Investigation of Deformation and Fracture Mechanisms in Two-dimensional Gallium Telluride Multilayers Using Nanoindentation

Yan Zhou, Zhou Shi, Penghua Ying, Qinghua Zhao, Yong Xie, Mingming Gong, Pisu Jiang, Hui Cai, Bin Chen, Sefaattin Tongay, Wanqi Jie, Jin Zhang, Tao Wang, Dong Liu, Martin KuballarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Two-dimensional (2D) materials possess great potential for flexible devices, ascribing to their outstanding electrical, optical, and mechanical properties. However, their mechanical deformation property and fracture mechanism, which are inescapable in many applications like flexible optoelectronics, are still unclear or not thoroughly investigated due methodology limitations. In light of this, such mechanical properties and mechanisms are explored on example of gallium telluride (GaTe), a promising optoelectronic candidate with an ultrahigh photo-responsibility and a high plasticity within 2D family. Considering the driving force insufficient in atomic force microscopy (AFM)-based nanoindentation method, here the mechanical properties of both substrate-supported and suspended GaTe multilayers were systematically investigated through full-scale Berkovich-tip nanoindentation, micro-Raman spectroscopy, AFM, and scanning electron microscopy. An unusual concurrence of multiple pop-in and load-drop events in loading curve was observed. By further correlating to molecular dynamics calculations, this concurrence was unveiled originating from the interlayer sliding mediated layers-by-layers fracture mechanism within GaTe multilayers. The van der Waals force between GaTe multilayers and substrates was revealed much stronger than that between GaTe interlayers, resulting in the easy sliding and fracture of multilayers within GaTe. This work provides new insights into the deformation and fracture mechanisms of GaTe and other similar 2D multilayers in flexible applications.

Introduction

Two-dimensional (2D) materials are highly sought after for flexible electronics due to their exceptional electrical and optical properties. Gallium Telluride (GaTe), in particular, is prized for its ultrahigh photo-responsivity. However, the mechanical reliability of these materials remains a critical bottleneck. Understanding how they deform and fracture under stress is essential for designing durable wearable devices. Previous research using Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM)-based nanoindentation often lacked the necessary force to fully explore deep structural changes or crack propagation. This study addresses this gap by using high-force nanoindentation to probe the mechanical limits of GaTe multilayers.

Experimental Methods

The researchers utilized full-scale Berkovich-tip nanoindentation, which allows for higher load applications compared to standard AFM techniques. This method was applied to both substrate-supported (on SiO2/Si) and suspended GaTe flakes ranging from ~300 nm to ~780 nm in thickness (approximately 178 to 459 layers). The experimental work was complemented by a multi-modal analysis:

  • Morphology & Topography: SEM and AFM were used for surface visualization and crack mapping.
  • Stress Mapping: Micro-Raman spectroscopy mapped residual stress and identified potential phase transitions.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD): Simulations using the LAMMPS code modeled atomic-scale interactions and the influence of internal defects like "void-clusters."

Results and Discussion

The PI-LD Concurrence and Layer-by-Layer Failure

A significant finding was the unusual concurrence of multiple "pop-in" (PI) and "load-drop" (LD) events during the loading phase. Pop-ins represent sudden increases in displacement at a constant load, while load-drops are sudden decreases in force.

Load-displacement curves for GaTe multilayers (a-c) and SiO2/Si substrate (d). Panels (a-c) illustrate Type I, II, and III behaviors with increasing indentation depth, highlighting pop-in and load-drop events indicative of internal fracture.

This PI-LD concurrence was linked to a "layer-by-layer" fracture mechanism mediated by interlayer sliding. Unlike bulk materials that might shatter, GaTe fails internally; layers fracture individually and slide over one another. This sliding acts as a strain-relief mechanism, contributing to the material's high plasticity. MD simulations revealed that the van der Waals (vdW) force between GaTe and the substrate (1.83 eV/nm²) is significantly stronger than the force between GaTe layers (0.56 eV/nm²), explaining why internal sliding is preferred over substrate detachment.

Stress and Defect Sensitivity

Raman mapping identified peak tensile stresses of approximately 1.3 GPa in the pile-up regions around indentations. Interestingly, in suspended samples, internal structural failure (indicated by pop-ins and load-drops) occurred even without visible surface damage, suggesting that subsurface degradation precedes catastrophic failure. Furthermore, MD simulations showed that "void-clusters" (common crystal defects) could reduce the maximum load capacity by roughly 50%, acting as triggers for the layer-by-layer fracture.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This investigation provides a detailed mechanical roadmap for GaTe multilayers, highlighting the critical role of interlayer sliding and layer-by-layer fracture. While MD simulations were limited by scale compared to experimental samples, this work establishes a foundation for predicting the mechanical reliability of 2D materials in flexible optoelectronic applications. Future research should focus on high-resolution TEM analysis to identify specific high-pressure phases and fatigue testing under cyclic loading to simulate real-world usage conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Two-dimensional (2D) materials possess great potential for flexible devices, ascribing to their outstanding electrical, optical, and mechanical properties. However, their mechanical deformation property and fracture mechanism, which are inescapable in many applications like flexible optoelectronics, are still unclear or not thoroughly investigated due methodology limitations. In light of this, such mechanical properties and mechanisms are explored on example of gallium telluride (GaTe), a promising optoelectronic candidate with an ultrahigh photo-responsibility and a high plasticity within 2D family. Considering the driving force insufficient in atomic force microscopy (AFM)-based nanoindentation method, here the mechanical properties of both substrate-supported and suspended GaTe multilayers were systematically investigated through full-scale Berkovich-tip nanoindentation, micro-Raman spectroscopy, AFM, and scanning electron microscopy. An unusual concurrence of multiple pop-in and load-drop events in loading curve was observed. By further correlating to molecular dynamics calculations, this concurrence was unveiled originating from the interlayer sliding mediated layers-by-layers fracture mechanism within GaTe multilayers. The van der Waals force between GaTe multilayers and substrates was revealed much stronger than that between GaTe interlayers, resulting in the easy sliding and fracture of multilayers within GaTe. This work provides new insights into the deformation and fracture mechanisms of GaTe and other similar 2D multilayers in flexible applications.
BibTeX
@misc{zhou2022investigation,
  author = {Yan Zhou and Zhou Shi and Penghua Ying and Qinghua Zhao and Yong Xie and Mingming Gong and Pisu Jiang and Hui Cai and Bin Chen and Sefaattin Tongay and Wanqi Jie and Jin Zhang and Tao Wang and Dong Liu and Martin Kuball},
  title = {{Investigation of Deformation and Fracture Mechanisms in Two-dimensional Gallium Telluride Multilayers Using Nanoindentation}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2204.11031},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2204.11031},
}
Figure