Investigating state-of-the-art planning strategies for electric vehicle charging infrastructures in coupled transport and power networks: a comprehensive review

Jinhao Li, Arlena Chew, Hao WangProgress in Energy 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This comprehensive review examines the current state of electric vehicle charging infrastructure (EVCI) planning, highlighting significant challenges like inadequate services, low utilization, and grid integration issues. It provides a structured overview of stakeholders, charging technologies, and planning methodologies, identifying critical research gaps for future advancements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid global adoption of electric vehicles (EVs) is crucial for reducing greenhouse gas emissions and achieving net-zero targets. However, the rollout of necessary charging infrastructure (EVCI) is lagging behind EV uptake. This paper addresses the complex problem of planning EVCI by identifying and analyzing the key challenges, stakeholders, technologies, and methodologies involved. The core issue is that despite significant governmental efforts, progress is slower than anticipated due to three main impediments:

  1. Inadequate EVCI charging services: This includes issues like range anxiety and the inconvenience of finding available chargers.
  2. Low utilization rates of public EVCI facilities: Many public chargers are underutilized, impacting profitability and discouraging further investment.
  3. Non-trivial integration of EVCI into the electric grid: The increasing demand from EV charging can strain power grids, especially with the rise of renewables.

These challenges are further complicated by the diverse interests of stakeholders (EV drivers, transport operators, grid operators) and the variety of charging technologies available. The paper aims to provide a holistic understanding of the current landscape and pinpoint areas for future research to accelerate effective EVCI planning.

Methods

This paper is a comprehensive review, not a study proposing new methods. It systematically analyzes existing literature on EVCI planning. The review categorizes and discusses:

  • Stakeholder Analysis: Examining the distinct interests and roles of EV drivers, transport system operators, and electric grid operators.
  • Charging Technologies: Detailing Level 1, 2, and 3 charging technologies, their modes, types, and suitability for different geographical locations (residential, destination, en-route).
  • EVCI Planning Methodologies:
    • Node-based approaches: Focusing on placing charging stations at specific traffic nodes (e.g., Set Covering Location Model - SCLM, Maximum Covering Location Model - MCLM, p-median model).
  • Flow-based approaches: Positioning EVCIs along EV travel routes (e.g., Flow-Capturing Location Model - FCLM, Flow-Refueling Location Model - FRLM, Capacitated FRLM - CFRLM).
  • Addressing Key Challenges: Reviewing how existing studies tackle issues like capacity sizing, uncertain routing choices, and grid integration.
  • Coupled Network Planning: Analyzing strategies that consider both traffic and power distribution networks.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a literature review and does not present new empirical studies or datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Chicken-and-Egg" Dilemma: Inefficient EVCI planning creates a cycle where low charger utilization discourages investment, while limited charging availability deters EV adoption.
  • Stakeholder Conflicts: Balancing the needs of EV drivers (convenience, range), transport operators (cost, revenue), and grid operators (stability, cost) is a central challenge.
  • Geographic Nuances: The optimal charging technology and placement vary significantly by location (urban vs. rural, residential vs. commercial vs. highway).
  • Limitations of Static Models: Traditional node-based models often assume static charging demands and service distances, which don't reflect the dynamic nature of EV usage.
  • Grid Integration is Crucial: The increasing EV load poses significant challenges to grid stability, especially with the rise of intermittent renewable energy sources.
  • Future Focus on Dynamics: There's a clear need to move beyond historical data and incorporate dynamic, time-varying EV charging demand and integrate it with grid decarbonization efforts.

Key Results

The paper synthesizes findings from numerous studies, highlighting:

  • Global EVCI Practices: Reviews the efforts of major players like China, the US, and the EU, noting that progress is still slower than anticipated.
  • Identified Barriers: Quantifies issues like low utilization rates (e.g., 4-15% in some regions) and the significant gap between current charger deployment and projected needs (e.g., 6.2 million public chargers needed by 2030).
  • Methodological Landscape: Categorizes and compares various node-based and flow-based models, discussing their strengths and weaknesses.
  • Research Gaps: Pinpoints critical areas for future research, including dynamic demand modeling, coordination with grid decarbonization, optimal charger portfolios, capacity expansion strategies, and the perspective of private charging operators.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors explicitly identify several research gaps and call for further contributions:

  • Dynamic EV Charging Demand: Current models often rely on static or historical data. Future work should leverage machine learning and deep learning to predict dynamic, time-varying charging demand, enabling more efficient and cost-effective planning.
  • Coordinating Vehicle Electrification with Grid Decarbonization: There's a need to align EV charging with renewable energy generation to utilize abundant renewables and avoid reliance on fossil fuels for grid stability. Smart charging operations are key to this synergy.
  • Optimal Portfolio of Charging Technologies: Most studies focus on single charger types. Future research should explore comprehensive strategies for selecting and deploying diverse charger types (Level 1, 2, 3) in various locations to meet specific needs without excessive investment.
  • Capacity Expansion of Existing Charging Resources: Planning should not only focus on new infrastructure but also on optimizing the expansion of existing resources, considering future uncertainties like EV adoption rates and renewable energy integration.
  • EVCI Planning Strategies for Private Charging Station Operators: The perspective of profit-driven private operators is underrepresented. Research should address their siting, sizing, and expansion strategies to maximize profits and competition.

The paper concludes by emphasizing the need for continued research to ensure EVCI planning keeps pace with the evolving landscape of electric mobility.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Electric vehicles (EVs) have emerged as a pivotal solution to reduce greenhouse gas emissions paving a pathway to net zero. As the adoption of EVs continues to grow, countries are proactively formulating systematic plans for nationwide EV charging infrastructure (EVCI) to keep pace with the accelerating shift towards EVs. This comprehensive review aims to thoroughly examine current global practices in EVCI planning and explore state-of-the-art methodologies for designing EVCI planning strategies. Despite remarkable efforts by influential players in the global EV market, such as China, the United States, and the European Union, the progress in EVCI rollout has been notably slower than anticipated in the rest of the world. This delay can be attributable to three major impediments: inadequate EVCI charging services, low utilization rates of public EVCI facilities, and the non-trivial integration of EVCI into the electric grid. These challenges are intricately linked to key stakeholders in the EVCI planning problem within the context of coupled traffic and grid networks. These stakeholders include EV drivers, transport system operators, and electric grid operators. In addition, various applicable charging technologies further complicate this planning task. This review dissects the interests of these stakeholders, clarifying their respective roles and expectations in the context of EVCI planning. This review also provides insights into level 1, 2, and 3 chargers with explorations of their applications in different geographical locations for diverse EV charging patterns. Finally, a thorough review of node-based and flow-based approaches to EV planning is presented. The modeling of placing charging stations is broadly categorized into set coverage, maximum coverage, flow-capturing, and flow-refueling location models. In conclusion, this review identifies several research gaps, including the dynamic modeling of EV charging demand and the coordination of vehicle electrification with grid decarbonization. This paper calls for further contributions to bridge these gaps and drive the advancement of EVCI planning.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2024investigating,
  author = {Jinhao Li and Arlena Chew and Hao Wang},
  title = {{Investigating state-of-the-art planning strategies for electric vehicle charging infrastructures in coupled transport and power networks: a comprehensive review}},
  booktitle = {Progress in Energy},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1088/2516-1083/ad6be1},
}
Figure