average surface temperature of the melt pool compared to simulations without gas flow. This highlights the importance of convective heat transfer.
  • Conduction Dominates Substrate Heat Transfer: The heat transfer to the substrate (melt-substrate interface) accounted for approximately 95% of the total heat flow, significantly outweighing the heat transfer to the gas.
  • SPH as a Powerful Tool: The validated SPH model proved effective in capturing complex melt pool dynamics and heat transfer phenomena, offering insights not easily obtainable through experiments alone.

Key Results

  • Temperature: Experimental pyrometry showed a slight decrease in melt pool temperatures with increasing helium content. Simulations corroborated this, with a monotonic decrease from Ar to He when gas flow was absent. The presence of gas flow generally reduced melt pool temperatures.
  • Melt Pool Dimensions: Melt pool widths and depths showed only a weak dependence on gas properties. A slight trend of decreasing dimensions with increasing helium content was observed, consistent with the slightly higher heat transfer. Experimentally, widths ranged from 180–195 µm and depths from 141–160 µm. Simulations yielded widths of 214–217 µm and depths of 103–106 µm.
  • Heating and Cooling Rates: Globally similar heating and cooling rates were observed across different gases. The highest heating rates (up to 10⁸ K/s) were near the laser interaction zone, while cooling rates were in the range of 10⁶–10⁷ K/s. The gas flow influenced temperature rate distributions near the melt-gas interface.
  • Integral Heat Balance: The total enthalpy transfer rate of the melt pool was small compared to the energy input from the laser. Heat transfer to the substrate was dominant, while heat transfer to the gas was significantly smaller. Cooling due to evaporation was negligible.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Gas Flow Velocity: The study investigated a single gas flow velocity (1.5 m/s). The authors suggest future work should explore the influence of increased gas flow velocities on heat balance and melt pool dynamics.
  • Single-Line Trials: The experiments and simulations focused on single-line trials. Future research could extend these investigations to more complex geometries and multi-layer builds.
  • Gas-Material Interaction: While the study focused on heat transfer, further research could explore more complex interactions between the process gases and the molten metal, especially at higher temperatures.
  • Industrial Application: The authors suggest extending studies to more complex and larger geometries to further support industrial applications of PBF-LB/M.

Summary updated

Abstract

During the powder bed fusion of metals using a laser beam (PBF-LB/M), an inert atmosphere is maintained in the build chamber to avoid reactions of the liquid metal with ambient air leading to the creation of oxides or nitrides, which alter the mechanical properties of the processed part. A continuous gas flow is guided over the process zone to remove spatters and fumes. This flow induces a convective heat transfer from the molten metal to the gas, which, depending on the level of the heat flow, may alter the melt pool dimensions by influencing the cooling rate. The present work investigated these phenomena with single-line trials, both experimentally and numerically. For this reason, a smoothed-particle hydrodynamics model was utilized to investigate the temperatures of the melt pool, cooling rates, and the integral heat balance with various gas atmospheres. In parallel, an on-axis pyrometer was set up on an experimental PBF-LB/M machine to capture the surface emissions of the melt pool. The atmosphere in the simulations and experiments was varied between argon, helium, and two mixtures thereof. The results showed a slight increase in the cooling rates with an increasing fraction of helium in the process gas. Consistently, a slight decrease in the melt pool temperatures and dimensions was found.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{baehr2024investigations,
  author = {Siegfried Baehr and Fabian Fritz and Stefan Adami and Thomas Ammann and Nikolaus A. Adams and Michael F. Zaeh},
  title = {{Investigations on the Heat Balance of the Melt Pool during PBF-LB/M under Various Process Gases}},
  booktitle = {Metals},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/met14091058},
}
Figure