Investigation of the Current Situation of Museum Audio Exhibition in Beijing Area and Countermeasures

Zihan Zhou, Li Zheng-yan, Tailin Pan, Jian Li, Yuexin SunSHS 2023 · DOI

This paper, published in the SHS Web of Conferences, provides a critical look at how Beijing—a city aiming to become a global "museum hub"—is utilizing audio to enhance the visitor experience. While visual displays have seen rapid technological advancement, the authors argue that audio remains an underutilized and often monotonous tool in the museum toolkit.

TL;DR

While Beijing's museums are world-class in visual curation, their audio exhibitions often suffer from "monologue fatigue" and a lack of interactive depth. This study audits eight major museums to identify a significant lag between audio innovation and digital display technology, proposing a shift toward immersive "scene restoration" and interactive soundscapes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors address the "visual bias" in contemporary museum curation. While high-quality visual exhibits are standard, sound is often relegated to simple, one-way audio guides. In the context of Beijing’s "14th Five-Year Plan," which aims to construct a "museum city," the quality of public cultural supply is under scrutiny.

The core challenge identified is inconsistency: some museums have excellent on-site audio but a poor digital presence, while others rely on "spoon-fed" knowledge delivery that fails to engage younger, tech-savvy audiences. The paper seeks to bridge the gap between primitive audio transmission and modern immersive technology.

Methods

The researchers employed a dual-track field research method:

  1. On-site Investigation: The authors visited eight representative museums in Beijing, recording audio application forms (background music, scene sound effects, video integration) and correlating these with visitor numbers.
  2. Online Audit: They analyzed the digital footprint of these museums across five major platforms: official websites, Microblog (Weibo), WeChat, TikTok (Douyin), and Bilibili.
  3. Categorization: Museums were divided into six functional categories (e.g., historical, intangible heritage, natural science, small-scale characteristic) to facilitate a systematic comparison across 10 main characteristic fields.

Datasets

The "dataset" for this study consists of a curated sample of Beijing’s cultural landscape:

  • The 8 Museums: National Museum of China, the Palace Museum, China Intangible Cultural Heritage Museum, Beijing Museum of Natural History, National Art Museum of China, Memorial Museum of Lao She, Beijing Sound Museum, and the Capital Museum.
  • Digital Platforms: Official websites and social media accounts (Microblog, WeChat, TikTok, Bilibili) for each institution.
  • Metrics: Fan counts (as of Dec 2022), visitor density in specific halls, and the variety of audio-visual elements present.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Audio-Visitor Correlation": There is a direct positive correlation between the abundance of audio-visual elements and visitor numbers. Halls with ambient sound (like the "Sound of the Alley" in the Beijing Sound Museum) attract significantly more visitors, particularly families, than those relying on silent displays.
  • Small Scale, High Innovation: Surprisingly, small-scale "characteristic" museums often outperform massive national institutions in audio creativity. For example, the Beijing Sound Museum uses over 200 types of "old Beijing" sounds (peddling, pigeon flutes) to create a more immersive environment than the traditional monologues found in larger historical museums.
  • The Monologue Trap: Most top-tier museums still rely on "monologue" style guides—either through human explainers or devices. The authors argue this leads to "sensory boredom" and fails to leverage the "scene restoration" potential of sound.
  • The "Paid Content" Barrier: A notable friction point identified was that some museums (like the Memorial Museum of Lao She) require payment for certain online audio explanations, which the authors suggest negatively impacts the sensory experience and accessibility.

Key Results

  • Social Media Dominance: The Palace Museum leads with over 10 million Microblog fans, successfully integrating panoramic digital exhibitions with audio-visual halls.
  • Technological Lag: Audio display apparently lags behind visual display in terms of quantity, quality, and interactive form. Most audio is still "automatic circulation" rather than "interactive on-demand."
  • Successful Case Studies: The National Museum’s "Compiling Canon in A Flourishing Age" exhibition was highlighted for its multi-sensory approach, integrating visual, auditory, and even olfactory senses to lead visitors "into" landscape paintings.
  • Sensor Integration: The Beijing Museum of Natural History successfully uses infrared sensors to trigger animal cries (e.g., bird chirps or dinosaur roars) as visitors pass, narrowing the gap between the visitor and the displayed context.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The study is geographically limited to Beijing, which may not represent broader national or international museum trends. * The analysis is largely qualitative; while fan counts are provided, more granular data on visitor dwell time or specific learning outcomes related to audio would strengthen the findings. * The paper does not deeply explore the budgetary or technical constraints that prevent smaller museums from adopting high-end immersive audio.

Future Work: The authors suggest that museums should move toward "interactive product concepts" rather than "single exhibit concepts." This includes using AI for voice recognition, creating "IP" (Intellectual Property) for specific national treasures through audio storytelling, and forming industry alliances to share technical expertise in audio-visual innovation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Audio, colorful and effective features are what the cultural inheritance pursues. However, the application status of audio exhibition in contemporary museums is very inconsistent. Through investigating the current status of audio exhibition, including the audio content uploaded by corresponding museums to the online media, in museums with different types in Beijing area, this paper analyzes and summarizes the main characteristics and problems of audio exhibitions in museums in the current stage, and further proposes countermeasures and suggestions, with the expectation of enlightening the promotion of the propagation of museum culture in Beijing area.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2023investigation,
  author = {Zihan Zhou and LI Zheng-yan and Tailin Pan and Jian Li and Yuexin Sun},
  title = {{Investigation of the Current Situation of Museum Audio Exhibition in Beijing Area and Countermeasures}},
  booktitle = {SHS},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1051/shsconf/202315801014},
}
Figure