Investigation of Turbulence Characteristics Influenced by Flow Velocity, Roughness, and Eccentricity in Horizontal Annuli Based on Numerical Simulation

Yanchao Sun, Jialiang Sun, Jie Zhang, Ning HuangSymmetry 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses numerical simulations to investigate how flow velocity, pipe roughness, and eccentricity affect turbulence in horizontal annular flows, common in industries like petroleum and food engineering. The findings reveal that increased roughness significantly amplifies wall shear stress and turbulence, while eccentricity leads to uneven flow distributions but can also reduce drag, offering valuable insights for optimizing industrial piping systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Annular flow channels, where a fluid flows between two concentric or eccentric cylinders, are prevalent in many industrial applications. Understanding the complex flow dynamics within these channels is crucial for optimizing processes and equipment. While research has explored smooth annuli and positive eccentricities, the combined effects of pipe roughness (both inner and outer) and both positive and negative eccentricities on turbulent flow characteristics, particularly their impact on pressure drop, remain less understood. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by systematically investigating these factors using numerical simulations.

Methods

The researchers employed the Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations to model the turbulent flow. Specifically, they utilized the Shear Stress Transfer (SST) turbulence model, a hybrid model known for its ability to handle both near-wall and free-stream turbulence effectively. The numerical model was validated against experimental data for pressure drop, ensuring its reliability. Simulations were conducted using ANSYS Fluent, with a hexahedral meshing strategy and a y+ value of 0.9 at the wall to accurately capture near-wall phenomena. The study explored various combinations of flow velocities, roughness values (smooth, 0.25 mm for inner, 1 mm for outer), and eccentricity ratios (-0.9 to 0.9).

Datasets

The study used experimental data for model validation. Specifically, they collected pressure drop measurements from a custom-designed experimental platform. This platform featured an outer tube (110 mm inner diameter) and an inner tube (63 mm inner diameter), with a total length of 8 meters. The experiments were conducted with air at flow velocities ranging from 8 to 13 m/s, corresponding to Reynolds numbers between 22,900 and 37,213. The data from this experimental setup served as the benchmark for verifying the accuracy of the numerical simulations. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Roughness is a major driver of turbulence and shear stress: Increasing roughness on either the inner or outer pipe significantly amplifies wall shear stress and turbulence intensity. This effect is more pronounced when the inner pipe is rough.
  • Eccentricity creates asymmetry but can reduce drag: While eccentricity leads to uneven velocity, turbulence intensity, and shear stress distributions (higher in the wider gap, lower in the narrower gap), it also exhibits drag-reducing characteristics.
  • Symmetry persists even with eccentricity: Despite the uneven flow distribution caused by eccentricity, the overall flow characteristics (velocity, turbulence intensity, and wall shear stress) exhibit axial symmetry, which is crucial for practical engineering applications.
  • Reynolds number amplifies shear stress: As the Reynolds number increases, both inner and outer pipe wall shear forces increase, and the difference between them widens, indicating a stronger influence of flow velocity on shear stress at higher speeds.

Key Results

  • Roughness Impact: In Case 2 (inner tube roughness of 0.25 mm), wall shear stress on the rough inner tube increased by 25% compared to smooth tubes (Case 1), while the outer tube saw a 3% increase. In Case 3 (outer tube roughness of 1 mm), the outer tube shear stress increased by 107.6%, and the inner tube by 17.3%. In Case 4 (both rough), inner tube shear stress increased by 48.3%, and outer tube by 113.3%.
  • Eccentricity and Shear Force: With an inner tube eccentricity of 0.6, the average shear force on both inner and outer tubes reduced by approximately 17-17.9% compared to the concentric case. At an eccentricity of 0.9, this reduction increased to 35.7-36.4%.
  • Turbulence Intensity: Roughness generally leads to higher turbulence intensity, especially near the walls. Eccentricity causes turbulence intensity to increase in the wider annulus and decrease in the narrower annulus.
  • Model Validation: The numerical simulations showed strong agreement with experimental data for pressure drop gradients, validating the RANS model's predictive capabilities.

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges that while the RANS model provides a good balance of accuracy and computational efficiency, it has limitations in fully capturing all turbulent phenomena. The authors suggest that future work could explore more advanced turbulence models or direct numerical simulations (DNS) for even higher fidelity. Additionally, while the study focused on horizontal annuli, extending this research to inclined or vertical annuli could provide broader applicability. The paper also highlights that further investigation into the specific mechanisms of turbulence generation and dissipation under various roughness and eccentricity conditions would be beneficial for refining engineering designs.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{sun2025investigation,
  author = {Yanchao Sun and Jialiang Sun and Jie Zhang and Ning Huang},
  title = {{Investigation of Turbulence Characteristics Influenced by Flow Velocity, Roughness, and Eccentricity in Horizontal Annuli Based on Numerical Simulation}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/sym17030409},
}
Figure