Investigating the Blazar TXS 0506+056 through Sharp Multiwavelength Eyes During 2017–2019

V. A. Acciari, T. Aniello, Stefano Ansoldi, L. A. Antonelli, A. Arbet Engels, Manuel Artero, Katsuaki Asano, Dominik Baack, A. Babić, Andrés Baquero, U. Barres de Almeida, J. A. Barrio, Ivana Batković, J. Becerra González, W. Bednarek, E. Bernardini, M. Bernardos, A. Berti, Jürgen Besenrieder, W. Bhattacharyya, C. Bigongiari, A. Biland, O. Blanch, Hendrik Bökenkamp, G. Bonnoli, Ž. Bošnjak, G. Busetto, R. Carosi, G. Ceribella, M. Cerruti, Yating Chai, A. Chilingarian, S. Cikota, E. Colombo, J. L. Contreras, J. Cortina, S. Covino, Giacomo D’Amico, V. D’Elia, P. Da Vela, F. Dazzi, A. De Angelis, B. De Lotto, Antonino Del Popolo, M. Delfino, J. Delgado, C. Delgado Mendez, Davide Depaoli, F. Di Pierro, L. Di Venere, E. Do Souto Espiñeira, D. Dominis Prester, Alice Donini, D. Dorner, M. Doro, D. Elsäesser, V. Fallah Ramazanı, L. Fariña, Alicia Fattorini, L. Font, C. Fruck, Satoshi Fukami, Y. Fukazawa, M. D. Caballero‐García, M. Garczarczyk, Sargis Gasparyan, M. Gaug, N. Giglietto, F. Giordano, Paweł Gliwny, N. Godinović, Jarred Gershon Green, D. Green, D. Hadasch, A. Hahn, T. Hassan, Lea Heckmann, J. Herrera, John Hoang, Dario Hrupec, Moritz Hütten, Tomohiro Inada, Roman Iotov, Kazuma Ishio, Y. Iwamura, Irene Jiménez Martínez, Jenni Jormanainen, L. Jouvin, D. Kerszberg, Yukiho Kobayashi, H. Kubo, J. Kushida, A. Lamastra, A. La Barbera, F. Leone, E. Lindfors, Lena Linhoff, S. Lombardi, F. Longo, R. López-CotoThe Astrophysical Journal 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive multi-wavelength study of the blazar TXS 0506+056, following its association with a high-energy neutrino event. By analyzing data from radio to very-high-energy gamma rays, the study reveals distinct variability patterns across different energy bands and proposes a lepto-hadronic model to explain the observed emissions, including the potential for neutrino production.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The discovery of a high-energy neutrino (IceCube-170922A) associated with a gamma-ray flare from the blazar TXS 0506+056 in 2017 marked a significant moment in multi-messenger astrophysics. This event suggested that blazars could be powerful accelerators of cosmic rays, producing both photons and neutrinos. However, TXS 0506+056 was poorly understood before this event. The problem this paper addresses is to characterize the broadband emission of TXS 0506+056 during a subsequent period (2017-2019) to better understand its physical processes, particularly the mechanisms responsible for producing both photons and neutrinos, and to test theoretical models of blazar emission. A key challenge is to reconcile the observed photon emission with potential neutrino production, especially considering previous neutrino-only flares that lacked corresponding photon activity.

Methods

The study employed a broad multi-wavelength observational campaign, collecting data from November 2017 to February 2019. This involved:

  • Very-High-Energy (VHE) Gamma Rays: Observations using the MAGIC (Major Atmospheric Gamma-ray Imaging Cherenkov) telescopes.
  • High-Energy (HE) Gamma Rays: Analysis of data from the Fermi Large Area Telescope (LAT).
  • X-rays: Observations from Swift/XRT and NuSTAR telescopes.
  • Optical/UV: Data from Swift/UVOT, ASAS-SN, KVA, and REM telescopes.
  • Radio: Monitoring by the Metsähovi (37 GHz) and OVRO (15 GHz) radio telescopes.

The data analysis involved standard techniques for each instrument, including spectral fitting and light curve generation. A key methodological aspect was the development and application of a lepto-hadronic model. This model aims to explain the observed spectral energy distributions (SEDs) by considering both leptonic (e.g., synchrotron, inverse-Compton) and hadronic (e.g., Bethe-Heitler pair cascade, pion decay) emission processes. The model was iteratively refined to match the observed data and predict neutrino emission rates. Variability was quantified using the fractional variability parameter ($F_{var}$). Spectral variability was investigated by studying the correlation between photon flux and photon index.

Datasets

The study utilized observational data from the following instruments and projects:

  • MAGIC: Very-High-Energy gamma-ray data.
  • Fermi/LAT: High-Energy gamma-ray data.
  • Swift/XRT: X-ray data.
  • NuSTAR: X-ray data.
  • Swift/UVOT: UV and optical data.
  • ASAS-SN: Optical data.
  • KVA: Optical data.
  • REM: Optical data.
  • Metsähovi Radio Observatory: Radio data (37 GHz).
  • OVRO: Radio data (15 GHz).

The study also references and compares its findings with previously published IceCube neutrino data and other multi-wavelength observations of TXS 0506+056. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Distinct Variability Across Energy Bands: The study highlights that TXS 0506+056 exhibits different variability behaviors in different energy ranges. While gamma rays showed a significant flare in December 2018 (similar to the 2017 event), the radio band showed a consistent, long-term brightening uncorrelated with other wavelengths.
  • Lepto-Hadronic Model as a Viable Explanation: The authors successfully modeled the multi-wavelength SEDs using a lepto-hadronic scenario, suggesting that both leptonic and hadronic processes are crucial for explaining the observed emissions, particularly the X-ray and VHE gamma-ray fluxes.
  • Hadronic Emission in X-rays and VHE Gamma Rays: The model specifically proposes that hadronic processes, such as Bethe-Heitler and pion-decay cascades, are responsible for the emission in the X-ray and VHE gamma-ray bands.
  • Neutrino Emission Tied to Flares: The modeling suggests that neutrino emission is likely associated with flaring activity, and that the December 2018 gamma-ray flare might have produced a neutrino signal too brief and faint to be detected by current instruments.
  • Spectral Variability in X-rays: A notable finding is the spectral variability in the soft X-ray band (2-10 keV), showing a "harder-when-brighter" trend, which is interpreted as a transition between different radiation mechanisms.

Key Results

  • VHE Gamma-Ray Flare: A significant VHE gamma-ray flare was observed in December 2018, similar in flux and day-scale variability to the October 2017 flare.
  • Low VHE Gamma-Ray State: For most of the campaign, TXS 0506+056 was in a low state in VHE gamma rays, with an average flux of (2.7 ± 2.1) × 10⁻¹¹ cm⁻² s⁻¹, representing the lowest observed level.
  • Radio Brightening: The radio light curves (15 and 37 GHz) showed a consistent increase in flux over the campaign, a trend not observed at higher energies.
  • Lepto-Hadronic Model Fit: The proposed lepto-hadronic model provided a good description of the SEDs for both the low-state and the December 2018 high-state.
  • Neutrino Rate Prediction: The model predicted a low-state neutrino rate of 0.14 neutrinos per year for IceCube, consistent with previous estimates, and a very brief, undetectable neutrino signal for the December 2018 flare.
  • Variability ($F_{var}$): The highest variability ($F_{var}$ ~0.40) was observed in the Fermi/LAT gamma-ray band, while X-ray and optical/UV bands showed moderate variability (0.15-0.25).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Dependence: The authors acknowledge that the lepto-hadronic model is "very model-dependent," and other solutions could exist by varying different parameters.
  • Lack of Simultaneous Low-Energy Data for Flares: The December 2018 VHE flare lacked simultaneous observations at lower energies (optical/UV/X-ray), which limits the ability to fully constrain the model for this specific event. Future observations are needed to characterize the synchrotron component during flares.
  • Future Observations: The paper emphasizes the need for future multi-wavelength and multi-messenger observations to fully understand the source's duty cycle, variability properties, and the role of AGNs as cosmic ray and neutrino sources. Specifically, characterizing the synchrotron emission during flares is highlighted as crucial.
  • Neutrino Detection: While the model predicts neutrino emission, the current instruments may not be sensitive enough to detect the brief or faint signals associated with some flares. Future, more sensitive neutrino detectors are implied as necessary for further validation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The blazar TXS 0506+056 got into the spotlight of the astrophysical community in 2017 September, when a high-energy neutrino detected by IceCube (IceCube-170922A) was associated at the 3 σ level with a γ -ray flare from this source. This multi-messenger photon-neutrino association remains, as per today, the most significant association ever observed. TXS 0506+056 was a poorly studied object before the IceCube-170922A event. To better characterize its broadband emission, we organized a multiwavelength campaign lasting 16 months (2017 November to 2019 February), covering the radio band (Metsähovi, OVRO), the optical/UV (ASAS-SN, KVA, REM, Swift/UVOT), the X-rays (Swift/XRT, NuSTAR), the high-energy γ rays (Fermi/LAT), and the very high-energy (VHE) γ rays (MAGIC). In γ rays, the behavior of the source was significantly different from the behavior in 2017: MAGIC observations show the presence of flaring activity during 2018 December, while the source only shows an excess at the 4 σ level during the rest of the campaign (74 hr of accumulated exposure); Fermi/LAT observations show several short (on a timescale of days to a week) flares, different from the long-term brightening of 2017. No significant flares are detected at lower energies. The radio light curve shows an increasing flux trend that is not seen in other wavelengths. We model the multiwavelength spectral energy distributions in a lepto-hadronic scenario, in which the hadronic emission emerges as Bethe-Heitler and pion-decay cascade in the X-rays and VHE γ rays. According to the model presented here, the 2018 December γ -ray flare was connected to a neutrino emission that was too brief and not bright enough to be detected by current neutrino instruments.
BibTeX
@article{acciari2022investigating,
  author = {V. A. Acciari and T. Aniello and Stefano Ansoldi and L. A. Antonelli and A. Arbet Engels and Manuel Artero and Katsuaki Asano and Dominik Baack and A. Babić and Andrés Baquero and U. Barres de Almeida and J. A. Barrio and Ivana Batković and J. Becerra González and W. Bednarek and E. Bernardini and M. Bernardos and A. Berti and Jürgen Besenrieder and W. Bhattacharyya and C. Bigongiari and A. Biland and O. Blanch and Hendrik Bökenkamp and G. Bonnoli and Ž. Bošnjak and G. Busetto and R. Carosi and G. Ceribella and M. Cerruti and Yating Chai and A. Chilingarian and S. Cikota and E. Colombo and J. L. Contreras and J. Cortina and S. Covino and Giacomo D’Amico and V. D’Elia and P. Da Vela and F. Dazzi and A. De Angelis and B. De Lotto and Antonino Del Popolo and M. Delfino and J. Delgado and C. Delgado Mendez and Davide Depaoli and F. Di Pierro and L. Di Venere and E. Do Souto Espiñeira and D. Dominis Prester and Alice Donini and D. Dorner and M. Doro and D. Elsäesser and V. Fallah Ramazanı and L. Fariña and Alicia Fattorini and L. Font and C. Fruck and Satoshi Fukami and Y. Fukazawa and M. D. Caballero‐García and M. Garczarczyk and Sargis Gasparyan and M. Gaug and N. Giglietto and F. Giordano and Paweł Gliwny and N. Godinović and Jarred Gershon Green and D. Green and D. Hadasch and A. Hahn and T. Hassan and Lea Heckmann and J. Herrera and John Hoang and Dario Hrupec and Moritz Hütten and Tomohiro Inada and Roman Iotov and Kazuma Ishio and Y. Iwamura and Irene Jiménez Martínez and Jenni Jormanainen and L. Jouvin and D. Kerszberg and Yukiho Kobayashi and H. Kubo and J. Kushida and A. Lamastra and A. La Barbera and F. Leone and E. Lindfors and Lena Linhoff and S. Lombardi and F. Longo and R. López-Coto},
  title = {{Investigating the Blazar TXS 0506+056 through Sharp Multiwavelength Eyes During 2017–2019}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ac531d},
}
Figure