Abstract
Magnetic clouds (MCs) are the interplanetary counterparts of coronal mass ejections (CMEs), and usually modeled by a flux rope. By assuming the quasi-steady evolution and self-similar expansion, we introduce three types of global motion into a cylindrical force-free flux rope model, and developed a new velocity-modified model for MCs. The three types of the global motion are the linear propagating motion away from the Sun, the expanding and the poloidal motion with respect to the axis of the MC. The model is applied to 72 MCs observed by Wind spacecraft to investigate the properties of the plasma motion of MCs. First, we find that some MCs had a significant propagation velocity perpendicular to the radial direction, suggesting the direct evidence of the CME's deflected propagation and/or rotation in interplanetary space. Second, we confirm the previous results that the expansion speed is correlated with the radial propagation speed and most MCs did not expand self-similarly at 1 AU. In our statistics, about 62%/17% of MCs underwent a under/over-expansion at 1 AU and the expansion rate is about 0.6 on average. Third, most interestingly, we find that a significant poloidal motion did exist in some MCs. Three speculations about the cause of the poloidal motion are therefore proposed. These findings advance our understanding of the MC's properties at 1 AU as well as the dynamic evolution of CMEs from the Sun to interplanetary space.
Introduction
Magnetic clouds (MCs) are large-scale magnetized plasma structures ejected from the Sun, serving as the interplanetary counterparts of coronal mass ejections (CMEs). Understanding their 3D structure and evolution is crucial for space weather forecasting. Traditionally, these structures are modeled as static or purely radially propagating flux ropes. However, this simplification neglects the complex internal dynamics—such as expansion, rotation, and non-radial deflection—that real MCs exhibit as they interact with the solar wind. By neglecting these velocity components, traditional models often produce inaccurate reconstructions of the cloud's orientation and size, which are critical for predicting impacts on Earth's magnetosphere.
The Velocity-Modified Model
To address these limitations, researchers developed a new "velocity-modified" model. Building upon the classic Lundquist force-free cylindrical flux rope, this model introduces a comprehensive velocity field defined by three primary components:
- Linear Propagation ($v_c$): A 3D vector representing the motion of the cloud's center, allowing for non-radial deflection.
- Expansion Motion ($v_e$): Radial expansion perpendicular to the cloud's axis.
- Poloidal Motion ($v_p$): Rotational motion or "swirl" around the cloud's axis.
The model utilizes 11 free parameters and employs a non-linear least-squares fitting algorithm (MPFIT) to simultaneously match both magnetic field ($B$) and velocity ($v$) vectors observed by spacecraft. This ensures the reconstructed physics honors both datasets, leading to more reliable geometric results.
Statistical Analysis and Results
The model was applied to 72 high-quality MC events identified by the Wind spacecraft (from the well-established Lepping list). The simultaneous fitting of velocity and magnetic data revealed several critical insights:
- Geometric Accuracy: Incorporating velocity data significantly altered the inferred orientation of the MC axis in approximately 40% of cases, with shifts exceeding 15°. This demonstrates that ignoring plasma motion leads to systematic errors in reconstructing the physical orientation of CMEs.
- Expansion Dynamics: The study confirmed that most MCs do not expand "self-similarly" (where expansion is proportional to distance from the Sun). Instead, 62% of the sampled clouds were found to be "under-expanding," with an average expansion rate of 0.6 rather than the theoretical 1.0.
- Discovery of Poloidal Motion: A significant finding was the detection of poloidal motion (rotation) in several MCs, averaging 10 km/s. This suggests that MCs retain or develop angular momentum, possibly due to solar wind interactions (viscosity), conversion of internal magnetic energy, or residual rotation from the initial solar eruption (kinking).
- Deflection Evidence: Some MCs exhibited propagation velocities significantly deviated from the radial direction, providing direct in-situ evidence of CME deflection or rotation in interplanetary space.
Discussion and Limitations
While the velocity-modified model provides a more realistic reconstruction than static models, it still relies on several simplifications. The model assumes cylindrical symmetry, whereas real MCs may be distorted into elliptical "pancake" shapes by solar wind pressure. Additionally, it assumes a quasi-steady evolution during the spacecraft's passage, which may not hold for highly dynamic events.
Future research will focus on applying this model to multi-spacecraft data from missions like Solar Orbiter and Parker Solar Probe. Tracking how these velocity components evolve as CMEs propagate through the heliosphere will further refine our ability to predict their impact on the terrestrial environment.
Summary updated