Investigation of cracks in GaN films grown by combined hydride and metal organic vapor-phase epitaxial method

Jianming Liu, Xianlin Liu, Chengming Li, Hongyuan Wei, Yan Guo, Jiao Chun-Mei, Zhiwei Li, Xiaoqing Xu, Huaping Song, Shaoyan Yang, Q.s. Zhu, Zhanguo Wang, Anli Yang, Tieying Yang, Huanhua WangNanoscale 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the formation and healing of cracks in thick GaN films grown using a novel combined MOCVD-HVPE technique. They found that cracks originate during the growth process due to accumulated tensile stress and are subsequently healed by lateral growth, rather than extending to the film surface or substrate.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gallium Nitride (GaN) is a crucial material for optoelectronic and high-power electronic devices, often grown as epitaxial films on foreign substrates like sapphire. The significant differences in thermal expansion coefficients (TEC) and lattice constants between GaN and these substrates lead to substantial residual stress in thick GaN films. This stress can cause cracking, which degrades device performance and yield. While hydride vapor-phase epitaxy (HVPE) is a cost-effective method for growing thick GaN, cracks are a common issue. This paper aims to understand the origin, distribution, and healing mechanism of these cracks in GaN films grown by a combined MOCVD-HVPE approach, which offers advantages like in-situ process control and reduced contamination.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to characterize the GaN films:

  • Combined MOCVD-HVPE Growth: A novel system integrated both techniques in a single chamber, allowing for the deposition of a GaN buffer layer by MOCVD followed by a thick GaN layer by HVPE.
  • High-Resolution X-ray Diffraction (HR-XRD): Used to determine the overall crystal quality (rocking curves) and lattice constants, providing insights into strain.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): Employed to observe the surface morphology and the cross-section of the films, revealing the presence and extent of cracks. Etching was used to expose subsurface cracks.
  • Micro-Raman Spectroscopy: A powerful tool for probing stress distribution within the film. By scanning along the depth of the film, they mapped the stress profile. The frequency of the E2 (high) phonon mode is particularly sensitive to in-plane strain.
  • Cathodoluminescence (CL): Used to reveal the effects of grain boundaries and dislocations on crack formation and propagation.
  • Cleaving and Etching: Cross-sections were prepared by cleaving and then lightly etched to compare the crystal quality of healed crack regions with uncracked areas.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the characterization of GaN films grown in their laboratory.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cracks Originate During Growth, Not Cooling: Contrary to some previous hypotheses, the evidence strongly suggests that the cracks form during the growth process itself, when accumulated tensile stress exceeds a critical threshold, rather than solely due to thermal stress during cooling.
  • Subsurface Cracks are the Norm: SEM analysis after etching revealed that cracks are primarily located within the film, not extending to the surface or the substrate interface.
  • Healing by Lateral Growth: The observation that the crystal quality of healed crack regions is comparable to uncracked areas, coupled with the morphology of the crack edges, points to a significant lateral growth rate that effectively "heals" the cracks during subsequent growth.
  • Complex Stress Profile: Micro-Raman depth profiling revealed a non-monotonic stress distribution, with compressive stress at the interface, a decrease, a sustained high value, another decrease, and a final increase near the surface. This complex profile likely contributes to the crack formation and healing dynamics.
  • Limited Interaction with Defects: CL mapping indicated that cracks do not appear to interact significantly with grain boundaries or dislocations, suggesting that the primary driver for cracking is the overall film stress.

Key Results

  • Cracks were observed in a 22-µm thick GaN film grown by the combined MOCVD-HVPE method.
  • SEM images showed cracks that were perpendicular to the film/substrate interface, pinched off at locations, and did not extend to the surface or substrate.
  • Micro-Raman spectroscopy revealed a complex stress distribution along the film depth.
  • Etching of cleaved cross-sections showed that healed crack regions had crystal quality similar to uncracked regions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Substrate Scope: The study focused on GaN grown on sapphire. Further investigation on other substrates would be valuable.
  • Specific Growth Conditions: The findings are specific to the combined MOCVD-HVPE parameters used. Optimizing these parameters for crack-free growth remains an area for exploration.
  • Quantitative Healing Mechanism: While lateral growth is proposed as the healing mechanism, a more quantitative analysis of the healing rate and its dependence on growth parameters could be beneficial.
  • Impact on Device Performance: While cracks are detrimental, the paper doesn't quantify the specific impact of these healed cracks on device performance. Future work could focus on correlating crack characteristics with device electrical and optical properties.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cracks appeared in GaN epitaxial layers which were grown by a novel method combining metal organic vapor-phase epitaxy (MOCVD) and hydride vapor-phase epitaxy (HVPE) in one chamber. The origin of cracks in a 22-μm thick GaN film was fully investigated by high-resolution X-ray diffraction (XRD), micro-Raman spectra, and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Many cracks under the surface were first observed by SEM after etching for 10 min. By investigating the cross section of the sample with high-resolution micro-Raman spectra, the distribution of the stress along the depth was determined. From the interface of the film/substrate to the top surface of the film, several turnings were found. A large compressive stress existed at the interface. The stress went down as the detecting area was moved up from the interface to the overlayer, and it was maintained at a large value for a long depth area. Then it went down again, and it finally increased near the top surface. The cross-section of the film was observed after cleaving and etching for 2 min. It was found that the crystal quality of the healed part was nearly the same as the uncracked region. This indicated that cracking occurred in the growth, when the tensile stress accumulated and reached the critical value. Moreover, the cracks would heal because of high lateral growth rate.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2011investigation,
  author = {Jianming Liu and Xianlin Liu and Chengming Li and Hongyuan Wei and Yan Guo and Jiao Chun-Mei and Zhiwei Li and Xiaoqing Xu and Huaping Song and Shaoyan Yang and Q.S. Zhu and Zhanguo Wang and Anli Yang and Tieying Yang and Huanhua Wang},
  title = {{Investigation of cracks in GaN films grown by combined hydride and metal organic vapor-phase epitaxial method}},
  booktitle = {Nanoscale},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1186/1556-276x-6-69},
}
Figure