Investigation of the Pauli paramagnetic effect in systematically tuned NbN thin films

Xiaoni Wang, Lijie Wang, Yixin Liu, Wanpeng Gao, Yu Wu, Zulei Xu, Hua Jin, Lu Zhang, Wei Peng, Zhen Wang, Wei Li, Gang Mu, Zhirong LinarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have systematically mapped the superconducting limits of Niobium Nitride (NbN) thin films by tuning their growth conditions. They discovered that the upper critical magnetic field in these films consistently exceeds the theoretical Pauli paramagnetic limit, a phenomenon driven by high normal-state resistivity and described accurately by the extended Werthamer–Helfand–Hohenberg (WHH) model.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Niobium Nitride (NbN) is a workhorse material in quantum technology, used extensively in superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors (SNSPDs) and SQUIDs. While it is known for having a high upper critical field ($B_{c2}$)—the maximum magnetic field a superconductor can withstand before returning to a normal state—the specific physics governing this limit in thin films has remained murky.

In type-II superconductors like NbN, $B_{c2}$ is limited by two main factors:

  1. Orbital pair-breaking: The magnetic field exerts a Lorentz force on the superconducting electrons, eventually ripping the Cooper pairs apart.
  2. Pauli paramagnetic effect: The magnetic field interacts with the electron spins. At high enough fields, it becomes energetically favorable for spins to align with the field, breaking the singlet state of the Cooper pair.

The authors sought to disentangle these effects and understand how film thickness, resistivity, and anisotropy (field direction) influence the superconducting-to-normal transition.

Methods

The team fabricated eight distinct NbN thin film samples using DC reactive magnetron sputtering. By precisely varying the nitrogen ($N_2$) content in the Ar/$N_2$ gas mixture and the chamber pressure, they were able to "tune" the physical properties of the films.

  • Characterization: They used Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) and Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) to ensure film smoothness (roughness < 0.3 nm) and X-ray reflectivity (XRR) to confirm thicknesses between 20–30 nm.
  • Transport Measurements: Electrical resistivity was measured in temperatures down to ~2 K and magnetic fields up to 12 T.
  • Modeling: The data was analyzed using the extended WHH model, which accounts for both orbital and Pauli effects, and the 2D Ginzburg-Landau (GL) model to investigate dimensionality effects.

Datasets

The primary "dataset" consists of the eight samples (labeled W2 through W12) characterized in Table I. These samples represent a systematic sweep of:

  • Nitrogen content: 21% to 50%.
  • Normal-state resistivity ($\rho_n$): Ranging from 0.5 to 3.4 m$\Omega$ cm.
  • Critical Temperature ($T_c$): Ranging from 2.5 K to 9.8 K.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Breaking the Pauli Limit: In all samples, the measured $B_{c2}$ exceeded the Clogston-Chandrasekhar (Pauli) limit ($B_p$). This indicates that the Pauli paramagnetic effect is a significant factor in NbN, but the material is surprisingly resilient to it.
  • Resistivity as a Driver: The authors found a linear correlation between the Maki parameter ($\alpha$)—which quantifies the strength of the Pauli effect—and the normal-state resistivity. This suggests that the "dirtier" (more resistive) the film, the more prominent the Pauli paramagnetic effect becomes.
  • Dimensionality Crossover: When the magnetic field is parallel to the film, the system behaves like a 2D superconductor near $T_c$. However, as the temperature drops and the superconducting penetration depth changes, the system deviates from 2D behavior, suggesting a transition toward 3D physics at high fields.
  • Universal Scaling: The relationship between the Maki parameter and the slope of the critical field near $T_c$ in NbN closely mirrors that of iron-based superconductors. This suggests that NbN thin films share similar strong-coupling physics with these more "exotic" materials.

Key Results

  • Tunability: The researchers successfully tuned $T_c$ across a wide range (2.5 K to 9.8 K) and increased resistivity by more than six times.
  • WHH Fit: The out-of-plane critical field ($B_{c2}^{\perp}$) was perfectly described by the extended WHH model with a Maki parameter $\alpha \approx 1.1$ (for sample W5) and negligible spin-orbit scattering ($\lambda_{so} \approx 0$).
  • Anisotropy: The parallel critical field ($B_{c2}^{\parallel}$) was consistently higher than the perpendicular field, confirming a strong anisotropic effect in these thin films.
  • 2D GL Agreement: For parallel fields, the data followed the $B_{c2} \propto (1 - T/T_c)^{0.5}$ relationship expected for 2D systems in the low-field region (below ~6 T).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors note that while the 2D GL model works well near $T_c$, it fails at lower temperatures/higher fields due to the film thickness (20-30 nm) falling into an "intermediate range." In this regime, the thickness is larger than the coherence length but smaller than the penetration depth.

Future research could explore even thinner films to maintain 2D behavior across the entire temperature range or investigate how different substrates might influence the spin-orbit scattering, which was found to be "unconspicuous" in this specific study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Superconductivity and the normal-state properties of NbN films can be tuned in a wide range, supplying a suitable platform to investigate the systematical evolution of the superconducting performances. Herein, we report the upper critical field of NbN films in both the vertical ($B\perp$ film) and parallel ($B\parallel$ film) orientations over a wide temperature range. Eight samples with the superconducting critical temperature $T_c$ ranging from 2.5 K to 9.8 K are studied. Meanwhile, the normal-state resistivity is tuned by more than six times by changing the conditions of the film growth. It is found that the magnitudes of the upper critical field in both field directions ($B_{c2}^{\perp}$ and $B_{c2}^{\parallel}$) exceed the paramagnetic limiting field $B_p$. The temperature dependent $B_{c2}^{\perp}$ can be described by the extended Werthamer--Helfand--Hohenberg (WHH) model considering the Pauli spin paramagnetism. Meanwhile, the $B_{c2}^{\parallel}$-$T$ data shows the feature of two-dimensional superconductivity in the temperature range near $T_c$. The evolution of the obtained Maki parameter with other parameters, such as the slope of the upper critical field near $T_c$ and the normal-state resistivity, are discussed to reveal the characteristics of the Pauli paramagnetic effect in this system.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2022investigation,
  author = {Xiaoni Wang and Lijie Wang and Yixin Liu and Wanpeng Gao and Yu Wu and Zulei Xu and Hua Jin and Lu Zhang and Wei Peng and Zhen Wang and Wei Li and Gang Mu and Zhirong Lin},
  title = {{Investigation of the Pauli paramagnetic effect in systematically tuned NbN thin films}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2211.05373},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.05373},
}
Figure