Abstract
This study aimed to understand the psychological health status and analyze the related factors of healthcare workers (HCWs) who provided aid in Hubei during the initial COVID-19 epidemic. Using the Self-Rating Scale of Sleep (SRSS), Generalized Anxiety Scale (GAD-7), and 9-item Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9), 210 subjects were analyzed. Results showed significantly higher SRSS scores compared to national norms, moderate anxiety levels, and mild depression. Key influencing factors included gender, patient mortality under care, history of psychosis, and family infection status. The findings suggest a critical need for individualized psychological support for frontline aid workers.
Introduction
When the COVID-19 pandemic first erupted in Wuhan, thousands of healthcare specialists from across China were deployed to Hubei Province. While early research focused on the clinical aspects of the virus, the psychological "second pandemic" affecting frontline workers emerged as a significant concern. These aid workers faced unique stressors: high infection risk, long-term separation from families, and the pressure of high-intensity environments. This study quantifies the mental health status of these individuals and identifies demographic and situational factors contributing to insomnia, anxiety, and depression.
Methods
A cross-sectional study was conducted between January and February 2020, recruiting 220 healthcare workers, with 210 completing the full assessment (105 men, 105 women). The cohort included 147 nurses (70%) and 63 physicians (30%), with an average age of approximately 30 years. Data were collected via an online survey using three standardized instruments:
- Self-Rating Scale of Sleep (SRSS): A 10-item scale to assess sleep quality.
- Generalized Anxiety Scale (GAD-7): A 7-item scale to measure anxiety levels.
- 9-item Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9): A tool to screen for depression severity.
Statistical analysis involved one-way ANOVA for initial correlations and multiple stepwise linear regression models to identify independent predictors of mental health outcomes.
Results
The quantitative findings reveal a significant psychological burden on frontline workers:
Sleep Quality (SRSS)
The average SRSS score was 25.13, significantly higher (indicating worse sleep) than the national norm of 22.14 (p < 0.001). The regression model explained 48.1% of the variance in sleep quality. Primary influencing factors included gender, whether patients died under their charge, history of psychosis, and whether family members were infected with COVID-19.
Anxiety (GAD-7)
The average GAD-7 score was 12.37, indicating a moderate anxiety level. Key predictors were gender, years of work, history of psychosis, self-perceived health status, and family infection status.
Depression (PHQ-9)
The average PHQ-9 score was 8.90, falling into the mild depression category. The primary influencing factors were whether the worker treated severely ill patients and their history of psychosis.
Discussion
Several key insights emerged regarding the vulnerability of aid workers:
- Gender and Coping Mechanisms: Male workers were particularly susceptible to more serious sleep and anxiety problems. This may be due to a "repressive" approach to stress, where negative emotions are suppressed rather than processed, leading to physical manifestations like insomnia.
- Impact of Patient Mortality: Witnessing patient deaths was a strong predictor of poor sleep, highlighting the specific trauma associated with high-stakes medical environments.
- Pre-existing Vulnerability: A history of psychological disorders was a consistent factor across all scales, suggesting that pandemic stress acts as a powerful trigger for those with a baseline vulnerability.
- Isolation Stressors: Unlike local staff, aid workers were isolated in hotels away from their support systems. The most requested forms of help were psychological support and improved communication with families.
Conclusion
During the COVID-19 outbreak, symptoms of insomnia and anxiety were prominent among healthcare workers aiding Hubei. Male workers, those experiencing patient deaths, and those with prior psychological histories faced the most severe challenges. Future interventions should be tailored to individual circumstances, implementing fast-acting psychological assistance programs such as focus-solving therapy and music therapy to help frontline workers process trauma in real-time.
Summary updated