Abstract: After drawbacks and shortages of using conventional kV or MV imaging mode were analyzed, this study proposes a new position verification mode with using the energy larger than 15 MeV or nominal accelerating potential greater than 25 MV X-Ray. The new position verification mode is named HMV imaging mode. Along with the comparison of theoretical analyses, phantom experiments and clinical results to the original imaging modes, this report is going to demonstrate the HMV imaging mode is superior to traditional kV and MV imaging modes. This report first theoretically analyzed three main effects of X-ray interacting with medium by numerous equations and compared their mass attenuation coefficient with different types of tissue. X-ray irradiated on a “Catphan 500” cylinder phantom with different energies to verify these theoretical results. Furthermore, based on phantom experiments’ results, we have done numerous clinical trials and comparisons with patient’s clinical results. The theoretical and experimental results illustrate that the scanned images from HMV mode have a good quality and have ability to identify different tissue components clearly. HMV imaging mode overcomes drawbacks of position verification from both kV and MV level imaging mode as well as keeping advantages of kV and MV imaging mode. The result indicates that HMV is a good position verification mode in radiotherapy.
Introduction: The Precision Dilemma in Radiotherapy
In modern radiotherapy, the ability to accurately target tumors while sparing healthy surrounding tissue is paramount. Image-Guided Radiotherapy (IGRT) is the standard for verifying patient positioning before treatment. Currently, clinicians rely on two primary imaging modalities: Kilovoltage (kV) and Megavoltage (MV) imaging.
While kV imaging (60–120 kV) offers superior soft-tissue contrast, it necessitates the installation of secondary X-ray generators and detectors. This additional hardware increases mechanical complexity, cost, and the risk of mechanical failure. Conversely, standard MV imaging (4–15 MV) utilizes the treatment beam itself, requiring no extra hardware. However, at these energy levels, the Compton Effect dominates, resulting in poor image contrast that makes it difficult to distinguish between different tissue types like bone and muscle.
Methodology: Harnessing the Electronic Pair Effect
This study proposes a "High Megavoltage" (HMV) imaging mode using X-ray energies exceeding 15 MeV (or nominal potentials greater than 25 MV). The core innovation lies in leveraging the Electronic Pair Effect (EPE). Unlike the Compton Effect, which is largely independent of a tissue's atomic number ($Z$), the EPE is proportional to $Z$ and $Z^2$. By operating in the HMV range, the imaging system regains sensitivity to the chemical composition of tissues, potentially offering kV-like contrast using the MV treatment hardware.
The researchers tested this hypothesis using a specialized LA45 linear accelerator capable of producing 10 MV, 25 MV, and 45 MV beams. Images were captured using a PekinElmer amorphous silicon flat-panel detector. Validation was performed using a "Catphan 500" cylinder phantom—containing modules of varying densities—and clinical abdominal images from a patient.
Results and Discussion
The experimental results confirmed that HMV imaging (specifically at 45 MV) significantly outperforms standard MV imaging.
- Phantom Studies: In the Catphan 500 phantom, the HMV mode successfully identified material modules that appeared indistinguishable at 10 MV and 25 MV.
- Clinical Application: Abdominal images captured at 45 MV provided clear anatomical landmarks, approaching the quality of dedicated kV systems while maintaining the hardware simplicity of MV imaging.
By utilizing the treatment beam's hardware, HMV imaging also eliminates the "isocenter shift" problem—a common issue where the imaging and treatment beams are not perfectly aligned in dual-source systems.
Conclusion
The HMV imaging mode represents a promising "Goldilocks" solution for IGRT, combining the high contrast of kV imaging with the hardware efficiency and isocenter accuracy of MV imaging. While widespread adoption requires specialized high-energy accelerators and optimized detector sensitivity, HMV imaging demonstrates clear potential to simplify and improve position verification in radiotherapy.
Summary updated