Investigating the Influence of Interaction on Learning Persistence in Online Settings: Moderation or Mediation of Academic Emotions?

Jianhui Yu, Changqin Huang, Zhongmei Han, Tao He, Ming LiInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different types of student interaction in online learning environments influence learning persistence, with a specific focus on the roles of academic emotions (enjoyment, anxiety, and boredom) as either mediators or moderators. The findings reveal that while interaction is crucial, academic emotions significantly shape this relationship, offering insights into how to better support students in online courses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Online learning has become increasingly prevalent, but it often struggles with low student persistence – meaning students drop out or fail to complete their courses. While it's understood that student interaction (with peers, instructors, and content) and academic emotions (feelings like enjoyment or anxiety) are important for learning, there's a gap in understanding precisely how these factors interact to affect whether students stick with their online studies. This paper aims to bridge that gap by examining the complex interplay between three types of student interaction and three key academic emotions, and their combined influence on learning persistence.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using structural equation modeling (SEM) and hierarchical regression analysis.

  • SEM: Used to test the mediating effects of academic emotions. This involves analyzing how interaction influences emotions, and how those emotions, in turn, influence learning persistence.
  • Hierarchical Regression: Used to examine the moderating effects of academic emotions. This involves testing whether academic emotions change the strength or direction of the relationship between student interaction and learning persistence.

The study also involved a confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) to validate the measurement models for interaction, academic emotions, and learning persistence.

Datasets

The study collected data from 339 students who had prior online learning experience in China. The data was gathered using self-report questionnaires. No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced; existing, validated scales were adapted and used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Emotions are not just a byproduct, they're a mechanism: The study highlights that academic emotions aren't just passive responses to online learning; they actively shape how student interaction translates into persistence.
  • Different emotions, different roles: Enjoyment, anxiety, and boredom don't behave the same way. Enjoyment seems to be a positive force, while anxiety and boredom can be detrimental, but their specific impact depends on whether they're mediating or moderating.
  • Interaction alone isn't enough: Simply having students interact isn't a guaranteed path to persistence. The quality and emotional context of that interaction are critical.
  • Context matters for moderation: The moderating effects of emotions were not uniform across all types of interaction. For example, enjoyment significantly moderated the relationship between student-instructor interaction and persistence, but not student-student or student-content interaction.

Key Results

  • Direct Effects: All three types of student interaction (SS, SI, SC) and academic emotions (enjoyment, anxiety, boredom) were found to be directly related to learning persistence.
  • Mediating Effects:
    • Enjoyment: Partially mediated the relationship between SS and SC interaction and learning persistence.
  • Boredom: Partially mediated the relationship between SC interaction and learning persistence.
  • Anxiety: Did not show significant mediating effects in this study, suggesting it didn't act as a bridge between interaction and persistence in the way enjoyment and boredom did.
  • Moderating Effects:
    • Enjoyment: Significantly moderated the relationship between SI interaction and learning persistence. Students with high enjoyment and high SI interaction showed the highest persistence.
  • Anxiety: Significantly moderated the relationship between SS and SI interaction and learning persistence. Lower anxiety was associated with higher persistence, especially when combined with higher interaction.
  • Boredom: Significantly moderated the relationship between SS interaction and learning persistence. High boredom, particularly with low SS interaction, led to lower persistence.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-sectional Design: The study used a cross-sectional design, meaning it captured data at a single point in time. This limits the ability to establish definitive causal relationships. Future research should consider experimental designs or longitudinal studies to explore causality.
  • Sample Size and Generalizability: While 339 participants is a reasonable sample, the authors note that a larger sample could increase statistical power. The generalization of findings might also be limited as the sample was drawn from specific universities, majors, and learning subjects. Future studies could benefit from more diverse samples or hierarchical data analysis.
  • Self-Report Bias: The reliance on self-report instruments for data collection could introduce same-source bias. Future research could incorporate other methods like interviews, open-ended questionnaires, or physiological data (e.g., biofeedback) to triangulate findings.
  • Interaction Equivalency Theorem: The authors suggest that for SC interaction, if learning is not negatively impacted and other interaction types are high, SC interaction might be less critical. This could explain why academic emotions had a slighter moderating effect on SC interaction.

The authors suggest future research should consider the joint relationship between academic emotions and student interaction, and explore diverse implications tailored to specific emotions. They also emphasize the importance of providing interactional support and fostering a sense of online community to enhance persistence.

Summary updated

Abstract

Learning persistence is a critical element for successful online learning. The evidence provided by psychologists and educators has shown that students' interaction (student-student (SS) interaction, student-instructor (SI) interaction, and student-content (SC) interaction) significantly affects their learning persistence, which is also related to their academic emotions. However, few studies explore the relations among students' interaction, academic emotions and learning persistence in online learning environments. Furthermore, no research has focused on multi-dimensional students' interaction and specific academic emotions. Based on person-environment interaction model and transactional distance theory, this study investigates the relationship between students' interaction and learning persistence from the perspective of moderation and mediation of academic emotions including enjoyment, boredom, and anxiety. Data were collected from 339 students who had online learning experience in China. AMOS 22.0 (IBM, Armonk, NY, USA) and SPSS 22.0 (IBM, Armonk, NY, USA) were employed to analyze the mediating and moderating effects of academic emotions, respectively. The results revealed that students' interaction and academic emotions directly related to learning persistence. Specifically, enjoyment, anxiety and boredom had significant mediating and moderating effects on the relationship between students' interaction and learning persistence. Based on these findings, we further discussed the theoretical and practical implications on how to facilitate students' learning persistence in online learning environments.
BibTeX
@article{yu2020investigating,
  author = {Jianhui Yu and Changqin Huang and Zhongmei Han and Tao He and Ming Li},
  title = {{Investigating the Influence of Interaction on Learning Persistence in Online Settings: Moderation or Mediation of Academic Emotions?}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph17072320},
}
Figure