Investigating the crowding effect of FDI on domestic investments: Evidence from Bangladesh

A. Q. Guo, Sayed Farrukh Ahmed, A. K. M. Mohsin, Arifur Rahman, Shamsul Nahar Abdullah, Choo Wou Onn, Mohammad Saiyedul IslamHeliyon 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates whether Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) "crowds in" or "crowds out" domestic investment in Bangladesh. Using time-series data from 1972-2022 and advanced econometric techniques, the research finds that FDI positively influences domestic investment in both the short and long run, suggesting a "crowding-in" effect. This has important implications for policymakers aiming to stimulate economic growth through investment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For developing economies like Bangladesh, attracting Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is crucial for economic growth, job creation, and technology transfer. However, a key question is how FDI impacts domestic investment. Does it stimulate local businesses (crowding-in) or displace them, leading to reduced domestic investment (crowding-out)? While this debate has been explored globally, the specific dynamics of this relationship in Bangladesh remained under-researched. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing empirical evidence on whether FDI in Bangladesh encourages or hinders domestic investment, offering crucial insights for effective policy formulation.

Methods

The study employs a rigorous econometric approach to analyze the relationship between FDI and domestic investment in Bangladesh.

  1. Unit Root Tests: To ensure the reliability of time-series data, the researchers first conducted unit root tests (ADF, PP) to check for stationarity. They specifically addressed potential structural breaks in the data using the ZA and LP unit root tests, which are more robust to such changes.
  2. Cointegration Analysis: After confirming that the variables were integrated of the same order (I(1)), the Johansen cointegration test was used to determine if a long-run equilibrium relationship exists between real GDP (RGDP), real foreign direct investment (RFDI), and real gross capital formation (RGCF).
  3. Vector Error Correction Model (VECM): If cointegration was established, a VECM was estimated. This model is suitable for analyzing the short-run dynamics and long-run adjustments of cointegrated variables, allowing for the estimation of both short-term and long-term effects.
  4. Crowding Effect Calculation: Finally, specific formulas were applied to the VECM results to quantify the magnitude of the crowding effect (CE) of FDI on domestic investment. This involved calculating the CE for both the long and short run.

Datasets

The study utilizes annual time-series data for Bangladesh from 1972 to 2022. The data was sourced from the World Development Indicators (WDI) [40]. The variables analyzed are:

  • RGDP: Real Gross Domestic Product (constant 2015 US$)
  • RFDI: Real Foreign Direct Investment net inflows as a ratio to Gross Domestic Product. This was adjusted to real values using the GDP deflator (2015=100).
  • RGCF: Ratio of Real Gross Capital Formation to Real Gross Domestic Product, used as a proxy for total domestic investment.

All variables were logarithmically transformed, and the Inverse Hyperbolic Sine (IHS) transformation was applied to RFDI to handle negative observations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bangladesh's FDI Landscape: Despite fluctuations, Bangladesh has consistently attracted FDI, with significant increases observed between 2009-2015. However, a notable decrease occurred after 2015, prompting policy efforts to attract more investment.
  • The "Crowding-In" Hypothesis: The study's core insight is that FDI in Bangladesh appears to stimulate, rather than displace, domestic investment. This suggests that foreign capital and expertise are contributing positively to the local investment environment.
  • Technological Spillovers as a Driver: A potential explanation for the crowding-in effect is the transfer of advanced technology and operational practices from foreign firms to domestic ones. This can enhance the productivity and competitiveness of local businesses.
  • Policy Relevance: The findings provide actionable insights for policymakers, emphasizing the need for strategies that foster collaboration between foreign and domestic firms, facilitate technology transfer, and strengthen local supply chains.

Key Results

  • Long-Run Crowding Effect: The magnitude of the crowding effect (CE) in the long run was found to be 25.73. This value, significantly greater than 1, indicates a strong crowding-in effect of FDI on domestic investments in Bangladesh.
  • Short-Run Crowding Effect: The magnitude of the crowding effect (CE) in the short run was 61.15. This also signifies a substantial crowding-in effect, suggesting that FDI's positive impact on domestic investment is evident immediately.
  • Cointegration: The Johansen cointegration test confirmed a long-run equilibrium relationship among LRGDP, LRFDI, and LRGCF, meaning these variables tend to move together over time.
  • Stationarity: Unit root tests confirmed that LRGDP and LRFDI are non-stationary at the level but stationary at the first difference (I(1)), while LRGCF is stationary at the level (I(0)). This is a standard prerequisite for VECM analysis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study utilized data up to 2022. The authors suggest that incorporating more recent data could provide a more contemporary perspective on FDI's impact.
  • Variable Inclusion: Future research could benefit from including additional supplementary variables to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the interplay between FDI and domestic investment.
  • Study Duration: Expanding the study duration could also yield deeper insights into long-term trends and relationships.
  • Policy Implications: The paper strongly advocates for policymakers to develop strategies that leverage FDI's crowding-in effect, focusing on collaboration, technology transfer, and strengthening local industries to foster sustainable economic development.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study empirically investigates the crowding effect of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) on domestic investments in Bangladesh, utilizing annual time series data from 1972 to 2022. Initially, unit root tests are conducted with and without considering structural breaks in the dataset. This study employs the Johansen test of cointegration to investigate the enduring association between the variables and utilizes the Vector Error Correction Model (VECM) to accommodate this relationship over the long term. Following the estimation of the VECM, formulas about the magnitude of the crowding effect (CE) are applied to examine the impact of FDI on domestic investment in Bangladesh. Results indicate that FDI positively influences domestic investments in both the short and long run.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2024investigating,
  author = {A. Q. Guo and Sayed Farrukh Ahmed and A. K. M. Mohsin and Arifur Rahman and Shamsul Nahar Abdullah and Choo Wou Onn and Mohammad Saiyedul Islam},
  title = {{Investigating the crowding effect of FDI on domestic investments: Evidence from Bangladesh}},
  booktitle = {Heliyon},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e31092},
}
Figure