Investigation of condensation shocks and re-entrant jet dynamics in a cavitating nozzle flow by Large-Eddy Simulation

Theresa Trummler, Steffen J. Schmidt, Nikolaus A. AdamsInternational Journal of Multiphase Flow 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Researchers from the Technical University of Munich have utilized high-fidelity Large-Eddy Simulations (LES) to investigate the complex dynamics of cloud cavitation in nozzle flows. Their study reveals a critical shift in the periodic vapor shedding mechanism: as cavitation intensifies, the driver transitions from liquid "re-entrant jets" to "condensation shocks." This marks the first documentation of such shocks in nozzles with a constant cross-section, providing new insights into the physics of cavitation-induced erosion and spray atomization.

Introduction

Cavitation—the rapid formation and collapse of vapor bubbles in a liquid—is a significant phenomenon in engineering, particularly in fuel injectors. While it can enhance spray atomization, it also leads to severe erosion and mass flow restrictions. "Cloud cavitation," characterized by the periodic shedding of vapor clouds, is especially violent. Traditionally, this shedding is attributed to a "re-entrant jet"—a thin liquid film moving upstream beneath the vapor. However, recent evidence suggests that "condensation shocks" (bubbly shock waves) may also play a role. This research aims to characterize the transition between these two mechanisms in standard constant-cross-section nozzles.

Methodology

The study employed Implicit Large-Eddy Simulation (LES) to resolve the turbulent interactions within the flow. The numerical framework included a multi-component mixture model tracking liquid, vapor, and non-condensable gas. A barotropic equilibrium cavitation model was used, assuming local thermodynamic equilibrium for phase changes. Crucially, the model accounts for full compressibility, which is vital for capturing the high-pressure shock waves generated during vapor collapse.

The nozzle geometry (a) and the refined computational mesh (b) used to capture complex flow features.

To manage computational demands, a structured grid was refined in stages, culminating in a final resolution of 51.5 million cells. Wall-normal spacing was maintained as small as 2.5 μm to accurately resolve near-wall dynamics.

Operating Conditions

The numerical results were validated against reference experiments involving a scaled-up, transparent step nozzle. The study focused on two distinct operating points representing different cavitation intensities.

Summary of the operating conditions and the resulting cavitation regimes.

The "developing cavitation" case ($σ = 1.19$) features a lower flow velocity where vapor fills only the initial portion of the nozzle. In contrast, the "super cavitation" case ($σ = 0.84$) involves higher velocities, with vapor structures extending nearly to the outlet.

Key Insights into Cavitation Dynamics

The simulations confirmed that the shedding mechanism is not universal but depends on the cavitation intensity. At $σ = 1.19$, the re-entrant jet is the dominant driver. However, at $σ = 0.84$, the flow is dominated by condensation shocks. This is a significant finding, as condensation shocks were previously thought to be exclusive to converging-diverging geometries.

The researchers also observed a transformation process where a re-entrant jet can evolve into a condensation shock as it moves upstream, particularly when the vapor cavity is attached to the nozzle wall. Furthermore, the rolling motion of detached vapor clouds induces an upstream flow that creates a feedback loop, amplifying the shedding cycle.

Results and Discussion

The LES results demonstrated excellent qualitative agreement with experimental high-speed imagery. The temporal accuracy was confirmed by the shedding frequency, with a Strouhal number ($Str \approx 0.3$) matching experimental values for cylindrical orifices. In the re-entrant jet regime, upstream velocities were measured at 30-50% of the mean flow velocity. These findings led the authors to propose updated schematics for the shedding process that distinguish between the behaviors of re-entrant jets and condensation shocks.

Conclusion

This study provides a breakthrough in understanding the physical mechanisms behind cloud cavitation in nozzles. While the current model successfully captures pressure peaks associated with erosion, future work could extend this to explicit material wear rate calculations. Additionally, investigating how these mechanisms manifest in more complex, real-world injector geometries—such as those with tapered holes or rounded inlets—remains a key area for further research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{trummler2020investigation,
  author = {Theresa Trummler and Steffen J. Schmidt and Nikolaus A. Adams},
  title = {{Investigation of condensation shocks and re-entrant jet dynamics in a cavitating nozzle flow by Large-Eddy Simulation}},
  journal = {International Journal of Multiphase Flow},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ijmultiphaseflow.2020.103215},
}
Figure