Investigation of the Dominant Effects of Non-Spherical Particles on Particle–Wall Collisions

Zhoutao Cen, Yuxin Wu, Jingyu Wang, Jie Liu, Minmin Zhou, Shukuan Chen, Dongqiang ZhaoProcesses 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the shape of particles, wall roughness, and impact angle influence particle-wall collisions, crucial for understanding gas-solid flows in industrial settings. They found that particle sphericity and wall roughness are the most significant factors, leading to the development of a four-parameter model capable of predicting the behavior of non-spherical particles on rough steel walls.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gas-solid flows are ubiquitous in industries like power generation and chemical engineering. Accurately simulating these flows, especially when particles interact with surfaces (particle-wall collisions or PWC), is vital for designing efficient equipment like pulverizers and cyclones. Current simulation models often rely on simplified assumptions about particle behavior, particularly for non-spherical particles, which are common in real-world applications (e.g., coal, biomass). Existing research has primarily focused on spherical particles or has yielded scattered results for non-spherical ones, highlighting a need for a better understanding of the dominant factors influencing PWC and a more generalized predictive model for these complex particle shapes.

Methods

The researchers conducted extensive experimental investigations using a high-speed camera setup to capture particle trajectories. They employed a variety of non-spherical particles, including glass powder, coal, and biomass, colliding with both polished and unpolished steel walls. The experimental setup allowed for controlled impact angles and velocities. Particle motion data was extracted using a custom MATLAB algorithm. The core of their analysis involved calculating two key coefficients: the restitution coefficient ($e$), which describes the energy retained after a collision, and the friction coefficient ($f$), which quantifies the tangential force during impact. They then analyzed how these coefficients varied with parameters like particle size, sphericity, wall roughness, and impact angle. Finally, they developed and validated a four-parameter model to predict PWC behavior.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data collected from particle-wall collision experiments. The dataset comprised over 52,000 valid collision events involving various non-spherical particles (coal, biomass, glass powder, Shepherd's purse seed) impacting polished and unpolished steel walls across a range of impact angles and velocities. This dataset represents a novel benchmark for non-spherical particle-wall interactions, encompassing a wider variety of particle types and conditions than many previous studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sphericity and Roughness Reign Supreme: The most impactful takeaway is that particle shape (sphericity) and wall surface texture (roughness) are the dominant factors governing particle-wall collision behavior, often overshadowing particle size and impact velocity.
  • Non-Spherical Particles Behave Similarly (on Rough Walls): Surprisingly, despite differences in material and size, many non-spherical particles (coal, glass powder, biomass) exhibited similar collision behaviors when impacting a rough steel wall. This suggests a unifying principle for these complex shapes under certain conditions.
  • Size Matters Less for Non-Sphericals: Unlike spherical particles, where size can significantly influence collision coefficients, the effect of particle diameter on the collision coefficients of non-spherical particles was found to be negligible.
  • A Universal Model is Possible: The consistent behavior observed for non-spherical particles on rough walls paved the way for a generalized four-parameter model that can predict rebound motions across a broad range of these particles.

Key Results

  • The restitution coefficient ($e$) generally decreases with increasing impact angle for non-spherical particles, while the friction coefficient ($f$) shows a more linear decrease with increasing impact angle.
  • For non-spherical particles impacting rough steel walls, the restitution coefficient ($e$) was found to be significantly lower (0.2-0.4) compared to spherical glass particles (0.6-0.8) at large impact angles.
  • The developed four-parameter model, fitted using experimental data from Coal A particles, demonstrated good agreement with experimental data for various non-spherical particles (coal, biomass) on rough steel walls, achieving a relative error of 6.0%.
  • The model's predictions showed deviations for polished steel walls, indicating that while the model captures general trends, specific wall surface properties can introduce variations.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the developed model shows deviations when applied to polished steel walls, suggesting that further refinement might be needed for different surface conditions. While the model is effective for a wide range of non-spherical particles, its accuracy might be limited for extremely unique particle shapes or under conditions not covered by the experiments (e.g., very high temperatures, different gas environments). Future work could focus on extending the model to include a wider range of wall materials and surface conditions, as well as investigating the influence of particle-particle interactions and more complex flow regimes. The authors also suggest that the model could be further improved by incorporating more detailed particle morphology parameters beyond simple sphericity.

Summary updated

Abstract

A deep understanding of the particle–wall collision (PWC) behaviors of non-spherical particles is important for managing gas–solid flows in industrial applications. It is important to identify the dominant parameters and to develop the common PWC prediction models for typical non-spherical particles. In this paper, different types of non-spherical particles were used to conduct the fundamental experiments. The effects of key parameters such as particle size, non-sphericity, wall roughness, and impact angle were analyzed. The results show that the trends of the collision coefficients with the impact angle for all non-spherical particles are similar. The dominant factors of particle–wall collisions are particle sphericity and wall roughness. A model with four parameters was fitted from the experimental data. The model can predict the collisions of non-spherical particles on rough steel walls with sizes ranging from 50 to 550 microns.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cen2024investigation,
  author = {Zhoutao Cen and Yuxin Wu and Jingyu Wang and Jie Liu and Minmin Zhou and Shukuan Chen and Dongqiang Zhao},
  title = {{Investigation of the Dominant Effects of Non-Spherical Particles on Particle–Wall Collisions}},
  booktitle = {Processes},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/pr12061234},
}
Figure