Investigation of Rectifier Responses Affecting Operational Bandwidth in an Electromagnetic Vibration Energy Harvester

Rui Zhong, Xueying Jin, Beichen Duan, Chung Ket Thein2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how different rectifier circuits impact the operational bandwidth of electromagnetic vibration energy harvesters (EMVEHs). The study reveals that half-wave rectifiers, particularly when using Schottky diodes, offer significantly wider bandwidths compared to traditional full-bridge rectifiers, which is crucial for powering wireless sensor nodes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless Sensor Nodes (WSNs) are increasingly vital for industrial monitoring, but their widespread adoption is hindered by power supply limitations. Vibration Energy Harvesters (VEHs) offer a promising solution, but their effectiveness is often constrained by their operational bandwidth – the range of frequencies over which they can efficiently deliver power. While the choice of rectifier is known to affect power output, its specific impact on the bandwidth of EMVEHs has been under-explored. This paper aims to fill this gap by systematically comparing the bandwidth performance of half-wave and full-bridge rectifier configurations using different diode types.

Methods

The researchers established circuit models for an electromagnetic vibration energy harvester (EMVEH) incorporating both half-wave and full-bridge rectifiers. These models were then used to derive theoretical expressions for the load voltage in the frequency domain. Experimentally, they utilized a single-degree-of-freedom cantilever beam EMVEH. The system was subjected to harmonic vibrations using a shaker, and the output voltage across various load resistors (100-800 Ω) was measured using a DAQ card. Two types of rectifier diodes were tested: the common high-speed switching diode 1N4148 and the Schottky diode MBR745. The experiments focused on a sweep mode of operation (18-21 Hz) to analyze the voltage-frequency response and determine the maximum power and bandwidth for each configuration.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from their setup.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rectifier Choice Matters for Bandwidth: The most significant finding is that the rectifier circuit design has a substantial impact on the operational bandwidth of EMVEHs, a parameter often overlooked in favor of peak power.
  • Half-Wave Rectifiers Shine in Bandwidth: Contrary to the common assumption that full-bridge rectifiers are always superior, this study demonstrates that half-wave rectifiers can offer a wider bandwidth, especially for low-power applications where diode losses are more pronounced.
  • Schottky Diodes are Key: The use of Schottky diodes (MBR745) consistently leads to broader bandwidths compared to standard switching diodes (1N4148), regardless of the rectifier configuration. This is attributed to their lower forward voltage drop and faster switching characteristics.
  • Synergy for Maximum Bandwidth: The combination of a half-wave rectifier with Schottky diodes yields the most significant bandwidth improvement, outperforming full-bridge configurations with standard diodes.

Key Results

The experimental results showed that:

  • For a load resistance of 100 Ω, replacing a full-bridge rectifier with high-speed switching diodes (1N4148) with a half-wave rectifier using Schottky diodes (MBR745) resulted in a 1.9 times increase in load bandwidth.
  • In general, half-wave rectifiers provided a wider bandwidth than full-bridge rectifiers across various load resistances and diode types. For instance, at 100 Ω with Schottky diodes, the half-wave rectifier's bandwidth was 1.33 times that of the full-bridge rectifier.
  • The trend of increasing load voltage with increasing load resistance was observed for all configurations, but the growth rate decreased, leading to a peak power that initially increased and then decreased.
  • Bandwidth generally showed a slight decrease with increasing load resistance, though this effect was less pronounced than the impact of rectifier type and diode choice.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Ripple Coefficient Not Explicitly Addressed: While the paper mentions that ripples can cause interference, the primary focus is on bandwidth and peak power. The ripple coefficient, an important factor for practical WSN applications, is not deeply analyzed.
  • Focus on Specific Frequency Range: The experiments were conducted within a narrow frequency sweep (18-21 Hz). A broader frequency analysis might reveal more nuanced behaviors.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future research should consider other crucial parameters like the ripple coefficient and power factor to achieve a balanced design for harvester circuit designers. They also emphasize the need for further profound study into the merit of half-wave rectifiers for powering WSNs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Energy harvesters provide excellent solutions for the power supply problem of wireless sensor nodes (WSNs), and energy harvesters with a wider bandwidth will clearly better serve WSNs and assist in the construction of Industry 4.0. However, the bearing of rectifiers on the load bandwidth of energy harvesters has rarely been investigated. This paper focuses on the impact of diverse rectifiers on the load electrical response of an electromagnetic energy harvester in the sweep mode of experiments, especially on the load bandwidth. The rectifiers were set as a half-wave rectifier and a full-bridge rectifier, respectively, and two different rectifier diodes were adopted in the experiment. The experimental results suggest that the half-wave rectifier exhibited certain advantages especially in the bandwidth field. If a full-bridge rectifier using high-speed switching diodes is replaced with a half-wave rectifier using Schottky diodes under the load resistance of 100 Ω, the load bandwidth will increase by almost 1.9 times. A preliminary analysis of the experimental results is provided at length.
BibTeX
@misc{zhong2023investigation,
  author = {Rui Zhong and Xueying Jin and Beichen Duan and Chung Ket Thein},
  title = {{Investigation of Rectifier Responses Affecting Operational Bandwidth in an Electromagnetic Vibration Energy Harvester}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ecsa-10-16016},
}
Figure