Investigating the Influence of Counterflow Regions on the Hydrodynamic Performance of Biomimetic Robotic Fish

Yanling Gong, Ming Wang, Qianchuan Zhao, Ruilong Wang, Lingchen Zuo, Xuehan Zheng, He GaoBiomimetics 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how countercurrent water flow affects the swimming efficiency of biomimetic robotic fish. Using computational fluid dynamics (CFD), the study reveals that countercurrents can surprisingly enhance propulsion at specific tail-beat frequencies by optimizing vortex dynamics, offering insights for more efficient underwater robot design.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Underwater exploration and monitoring are increasingly reliant on agile and efficient robotic systems. Biomimetic robotic fish offer a promising solution due to their potential for quiet, maneuverable, and energy-efficient locomotion, mimicking natural fish. However, a significant knowledge gap exists in understanding how these robots perform in complex aquatic environments, particularly in the presence of countercurrents. While it's known that fish can leverage vortices for propulsion, how robotic fish interact with and benefit from these flow dynamics in opposing currents remains largely unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by analyzing the hydrodynamic performance of a biomimetic robotic fish in both still water and countercurrent conditions, focusing on the influence of tail-beat frequency on propulsion efficiency and the underlying flow mechanisms.

Methods

The researchers developed a biomimetic robotic fish model capable of self-propelled motion, driven by a user-defined function (UDF). To analyze its performance, they employed Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations using ANSYS Fluent. A key aspect of their methodology was the development and refinement of a kinematic model for the robotic fish's tail movement. Initially based on Lighthill's model, it was iteratively improved to better represent the nuances of fish swimming, including accounting for head bobbing and enabling a gradual start from rest.

For the simulations, a 3D model of the robotic fish was created and placed in a computational domain representing both still water and countercurrent conditions (with a flow velocity of 0.05 m/s). They utilized the SST k-ω turbulence model for its balance of accuracy and computational efficiency. The study systematically varied the tail-beat frequency (1.0 Hz, 2.0 Hz, 3.0 Hz, and 4.0 Hz) and analyzed various hydrodynamic coefficients, including thrust, drag, and lateral fluctuation power. Crucially, they used isovorticity maps and Q-criterion isosurfaces to visualize and analyze the wake vortex structures, particularly the "reverse Kármán vortex street" generated by the robotic fish, to understand the underlying propulsion mechanisms. Propulsive efficiency was quantified using Froude efficiency.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations rather than experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Countercurrents aren't always a hindrance: Contrary to intuition, countercurrents can actually improve the propulsive efficiency of the robotic fish under specific tail-beat frequencies. This suggests that robotic fish can be designed to actively exploit these flow conditions.
  • Vorticity is key: The formation and dynamics of the "reverse Kármán vortex street" generated by the fish's tail are central to its propulsion. The study visualizes how these vortices interact with the flow and contribute to thrust.
  • Frequency matters, but not linearly: The relationship between tail-beat frequency and propulsion efficiency is complex. While higher frequencies generally lead to faster acceleration, peak efficiency doesn't always align with the highest frequency, especially in countercurrents.
  • Optimizing vortex structure: The study identified that a specific tail-beat frequency (3 Hz in this case) in countercurrent water resulted in an optimal vortex street configuration (maximized longitudinal spacing, minimized transverse spacing), leading to the highest observed Froude efficiency.
  • Harnessing water power: The robotic fish can enhance its propulsive speed by effectively harnessing the energy from the water, particularly in countercurrent environments.

Key Results

  • Reduced speed in countercurrents: In general, the swimming speed of the robotic fish decreased in countercurrent conditions compared to still water across all tested frequencies.
  • Peak efficiency at 2.0 Hz and 3.0 Hz: Froude efficiency analyses showed peak performance at tail-beat frequencies of 2.0 Hz and 3.0 Hz in still water.
  • Augmented efficiency at 3.0 Hz in countercurrents: Notably, at a tail-beat frequency of 3.0 Hz, the propulsive efficiency was marginally augmented even in the presence of countercurrent flow.
  • Vortex street evolution: The vortex street spread more rapidly with increasing tail-beat frequency. At 1 Hz, it formed compact leading and trailing vortices, while at 4 Hz, it dispersed into two wider vortex streets.
  • Countercurrent vortex dynamics: In countercurrents, the transverse fluctuation frequency tended to diminish, contributing to enhanced Froude efficiency. At 3 Hz in countercurrents, the longitudinal vortex spacing (Lf) was maximized, and the transverse spacing (af) was minimized, correlating with superior propulsion.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Model Simplification: The robotic fish model was simplified for computational speed. Future work should incorporate more detailed factors like pectoral fins, and the influence of the fish's shape, size, and material properties on hydrodynamic coefficients.
  • Computational Cost: Numerical simulations, while powerful, are computationally expensive, limiting the number of scenarios that can be simulated.
  • Experimental Validation: While the study presents a robust numerical framework, direct experimental validation of the findings would strengthen the conclusions.
  • Advanced Modeling: The authors propose developing large-scale predictive models using deep learning techniques to reduce computational costs and improve accuracy.
  • Broader Factors: Future research should investigate other factors influencing hydrodynamic coefficients beyond tail-beat frequency and water flow velocity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Biomimetic robotic fish are a novel approach to studying quiet, highly agile, and efficient underwater propulsion systems, attracting significant interest from experts in robotics and engineering. These versatile robots showcase their ability to operate effectively in various water conditions. Nevertheless, the comprehension of the swimming mechanics and the evolution of the flow field of flexible robots in counterflow regions is still unknown. This paper presents a framework for the self-propulsion of robotic fish that imitates biological characteristics. The method utilizes computational fluid dynamics to analyze the hydrodynamic efficiency of the organisms at different frequencies of tail movement, under both still and opposing flow circumstances. Moreover, this study clarifies the mechanisms that explain how changes in the aquatic environment affect the speed and efficiency of propulsion. It also examines the most effective swimming tactics for places with counterflow. The results suggest that the propulsion effectiveness of robotic fish in counterflow locations does not consistently correspond to various tail-beat frequencies. By utilizing vorticity maps, a comparative analysis can identify situations when counterflow zones improve the efficiency of propulsion.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gong2024investigating,
  author = {Yanling Gong and Ming Wang and Qianchuan Zhao and Ruilong Wang and Lingchen Zuo and Xuehan Zheng and He Gao},
  title = {{Investigating the Influence of Counterflow Regions on the Hydrodynamic Performance of Biomimetic Robotic Fish}},
  booktitle = {Biomimetics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/biomimetics9080452},
}
Figure