Investigation on the Coupling Coordination Relationship between Electric Power Green Development and Ecological Civilization Construction in China: A Case Study of Beijing

Jianxue Chai, Lihui Zhang, Meng Yang, Qingyun Nie, Lei NieSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel model to analyze the complex, intertwined development of electric power green development (EPGD) and ecological civilization construction (ECC) in China. By combining advanced analytical techniques, the study reveals Beijing's progress from a "slightly unbalanced" to a "highly balanced" state in this relationship, offering crucial insights for policy development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China faces a critical challenge in balancing rapid economic growth with environmental sustainability. Two key national strategies, Ecological Civilization Construction (ECC) and the Energy Revolution, are designed to address this. While EPGD is a cornerstone of the Energy Revolution and ECC is a broad framework for sustainable development, their interconnectedness and how they influence each other's progress have not been thoroughly studied. This paper aims to fill that gap by quantifying the coupling coordination relationship between EPGD and ECC, understanding their mutual influence, and identifying areas for improvement.

Methods

The authors propose a multi-faceted analytical model:

  • Evaluation Index System: They first establish comprehensive index systems for both EPGD and ECC, drawing from policy documents and existing literature. These systems break down each broad concept into measurable components.
  • Coupling Coordination Degree Model (CCDM): This standard model is used to quantify the degree of interaction and harmony between the two subsystems.
  • Improved Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) based on Cloud Model: This is the paper's key methodological innovation. Traditional AHP can be subjective. By integrating a "cloud model," which can represent qualitative concepts with numerical features (expectation, entropy, hyper entropy), the authors aim to better capture the ambiguity and randomness inherent in expert judgments when assigning weights to indicators. This makes the weight determination more objective and reflective of decision-makers' true intentions.
  • Regression Model: Linear regression is employed to analyze the influence of first-level indicators of one subsystem on the other, helping to identify key drivers and dependencies.

Datasets

The study uses time-series data for Beijing from 2004 to 2017. The data sources include:

  • Beijing Statistical Yearbook
  • China Electric Power Yearbook
  • China Energy Statistical Yearbook
  • Literature

The authors state that the data used is credible. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing data was analyzed using the developed model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interdependence is Crucial: The study strongly emphasizes that EPGD and ECC are not independent efforts but are deeply intertwined. Progress in one directly impacts the other, and coordinated development is essential for overall sustainability.
  • Cloud Model for Subjectivity: The integration of the cloud model into AHP is a significant methodological contribution, offering a more robust way to handle subjective expert opinions in complex evaluations.
  • Beijing's Progress: Beijing has shown a clear positive trajectory, moving from a "slightly unbalanced" state in 2004-2006 to a "highly balanced" state by 2016-2017, indicating successful efforts in coordinating EPGD and ECC.
  • Key Drivers Identified: The research pinpoints specific indicators that have the most significant impact. For EPGD on ECC, grid-side green development is key. For ECC on EPGD, ecological economy is the most influential.

Key Results

  • Beijing's Development Stages: Beijing's coupling coordination between EPGD and ECC progressed through three stages: "slightly unbalanced" (2004-2006), "barely balanced" (2007-2015), and "highly balanced" (2016-2017).
  • Weightiest Indicators:
    • For EPGD: "Proportion of clean energy power generation" (G12) is the most weighted indicator.
  • For ECC: "Proportion of energy saving and environmental protection expenditure" (E26) is the most weighted indicator.
  • Weakest Links:
    • For EPGD: "Proportion of clean energy installed capacity" (G11) and "Annual utilization hours of power generating equipment" (G15).
  • For ECC: "Water resources per capita" (E13) and "Forest area per capita" (E14).
  • Regression Findings:
    • Grid-side green development (G2) has the largest impact on ECC.
  • Ecological economy (E3) has the greatest impact on EPGD.
  • High Coupling Degree: The coupling degree (CD) between EPGD and ECC in Beijing remained high throughout the study period, suggesting a strong inherent connection.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Index System Universality: The authors acknowledge that the evaluation index system is relatively basic and universal. They suggest that future research should develop more differentiated index systems tailored to the specific characteristics of different countries and regions.
  • Policy Recommendations: The paper provides policy recommendations for Beijing, focusing on improving weak links and leveraging influential factors. Future work could involve implementing and evaluating these recommendations.
  • Further Model Refinement: While the improved AHP with cloud model is a novel contribution, further exploration and validation of its application in similar complex systems could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the context of ecological civilization construction (ECC) and energy revolution strategy, there are many studies on ECC or electric power green development (EPGD). However, EPGD and ECC influence each other and are closely related, and there are few studies on the development relationship of EPGD and ECC. Therefore, this paper aims to study the coupling coordination relationship between EPGD and ECC to make them develop in harmony. Firstly, an evaluation index system of EPGD and ECC for their coupling coordination relationship is proposed. Then, this paper combines the coupling coordination degree model (CCDM), improved analytic hierarchy process (AHP) based on cloud model, and regression model to propose a coupling coordination relationship analysis model for EPGD and ECC. The improved AHP based on cloud model can fully reflect the will of decision-makers and effectively deal with the ambiguity and randomness of weight judgment. Finally, this paper conducts an empirical study on Beijing and verifies the applicability of the model proposed in this study. Policy recommendations to promote EPGD and ECC are proposed based on weight analysis, coupling coordination degree (CCD) analysis and regression analysis. This paper provides tools for the study on policies related to power development and ecological civilization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chai2020investigation,
  author = {Jianxue Chai and Lihui Zhang and Meng Yang and Qingyun Nie and Lei Nie},
  title = {{Investigation on the Coupling Coordination Relationship between Electric Power Green Development and Ecological Civilization Construction in China: A Case Study of Beijing}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12218845},
}
Figure